Independent contractor criteria set

Summary#

SB-1073 would amend West Virginia’s existing Employment Law Worker Classification Act, specifically its rules for classifying workers. Its stated goal is to align state classifications with Internal Revenue Service classifications; that is a goal, not a guaranteed result. The bill is introduced and referred to the Senate Judiciary Committee, so it is not law.

  • A worker would qualify as an independent contractor under specified state laws if the worker meets the bill’s conditions: a written contract with required acknowledgements; a business or self-employment tax filing, or service through a business; direct control over how the work is done, subject to exceptions; and at least three of nine listed indicators—or the bill’s separate direct-seller condition.
  • If a worker does not meet those conditions, the bill says classification is determined under IRS Revenue Ruling 87-41.
  • The listed state laws cover workers’ compensation, unemployment compensation, Human Rights Act rights, and wage payment and collection.
  • The bill says a principal (the party engaging the worker) may still hire a person as an employee, even if the person meets the independent-contractor criteria.
  • The supplied text also includes a sentence saying ambiguity is resolved in favor of independent-contractor status. Because the bill’s strikeout and underline formatting is missing, it is unclear whether that sentence would remain.

What it means for you#

  • Workers: If classified as independent contractors under the bill, workers would acknowledge in their contracts that the principal will not provide workers’ compensation or unemployment compensation benefits, and will not withhold taxes from payments. The worker would acknowledge responsibility for applicable income taxes.
  • Workers: The contract must say the worker is responsible for most supplies and other variable expenses, with exceptions for non-local travel, contractually reimbursed expenses, and expenses commonly reimbursed in the industry.
  • Businesses and other principals: The bill sets conditions for independent-contractor classification, including a written contract and the listed worker criteria. It does not require a principal to classify a qualifying worker as an independent contractor.
  • State programs and workers: The classification test would apply to the four areas of state law named above. The bill does not create an application, review, or appeal process in the supplied text.

Money#

No cost estimate is available in the supplied material.

  • The bill includes no appropriation or cost estimate for government.
  • Workers classified as independent contractors would acknowledge they are responsible for applicable income taxes and that the principal will not withhold them.
  • The bill makes responsibility for most supplies and variable expenses part of the classification conditions; it gives no estimate of those costs.

What is unclear#

  • The current text of the amended law was not supplied, so the existing rules and the exact changes cannot be verified against current law.
  • The bill’s formatting is missing, so it is unclear which wording is new, which is retained, and whether the sentence favoring independent-contractor status when there is ambiguity remains.
  • Terms such as “substantial compliance,” “majority” of expenses, and “actually and directly controls” are not defined in the supplied text.
  • The bill does not set out how classification disputes would be handled, who would make a decision, or what review or appeal rights would apply.
  • The supplied text does not state when the changes would take effect. Passage is uncertain because the bill is only introduced.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to give workers and principals a written set of conditions for independent-contractor classification.
  • A possible argument for the bill is that its contract, tax, control, and business-indicator tests could make classification more predictable.
  • Using IRS Revenue Ruling 87-41 when a worker does not meet the listed conditions could provide a fallback test rather than leaving that group without a stated standard.

Case against#

  • One concern is that independent-contractor classification can affect access to workers’ compensation, unemployment compensation, and rights under the other named laws.
  • The bill’s conditions may be difficult to apply consistently because several key terms are undefined and the bill does not describe a dispute process.
  • The bill’s listed criteria and fallback test may not produce the same result as federal classifications in every case; the supplied material does not explain how that alignment would work.
  • It is unclear whether the ambiguity rule favoring independent-contractor status would remain, which could materially affect close classification cases.