Refundable birth and stillbirth tax credits proposed

Summary#

SB 236 would add a new section to the Virginia Code to create refundable state income-tax credits for certain births and stillbirths. The credits would apply to tax years beginning in 2026 through 2030; the bill’s stated subject is a newborn and stillborn tax credit, not a guaranteed outcome. The bill is introduced and is not law.

  • For each eligible birth, married individuals could claim a $2,000 refundable credit. Married people filing separately could have only one of them claim it, and only one credit could be claimed for each birth.
  • For each qualifying stillbirth, an individual or married couple filing jointly could claim a $2,000 refundable credit. If two unmarried individuals claim for the same stillbirth, each could claim up to $1,000.
  • A stillbirth must involve a spontaneous death, meet a gestation or weight threshold, and have a stillbirth certificate or other verifying documents. The definition excludes an induced termination.
  • The credits would not cover births by a surrogate. The bill directs the Tax Commissioner to issue claiming guidelines, which would be exempt from the Administrative Process Act (the usual process for making state rules).

What it means for you#

  • Parents of a newborn: A married taxpayer could claim $2,000 for a child claimed as a Virginia dependent. The bill does not provide this credit for a birth by a surrogate.
  • People who are married and file separately: Only one spouse could claim the newborn credit for a birth. For a stillbirth, the bill names individuals and married couples filing jointly, but does not say married spouses filing separately may claim.
  • People who experience a stillbirth: The bill would offer a refundable credit if the child would have qualified as a Virginia dependent but for the death, and the bill’s other conditions are met. If two unmarried people claim for the same loss, each is limited to $1,000.
  • Taxpayers generally: A refundable credit can be paid even if it is larger than the income tax owed. Any excess would be refunded by the Tax Commissioner within 90 days after the return’s filing date.

Money#

No publicly available information gives an estimated cost or the number of people likely to claim these credits.

  • The bill would reduce tax owed or require refunds of up to the credit amount for eligible claims.
  • The bill requires the Tax Commissioner to refund 100 percent of the credit’s face value within 90 days after the return is filed, but does not estimate the staffing or administrative cost of handling claims.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not set out what documents or steps claimants must provide beyond the stillbirth documentation it names; the Tax Commissioner’s guidelines would address claiming, but their details are not included.
  • The bill does not explain how the credits would interact with other tax credits or benefits. The supplied material does not include the rest of the current Virginia tax code, so that interaction could not be checked.
  • The bill refers to the existing legal definition of “surrogate,” but that definition was not supplied here.
  • It is unclear how the Tax Commissioner would resolve competing claims, especially if more than one person seeks a credit for the same birth or stillbirth.
  • The bill does not state when it would take effect as law; its credit period is limited to tax years beginning in 2026 through 2030.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that it would provide direct financial help after a birth or qualifying stillbirth.
  • Because the credit is refundable, its full value would not depend on having at least $2,000 in state income-tax liability.
  • The bill sets out limits on duplicate claims for a newborn and a way to split the stillbirth credit between two unmarried claimants.

Case against#

  • The bill could create a public cost through reduced tax payments and refunds, but the available material gives no estimate of that cost or the number of claims.
  • The bill leaves key claim-handling details to later guidelines and exempts those guidelines from the Administrative Process Act.
  • The bill treats claimants differently depending on marital and filing status. In particular, it does not clearly provide a stillbirth credit for married people filing separately.
  • The bill does not explain how competing claims would be resolved or how the new credits would fit with existing tax provisions.