Funding local journalism via nonprofit consortium

Summary#

SB 1183, titled “Creating a Civic Information Consortium Board and a grant program administered by a nonprofit corporation to support local journalism and media projects and making an appropriation,” failed and is not law. It would have created new provisions in Wisconsin law, including a board attached to the University of Wisconsin System and a nonprofit corporation to run grants. Its stated goal was to support local journalism, media literacy and civic engagement, especially in underserved communities.

  • The board would have 11 members: four UW System representatives, five local media representatives and two public members. The UW System president would appoint the first four; board members would appoint the others.
  • The board would have to organize and maintain the Wisconsin Civic Information Consortium, Inc. The four UW System representatives would be the corporation’s members; the board would manage its affairs and select a director to run daily operations.
  • The corporation would have to award grants for local journalism and media projects. Applications would have to explain how a project meets Wisconsin’s civic information needs and provides media literacy skills or local journalism access to underserved residents.
  • Grant recipients would have to agree to remain independent of the state, institutions and other providers of funds related to the grant. At least 30% of all grant money would have to go to off-campus partners in rural communities.
  • The corporation would have to collect information on communities underserved by local news and prioritize funding for them. The board could not make an action or funding decision based on a grant recipient’s reporting, and would have to report annually on spending and results.

What it means for you#

  • UW System: The system’s president would appoint four board members with relevant experience or expertise. The bill does not specify how much staff support the system would provide.
  • Local media and the public: Media representatives would have to include people whose primary work is in print, online or new media, radio and television, and include nonprofit and for-profit news providers. Two public members would also serve.
  • Potential grant applicants: The corporation could require additional information beyond the explanation specified in the bill. The bill does not guarantee a grant to any applicant or require a particular number of grants.
  • Grant recipients: They would have to sign the independence agreement. The bill does not say that media organizations must apply or change their reporting.
  • Wisconsin residents: The bill would not create an individual benefit or guarantee access to a new news service. It would direct public money to projects intended to address information needs.

Money#

The bill proposed $20 million for 2025–26 and $1 million for 2026–27 for grants and the corporation’s operations.

  • The amounts would come from a state general fund appropriation to the board, which would provide funding to the corporation.
  • The appropriation is described as continuing. The bill does not break out how much would go to grants versus operations.
  • No publicly available information on the expected administrative costs or a fiscal estimate is included in the supplied material.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not define terms such as “underserved,” “rural communities,” or “off-campus partners.”
  • It does not set out detailed grant-selection rules, decision timelines, an appeal process or how the corporation would check recipients’ independence.
  • It does not say how the 30% rural-partner requirement would be measured or what would qualify as an off-campus partner.
  • The supplied material does not include current related laws or programs, so it is not possible to verify how this would overlap with existing funding.
  • The bill does not provide an implementation date or a detailed plan for staffing and oversight.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that grants could support local reporting and media literacy in places the corporation identifies as underserved.
  • A required 30% share for off-campus partners in rural communities could direct a defined portion of grant money beyond campus-based work.
  • Board representation across several media types, nonprofit and for-profit providers, UW System and the public could bring different perspectives to the grant program.
  • The independence agreement and restriction on decisions based on a recipient’s reporting are intended to protect editorial independence.

Case against#

  • One concern is that the bill sets broad goals but leaves important grant rules and definitions to the corporation, making it hard to know in advance who would qualify or how awards would be chosen.
  • The proposed appropriation is substantial, but the bill does not specify how much would fund grants, operations or oversight.
  • The board would have a role in forming and managing the corporation, while the four UW System representatives alone would be its members. The bill does not explain how potential conflicts in that structure would be handled.
  • The rural funding minimum may limit flexibility if the corporation identifies other urgent needs, while the bill does not define which projects count toward that minimum.