Civil liability for officers violating gun rules

Summary#

HB 303, the Second Amendment Protection Act-amendments, would amend Wyoming’s Governmental Claims Act and Second Amendment Protection Act. Its stated goal is to protect constitutional rights; it did not become law because it failed. The bill’s text refers to a restriction on enforcing federal rules about firearms and related items, but the materials do not include the text of that restriction.

  • A governmental entity, state agency, local government or law enforcement agency could be sued if an officer it employs knowingly violates that restriction while working.
  • A court could award damages and, in addition, impose a civil penalty of up to $50,000 per violation. It could also order other relief allowed by law and award reasonable attorney fees and costs.
  • Sovereign immunity (a government’s legal protection from some lawsuits) could not be used as a defence in an action under the new provision.
  • The bill would expressly include peace officers, as well as public officers, in provisions about assistance to federal authorities and criminal penalties for knowingly violating the restriction. The penalty stated is up to one year in jail, a $2,000 fine, or both.
  • The bill would not bar Wyoming governmental entities from accepting federal law-enforcement funds.

What it means for you#

  • People alleging harm: You could bring a civil action against an eligible government entity if an employed officer knowingly violated the referenced restriction while acting within the scope of employment. The bill does not set out how a court would determine damages.
  • Government entities and law-enforcement agencies: They could face damages, a civil penalty, other court-ordered relief, and the injured party’s reasonable legal costs. The penalty is discretionary (“may”), not automatic.
  • Public and peace officers: The bill states that either could face the existing criminal penalty for a knowing violation. It also says either may assist federal authorities for purposes not specifically identified in the restriction.
  • General public: The bill would not itself create a new front-line service or say that every alleged violation must be investigated. The restriction in subsection (a) is not included in the supplied text, so its exact scope cannot be verified.
  • Current law: The existing Act is not supplied. I could not verify which rules or penalties already apply, or how much of the bill would be new.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill authorizes possible payments by government entities through damages, civil penalties, court-ordered relief, and legal fees, but gives no estimate of how often these would arise or their total cost.
  • It does not state a staffing requirement or provide a spending appropriation.

What is unclear#

  • The text of the restriction in subsection (a)—the conduct that could trigger civil and criminal consequences—is not supplied.
  • The existing law is not supplied, so the changes to current officer duties, penalties, and government liability cannot be fully compared.
  • The bill does not specify filing deadlines, court procedures, or how damages would be calculated. The supplied text does not show whether other laws provide those rules.
  • It does not explain how this new civil action would interact with existing claims procedures or remedies.
  • No publicly available information on expected claims, government costs, or the number of people affected is in the supplied material.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to give people harmed by a knowing violation a way to seek damages from the government entity that employed the officer.
  • Allowing a court to award legal fees and impose a penalty could make the remedy more meaningful for an injured person.
  • Including peace officers in the wording could make the bill’s stated rules apply to them as well as to public officers.

Case against#

  • The text provided does not include the restriction that triggers these consequences, so readers cannot assess the scope of the proposed liability or criminal penalty.
  • Government entities could face substantial, uncapped damages in addition to a discretionary penalty of up to $50,000 per violation and legal fees.
  • The bill does not explain how the new action would fit with existing government-claims procedures, making the practical route to a remedy unclear.