Bill would publish blocked legislator emails

Summary#

HB-338, “Disclosure of undelivered legislator emails,” would amend Wyoming Statute 28-8-105. Its stated goal is to disclose which email domains and internet protocol (IP) addresses are being blocked from delivering email to legislators, and to let affected senders ask for delivery to resume. The bill failed, so it did not change the law.

  • The Legislative Service Office (LSO) would have to publish or update a list of all domains and IP addresses it quarantines or otherwise prevents from delivering email to legislators, at least once each legislative day during a session.
  • A person whose emails the LSO quarantined could ask the LSO to remove the sender’s current and future emails from quarantine.
  • The LSO would have to remove the requested domain or IP address from quarantine and allow delivery within two days, unless doing so posed an actual, articulable security threat to Wyoming’s information technology systems.

What it means for you#

  • People emailing legislators: If the LSO quarantined your emails, you could ask it to allow delivery from your domain or IP address. The bill would not guarantee delivery in every case: the LSO could keep the address quarantined if the stated security exception applied.
  • People using the published list: You could see which domains and IP addresses the LSO was quarantining or otherwise preventing from delivering email during a legislative session.
  • Legislators: The bill does not set a duty for legislators to read or respond to emails.
  • The LSO: It would have new publication and request-handling duties. The bill failed, so those duties did not take effect.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill would require the existing LSO to publish the list and handle removal requests, but gives no estimate of staffing or other costs.
  • The bill does not provide an appropriation or set a fee.

What is unclear#

  • The bill refers to a definition of “internet domain names” in another statute, but that text was not supplied. I could not verify its scope.
  • The bill does not explain how people would make requests, how the LSO would verify them, or how it would decide whether the security exception applies.
  • It does not provide a way to challenge a refusal, or require notice explaining why a request was denied.
  • The bill does not explain whether or how the published list would account for security concerns.
  • The existing text of W.S. 28-8-105 was not supplied, so I could not verify how the proposal would interact with current law or existing email-quarantine practices.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to make email blocking more visible. A public list could help people learn that their domain or IP address is being prevented from reaching legislators.
  • A two-day deadline and a way to request removal could give affected senders a clear route to seek restored delivery.
  • The security exception would allow the LSO to keep an address blocked when releasing it posed an actual, articulable threat to state IT systems.

Case against#

  • The bill does not set out how the LSO would assess requests or apply the security exception. That could leave senders uncertain about what to provide or why a request was refused.
  • The list could reveal information about blocked domains or addresses. The bill does not explain how publication would be handled if disclosure raised a security concern.
  • Removing a domain or IP address from quarantine could allow delivery from that address beyond the individual making the request. The bill does not describe how the LSO would handle that possibility.