Study constitutional budget priorities

Summary#

HCR-28, “Study Resolution for Constitutionally Aligned Budget Prioritization,” is a resolution, not a bill that amends state law. If adopted, it would direct the West Virginia Attorney General’s Office and State Treasurer’s Office to study state appropriations for the current year and previous five years. Its stated goal is to identify how spending relates to constitutional duties and other purposes.

  • The two offices would have to work together and examine each budget line and supplementary appropriation item in the covered period.
  • The study must sort spending into four categories: spending explicitly required by the state Constitution; spending for core government functions expressed in the Constitution; spending for policy goals not arising from those obligations or functions; and spending with historical precedent but a more speculative or unclear purpose.
  • The offices must send findings, conclusions, and recommendations to the Joint Committee on Government and Finance by December 21, 2026.
  • The resolution does not itself change appropriations, cut or approve spending, or require the Legislature to act on the recommendations. It has been introduced and referred to House Rules; whether it will be adopted is uncertain.

What it means for you#

  • Attorney General’s Office and State Treasurer’s Office: If the resolution is adopted, they must produce the study together and report by the deadline.
  • Taxpayers and people who use state services: The resolution does not directly change taxes, services, or funding. Any later budget changes would require further action.
  • Legislators: The Joint Committee on Government and Finance would receive the report and recommendations. The resolution does not require the committee or Legislature to follow them.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The two offices would have to spend staff time on the study, but the resolution gives no staffing level or cost estimate.

What is unclear#

  • The resolution does not define “core functions of government” or explain how to decide whether a purpose is “speculative or nebulous.”
  • It does not set a method for assigning budget items to categories, including items that may fit more than one.
  • It does not specify what data or level of detail the study must include beyond examining each budget line and supplementary appropriation item.
  • It does not say whether the offices must consult other agencies or how disagreements between the two offices would be handled.
  • It does not set out what happens if the report is late or recommendations are not followed.

Case for#

  • The study could give legislators a structured account of how state spending relates to constitutional duties and other purposes.
  • Examining several years of budgets could help show which spending items recur and which are tied to particular policy goals.
  • Recommendations could give the Legislature information to consider when setting future budgets, without changing spending automatically.

Case against#

  • The resolution leaves important categories undefined, so the offices’ classifications and recommendations may depend on judgments the text does not guide.
  • The study requires staff time, but the resolution does not identify funding or explain what other work might be affected.
  • The resolution does not require the Legislature to respond to the study, so it may not change budget decisions.