BadgerCare options could expand health coverage

Summary#

SB 1121, titled “BadgerCare purchase option, basic plan, state-based insurance exchange, and granting rule-making authority,” would add new provisions to Wisconsin statutes. It would require planning and federal approval requests for expanded BadgerCare purchase options, a basic health plan, and a state-based insurance exchange; its stated goal is to make these coverage options available. The bill failed, so it did not change current law.

  • The Department of Health Services (DHS) would have to seek federal approval for people over BadgerCare’s income limits who otherwise qualify to buy coverage through a BadgerCare purchase option.
  • If the required approvals are granted, DHS would have to implement that purchase program. Its coverage would match existing BadgerCare benefits, and its annual premium would be similar to the average rate the state pays managed care contractors.
  • The purchase option would have annual enrollment during the same open-enrollment periods as existing programs, an actuarial value no lower than 87 percent, and reimbursement mechanisms for potential added program costs. Actuarial value is an estimate of the share of covered costs a plan pays.
  • DHS would have to include a way for groups of 50 or fewer employees to buy coverage for their members, and seek approval for eligible purchasers to use federal tax credits and cost-sharing credits.
  • DHS would have to plan and seek federal approval for a basic health plan for people with household income up to 200 percent of the federal poverty line. The bill does not expressly require DHS to implement that plan.
  • The Office of the Commissioner of Insurance (OCI) would have to plan for a state-based insurance exchange and ensure the BadgerCare purchase option can be accessed through it. The bill also gives the commissioner power to make rules and enter necessary federal agreements.

What it means for you#

  • People above BadgerCare’s income limits: If the bill had become law and required federal approval had been granted, people who otherwise meet BadgerCare eligibility rules could buy coverage through the purchase option instead of an individual private plan. The bill does not make coverage free.
  • Small groups: Groups with 50 or fewer employees would have to be offered a way to purchase coverage for group members through the program, subject to the program being approved and implemented.
  • People seeking coverage through an exchange: Wisconsin currently uses the federally run exchange, according to the bill’s analysis. The bill would require OCI to plan for a state-based exchange, but does not set a launch date or specify the exchange’s operating arrangements.
  • Other residents: The bill would not directly change existing BadgerCare eligibility limits. It also would not itself guarantee that a basic health plan starts.
  • DHS and OCI: They would have new planning, federal-approval, coordination, and exchange-related duties. DHS would also have to report to legislative committees by March 1, 2027, on the status of the waiver request and relevant analyses.

Money#

No publicly available information on the cost amount is included in the supplied materials; they say a state fiscal estimate would be printed as an appendix, but do not provide it.

  • DHS and OCI would have new duties, but the bill gives no staffing or administrative cost figures.
  • People who use the purchase option would pay an annual premium. The bill says its rate must be similar to the average rate paid by the state to managed care contractors, but does not set a dollar amount.
  • The bill requires mechanisms to address potential increased program costs and financial risks, but does not specify their cost or how they would be funded.
  • Federal tax credits and cost-sharing credits could be used only if eligible and if required federal approvals are obtained.

What is unclear#

  • Whether federal authorities would approve the purchase option, basic health plan, tax-credit use, or state-based exchange.
  • What “similar” means for the purchase-option premium, and how that rate would be calculated.
  • How the basic health plan would be designed, funded, or put into operation; the bill requires planning and approval requests but does not set out an operating plan.
  • The bill does not set detailed application, decision, appeal, or oversight procedures for the new purchase option.
  • How the state-based exchange would operate, when it would start, and how it would interact with the existing federal exchange are not specified.
  • The supplied material summarizes current law but does not include the full existing statutes, so those details could not be checked against the current statutory text.

Case for#

  • A purchase option could give people who earn too much for BadgerCare, but otherwise qualify, another coverage choice.
  • Using the existing BadgerCare benefit set and enrollment periods could support continuity with current programs.
  • A basic health plan could provide another coverage option for people with household income up to 200 percent of the federal poverty line.
  • A state-based exchange could give Wisconsin a role in operating the exchange and connect it to the proposed BadgerCare purchase option.

Case against#

  • The bill leaves major choices to later planning and federal approval, so it does not establish when—or whether—the new options would become available.
  • The premium standard and financial safeguards are not defined in enough detail to show what purchasers or the state would pay.
  • The bill requires work by DHS and OCI but supplies no cost or staffing estimate in the provided material.
  • A new state-based exchange and new coverage options could add administrative complexity; the bill does not explain how they would fit with existing systems.