Nonsolicitation clauses banned for former workers

Summary#

SB 1170, “Prohibitions on postemployment nonsolicitation clauses in employment contracts,” would amend Wisconsin Statutes section 103.465; it would not create a separate law or agency. It failed and is not law. Its stated goal is to make contract clauses that restrict former workers from recruiting their former employer’s workers illegal and unenforceable.

  • The bill would make those clauses void, with no exception for a restriction that an employer says is reasonably necessary.
  • It defines “solicitation” as recruiting an employer’s employee or agent to work for, or provide agent services to, a different employer or principal.
  • Employers and principals would have to post a notice in customary notice locations and, if they have a website, in a conspicuous place there. The Department would approve the notice’s form.
  • The bill would keep the existing rule for non-compete covenants: they are enforceable only when reasonably necessary to protect the employer or principal; an unreasonable restraint is void.
  • The prohibition would first apply to a contract provision in a contract entered into, extended, modified, or renewed on the effective date named in the bill.

What it means for you#

  • Former employees and agents: If the bill had become law, a covered contract clause could not stop you from recruiting a former employer’s employee or agent to work for another employer or provide agent services to another principal. The bill does not directly change other kinds of post-employment restrictions.
  • Employers and principals: You would have to post the Department-approved notice. A covered nonsolicitation clause would be illegal and unenforceable.
  • Workers and employers now: Because the bill failed, it does not itself change anyone’s rights or duties. The supplied material does not establish whether other current laws or contract rules affect these clauses.
  • General public: The bill would not create a new service, benefit, fine, or enforcement office.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill would require employers and principals to post a notice, but gives no estimate of the cost of doing so or of the Department approving the notice form.
  • No funding or staffing amount is specified.

What is unclear#

  • The bill gives no effective date in the supplied text, so the start date cannot be determined from these materials.
  • The parent statute was not supplied. The bill’s analysis describes current law, but I could not independently verify that description or check how the bill would interact with all current law.
  • The bill does not explain how the Department would approve the notice, or when the form would be available.
  • It does not set out a complaint, review, or appeal process, or specify a penalty for failing to post the notice.
  • It defines “solicitation” as recruiting, but does not further explain what counts as recruiting.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that it would give former workers a clear rule: employers could not enforce contract clauses that bar them from recruiting the employer’s employees or agents.
  • The categorical prohibition could avoid disputes over whether a particular post-employment recruiting restriction is reasonably necessary.
  • Requiring employers and principals to post a notice could inform workers about the proposed rule.

Case against#

  • One concern is that the bill would invalidate these clauses categorically, even if an employer believes a narrower restriction is reasonably necessary to protect its interests.
  • The bill does not explain how the prohibition would apply in close cases, such as what conduct counts as “recruiting.”
  • The posting duty and Department-approved notice would add requirements, but the materials give no cost estimate or details about how the notice process would work.