Amendment would ban involuntary servitude

Summary#

AJR 152 is a proposed amendment to the Wisconsin Constitution, not an ordinary law. The bill analysis says its goal is to remove the exception that allows slavery or involuntary servitude as punishment for a crime, but the amendment text supplied repeats that exception, so the text does not show that change. The resolution failed and did not change the constitution.

  • If adopted as described in the analysis, the amendment would prohibit slavery and involuntary servitude without an exception for people convicted of crimes.
  • This was a first-step proposal: a constitutional amendment would also need approval by a later legislature and ratification by voters before taking effect.
  • The resolution does not set rules for applying a new prohibition or explain how existing practices would change.

What it means for you#

  • People in prison: The analysis describes a proposed change that could affect whether involuntary servitude may be imposed as punishment. But the text supplied does not clearly make that change, and the resolution failed.
  • State government: The proposal does not create a new office, program, enforcement process, or benefit.
  • Voters: The resolution did not itself put a constitutional amendment to a vote. The proposal failed before that could happen.
  • Everyone: Wisconsin’s constitution was not changed by this resolution.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The resolution shows no appropriation, fee, fine, or cost estimate.
  • It does not estimate any costs of changing practices if the amendment were later adopted.

What is unclear#

  • The bill analysis says the exception would be removed, but the proposed constitutional text supplied still includes the exception. The materials do not resolve this conflict.
  • The proposal does not define “slavery” or “involuntary servitude.”
  • The bill does not explain which practices would be affected, how they would change, or when any change would begin.
  • The resolution failed, so there is no enacted amendment to apply.

Case for#

  • If the intended change is to prohibit involuntary servitude without exception, a possible argument is that the constitutional protection should apply regardless of whether a person has been convicted of a crime.
  • A clear ban without that exception could limit the state’s ability to impose involuntary servitude as criminal punishment.

Case against#

  • The supplied amendment text does not clearly carry out the change described in the bill analysis. That conflict makes the proposal’s legal effect uncertain.
  • The bill does not define key terms or explain how the proposed ban would affect existing practices.
  • If the exception were removed, the constitution’s text would change without the bill explaining what replacement arrangements, if any, would apply.