Courts Could Seize Crypto Linked to Fraud

Summary#

SB-860, “Virtual currency fraud investigations and recovery,” would add a new chapter to Virginia’s Code; it is a proposal, not law. It would create warrants to seize virtual currency and a court process to recover it for victims, with the stated goal of expediting recovery from virtual currency fraud.

  • The process would cover virtual currency linked to extortion; grand or petit larceny; embezzlement, including misuse of public funds or assets; computer fraud or trespass; obtaining money by false pretenses; financial exploitation of vulnerable adults; identity theft; or money laundering.
  • A judge or magistrate could issue a recovery warrant on probable cause. It could direct law enforcement to seize, secure, transfer, burn, reissue, redeem, or freeze the currency and hold it in a secure wallet controlled by the agency or, if needed, the Department of State Police.
  • A warrant could also be served on a virtual asset service provider, including one outside Virginia, if at least one of the bill’s listed links to Virginia applies. On receipt, the provider must immediately freeze the specified assets and transfer them to a law-enforcement wallet; a centralized stablecoin issuer could be ordered to freeze, reassign, or transfer a wallet.
  • After recovery, the attorney for the Commonwealth must file a court case within 90 days. The case is against the currency itself, and the Commonwealth must prove by a preponderance of the evidence (more likely than not) that it qualifies for recovery.
  • The bill would create a restitution fund, administered by the Comptroller, for leftover recovery proceeds and for need-based payments to people who lack another way to recover losses.

What it means for you#

  • Victims: A court could order qualifying seized currency returned in kind to an identified innocent victim. If the wallet owner is unknown, a court could order an early release to an alleged victim without a bond, but that victim must repay the owner if the owner later wins.
  • Virtual currency owners and lienholders: You could lose an interest after a recovery judgment. The bill provides defenses for owners who lacked knowledge, bona fide purchasers without notice, and lienholders who meet stated conditions. A notified claimant generally has 30 days to file an answer under oath; the court may allow more time.
  • Virtual asset service providers: A provider served under the bill would have to act immediately to freeze and transfer specified currency. The bill allows service through listed physical or electronic channels, including public-facing support or operational addresses in some cases.
  • Law enforcement and prosecutors: Law enforcement could seek warrants and hold seized currency. The attorney for the Commonwealth must start the recovery case within 90 days. The case may proceed even if no suspect is identified or a criminal investigation or prosecution is ongoing.
  • General public: The bill creates a seizure and recovery process, not a new criminal offense or a general ban on virtual currency. The supplied materials do not include current text of the related forfeiture chapters, so it is not possible to verify how this process would change or overlap with existing rules.

Money#

The bill gives no total estimate for operating costs; its fiscal statement assigns a minimum $50,000 impact for possible state adult prison terms, while estimating $0 for juvenile commitments.

  • If liquidation proceeds do not cover actual expenses of the recovery process, the Commonwealth must pay those expenses from the Criminal Fund.
  • Legal and liquidation costs are paid from net proceeds before distributions to identified innocent owners. The bill also says law enforcement is not liable for a loss in value caused by liquidation.
  • Leftover proceeds would go to the new restitution subfund. The bill does not provide a start-up appropriation or an estimate of staffing, technology, or other operating costs.

What is unclear#

  • The supplied materials do not include the current text of the Code provisions that define “virtual currency,” “virtual currency address,” “virtual currency wallet,” and “blockchain analytics.” Their exact scope cannot be verified here.
  • The bill does not define “secure” wallet or set a time limit more specific than “immediately” for providers to act.
  • It does not set out a separate process for challenging a seizure before the recovery case, or give timelines for a hearing after seizure.
  • The restitution fund’s payments depend on rules made by the Virginia Workers’ Compensation Commission, but those rules are not supplied.
  • No publicly available information on the bill’s start date, projected number of cases, or likely fund distributions.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to let law enforcement secure virtual currency quickly, before it can be moved, while requiring a judge or magistrate to find probable cause.
  • A court case against the currency itself could proceed without waiting for a suspect to be identified or a criminal case to finish.
  • The bill sets out notice and court procedures, recognizes defenses for some owners and lienholders, and allows identified innocent victims to seek return of currency.
  • A restitution fund could provide need-based help to people who have no other route to recover, using leftover proceeds from cases.

Case against#

  • The bill allows warrants to reach providers outside Virginia and permits electronic service through some public-facing addresses. The breadth of those rules could create disputes about jurisdiction, service, or whether a provider received a valid warrant.
  • Currency could be frozen and transferred before the recovery case decides ownership. The bill does not set a prompt post-seizure hearing deadline.
  • If a victim receives an early release and an unknown owner later wins, the victim—not the government—must repay the released amount. That could leave the victim with a debt.
  • The bill does not estimate the public costs of staffing, secure wallets, litigation, or uncovered case expenses. The amount available for the restitution fund would also depend on leftover proceeds and later rules.