Prison Isolation Would Face Tighter Limits

Summary#

HB 35, “Restorative housing and isolated confinement; restrictions on use,” would amend and reenact a section of the Code of Virginia. Its stated aim is to restrict when and how state correctional facilities use restorative housing and isolated confinement. The supplied status says it passed the House, but the supplied text is a proposed Senate substitute; it is not shown as law.

  • A person could be placed in restorative housing or isolated confinement only for specified reasons, including the person’s informed voluntary request, protection, medical isolation, an imminent threat of physical harm, or a substantial threat to safe facility operations that cannot be addressed in a less restrictive setting.
  • Placements would generally be limited to 15 consecutive days, including investigative time, and 15 days total in a 60-day period. The text sets exceptions and conditions, including a limited additional period after new misconduct that creates an imminent threat.
  • Facilities would have to document placements, provide medical and mental health evaluations, review placements, and make transition plans. The supplied text gives conflicting review intervals.
  • People in restorative housing, isolated confinement, or another population without full privileges would generally have to be offered at least four hours a day of out-of-cell programming or other congregate activities, subject to a safety exception.
  • Lockdowns that interrupt those activities would have to serve a specific, necessary security purpose, be documented, and end when that purpose is served. Longer or repeated lockdowns would require regional approval, and documentation would be published.
  • The Director would have to develop policies and procedures. Facility administrators would have to maintain a publicly available transition policy, subject to the Director’s approval.

What it means for you#

  • People in state correctional facilities: The bill would limit the reasons and duration for restrictive placement. It would also provide for evaluations, placement reviews, opportunities to contest some removals, and a way to refuse continued protective isolation. A person who refuses would have to be given safe placement outside isolation within 48 hours.
  • People seeking protection: Before placing someone in restrictive housing for their own protection, the facility administrator would have to use a less restrictive setting unless no such setting would be sufficient or practicable for safety. Protective-custody settings that do not count as restorative housing would still be allowed.
  • Facility administrators and the Department of Corrections: They would have to document decisions, arrange evaluations and reviews, create transition plans and policies, and meet activity and lockdown rules.
  • People outside state correctional facilities: The bill does not directly change rules for local jails or create a new public service, benefit, or tax.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill assigns work involving evaluations, reviews, documentation, programming, and policies, but provides no staffing estimate, cost estimate, or appropriation. These duties may require staff time; the amount is unknown.
  • No fees, fines, or changes to taxes are stated.

What is unclear#

  • The current text of the amended Code section was not supplied, so the exact changes from current law could not be verified.
  • The placement-review wording says both “once a week” and “every two business days.” The supplied text does not make the required interval clear.
  • The text does not define “informed voluntary consent” or explain how facilities must decide whether consent is informed and voluntary.
  • The exceptions to the 15-day limits, and how they work together, are not fully clear from the supplied wording.
  • The text does not specify the staffing, funding, or detailed procedures for reviews, appeals, and required activities.
  • The supplied materials do not show an effective date or confirm the bill’s final status.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to reduce extended isolation and require facilities to justify restrictive placements.
  • Requiring less restrictive options for people seeking protection could limit isolation when another safe placement is available.
  • Evaluations, written reasons, review opportunities, and transition plans could make placements easier to track and challenge.
  • Limits and approval rules for lockdowns could make extended interruptions to programs less routine and more accountable.

Case against#

  • One concern is that the bill creates many duties—evaluations, reviews, programming, records, and approvals—without stating how they will be staffed or paid for.
  • The unclear review interval and other wording problems could make it hard for facilities and incarcerated people to know exactly what the rules require.
  • The bill allows exceptions for safety, protection, and medical isolation, but the supplied text leaves some details of those exceptions and their interaction with the time limits unclear.
  • A possible trade-off is that limits on restrictive housing and lockdowns may be difficult to apply when facility safety risks are serious; the bill does not explain how disputes over those risks would be resolved.