Lawmakers curb state help to federal gun enforcement

Summary#

HB 283, “Second Amendment Protection Act amendments-2,” would amend Wyoming’s Second Amendment Protection Act and the Wyoming Governmental Claims Act. Its stated goal is to limit state and local help with federal firearms enforcement and provide ways to challenge violations. The bill failed, so it did not become law.

  • State and local entities would be barred from using personnel or funds to help enforce certain federal firearms measures that the bill describes as unconstitutional and infringing Second Amendment rights.
  • A government entity could be liable for damages resulting from a violation. The bill would also allow lawsuits seeking court orders, damages and other remedies, and would remove sovereign immunity as a defense in those lawsuits.
  • Courts would impose a $50,000 civil penalty per violation in some cases. A separate provision would impose a $50,000 penalty for each covered employee who knowingly carries out specified federal firearms enforcement or aid.
  • The bill would create exceptions for certain assistance to federal officers or prosecutors and for accepting federal assistance to enforce Wyoming law.
  • It would define “law abiding citizen” and “material aid,” with “material aid” covering such things as lodging, communications, personnel, weapons and transportation.

What it means for you#

  • Wyoming residents: A person who meets the bill’s definition of “law abiding citizen” could seek damages if a public or peace officer violated the Act against them in the circumstances described. An “interested party” could also sue to enforce the Act. The bill does not define “interested party.”
  • State and local governments and law enforcement agencies: They would face limits on assisting with covered federal firearms enforcement, and could face damages, court orders and civil penalties for violations.
  • Agencies employing former federal officials or employees: They could face a $50,000 penalty for each covered employee who knowingly carries out or materially aids the specified federal firearms enforcement. The bill does not require that the federal measure be found unconstitutional for this provision to apply.
  • People providing aid: The bill’s exceptions include aid in certain out-of-state or cross-border pursuits, specified federal prosecutions, and accepting federal assistance to enforce state law. It also excludes medical aid and help to escape a serious, immediate risk of life-threatening injury from “material aid.”
  • Current law: The existing Act’s text was not supplied, and the bill’s amendment text does not clearly show every deletion and addition. I could not verify all changes against current law.

Money#

The bill could create public costs and penalty payments, but no cost estimate is available.

  • It would expose government entities to damages and reasonable attorney fees in specified lawsuits, and create $50,000 civil penalties.
  • The bill provides no estimate for claims, penalties, staffing, or other costs. It does not specify who would receive the civil penalties.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not say how a court would decide whether a federal measure is “unconstitutional” for purposes of the prohibition.
  • It does not set out detailed procedures or timelines for lawsuits, apart from requiring a hearing on certain requests for court orders within 30 days.
  • The amendment text does not clearly show which parts of the existing Act would be replaced, so the full change from current law is uncertain.
  • The text does not explain how the exceptions would apply when more than one exception or prohibition may be relevant.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to keep Wyoming state and local resources from helping enforce federal firearms measures that it regards as unconstitutional.
  • A possible argument for the lawsuits and penalties is that they would give people and interested parties a way to seek remedies when the Act is violated.
  • The stated exceptions preserve some cooperation with federal authorities, including assistance in certain prosecutions and enforcement of Wyoming law.

Case against#

  • The bill’s limits on assistance could reach many forms of support: “material aid” includes communications, lodging, personnel and transportation.
  • The bill does not explain how agencies should determine whether a federal measure is unconstitutional before deciding whether to assist.
  • The $50,000 penalties and potential damages could expose government entities to significant liability; the materials do not estimate the likely cost.
  • The separate penalty for employing a former federal official or employee may apply even when the federal firearms measure is not found unconstitutional.