Curbing Coordinated Mass Communications in Elections

Summary#

AB 1220, “Coordination of mass communications,” would amend Wisconsin campaign-finance law in chapter 11; it did not become law because it failed. Its goal appears to be to apply coordination rules to certain mass communications and prevent them from avoiding candidate contribution limits or source restrictions.

  • It would define mass communication to include messages sent through communications media, plus 500 or more substantially identical pieces distributed by email or fax, 500 or more substantially identical pieces of material distributed, or 500 or more calls with a substantially identical message. Bona fide polls to objectively collect electors’ views are excluded.
  • For express-advocacy spending, it would treat an expenditure as coordinated if a candidate, the candidate’s agent, a legislative campaign committee (LCC), or the candidate’s political party controls it or has substantial discussions or negotiations about specified parts of the communication. Current law, according to the bill analysis, also treats a direct request followed by explicit agreement as coordination; the bill would remove that test.
  • During the 60 days before an election through election day, it would prohibit certain coordinated mass-communication spending that refers to a clearly identified candidate on the ballot and can only reasonably be read as urging a vote for that candidate or against an opponent, when it violates contribution limits or source restrictions.
  • If a mass-communication expenditure is coordinated but does not violate that prohibition, the spending committee or other covered spender would have to report it, and the candidate’s committee would have to report it as a contribution.

What it means for you#

  • Political action committees, independent expenditure committees, and other covered spenders: If the bill became law, they could face the new prohibition for specified spending in the 60-day election period. The bill would also require reporting for coordinated mass-communication spending that is not prohibited.
  • Candidates and their committees: Coordination could make otherwise independent spending count as a contribution for reporting purposes. The bill does not set out a new application or approval process.
  • Voters: The bill would not directly change voting rules, ballot access, or who may vote.
  • Everyone: Because the bill failed, it does not change current law.

Money#

No cost estimate or fiscal information is included in the supplied material.

  • The bill would require some spenders and candidate committees to report coordinated mass-communication expenditures. The material does not estimate the cost of that reporting or any government administration.
  • The bill does not set an appropriation, tax, fee, or fine.

What is unclear#

  • “Communications media” is not defined in the bill, so the full range of messages covered by that part of the definition is unclear.
  • The bill’s definition of coordination does not list a candidate’s committee, although the prohibition refers to coordination with a candidate’s committee. The supplied text does not explain this difference.
  • The bill does not specify how the new reporting duties would be administered, or how they would interact with all existing reporting rules.
  • The supplied material does not include the full current statute. The bill analysis summarizes current coordination rules, but the full current law, including exceptions and penalties, could not be checked against the bill.
  • The bill failed, so it has no start date and creates no current duties.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that substantial discussions or negotiations can indicate coordination even when there is no direct request followed by explicit agreement.
  • Applying coordination rules to defined mass communications could help make the contribution limits and source restrictions apply to certain election messages as well as express advocacy spending.
  • The bill excludes bona fide polls conducted to objectively collect information about electors’ views.

Case against#

  • The new test could make it harder to know when discussions or negotiations are “substantial”; the bill does not define that term.
  • The definition of mass communication includes communications media without explaining what that covers, which could leave uncertainty about which messages are subject to the rules.
  • The bill’s wording differs on whether coordination with a candidate’s committee counts, leaving uncertainty about how that part would operate.