Bill bars post-employment nondisparagement

Summary#

SB 1175 is a failed Wisconsin bill and did not become law. It would amend Wisconsin Statute 103.465, which covers restrictive covenants in employment contracts, to prohibit certain post-employment nondisparagement clauses; its stated aim is to make those clauses illegal and unenforceable.

  • An employment contract could not require an employee or agent to avoid disparaging a former employer or principal, in writing or speech, after the job or agency ends.
  • The bill would require each employer and principal to post a notice in customary workplace notice areas. Employers and principals with a website would also have to post it there.
  • The notice would need to use a form approved by the department.
  • The existing rule on non-compete covenants would remain: restrictions must be reasonably necessary to protect the employer or principal, and an unreasonable covenant is void and unenforceable.

What it means for you#

  • Employees and agents: If enacted, the bill would make covered post-employment nondisparagement terms illegal and unenforceable for contracts within its applicability rule. It does not create a general right or immunity from other laws.
  • Employers and principals: They would have to post the required notice. The bill does not set a fine or describe an enforcement process for failing to post it.
  • The public: Because the bill failed, it does not change the law.

Money#

No publicly available information on the bill’s cost.

  • Employers and principals would have to post notices; the materials do not estimate the cost.
  • The bill requires a department-approved notice form but gives no cost estimate or staffing details.

What is unclear#

  • The supplied text does not give a calendar date for when the bill would have taken effect. It says the rule would first apply to contracts entered into, extended, modified, or renewed on the effective date.
  • “Disparage” is not defined. The bill does not distinguish between types of statements or set out exceptions.
  • The bill does not explain how the notice requirement would be enforced, or what would happen if an employer or principal did not comply.
  • The bill refers to “the department” but does not name it in the supplied text or set a deadline for approving the notice form.
  • The Legislative Reference Bureau analysis describes the existing non-compete rule, but the current version of the amended statute was not supplied, so I could not independently check the full current-law context.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that workers should not be bound by contract terms that restrict what they can say about a former employer after their employment ends.
  • Making those terms unenforceable could give workers more room to speak about their experiences.
  • Required notices could help inform employees and agents that these contract terms would not be enforceable under the bill.

Case against#

  • The bill does not define “disparage” or distinguish among kinds of speech. That could leave uncertainty about which contract terms would be invalid.
  • The prohibition is broad: it does not set out exceptions for particular circumstances or allow a narrower post-employment nondisparagement term.
  • The bill does not explain how the posting rule would be enforced or how the required notice form would be approved.