Push to investigate anti-ESG investments

Summary#

SJ-11, “Supporting anti-ESG litigation,” is a Wyoming Senate joint resolution. It failed, so it does not change the law. Its stated goal was to protect state investments, industries and policies by asking state officials to use existing legal tools against alleged illegal conduct involving nonpecuniary (not financial) investment factors.

  • It would request—not require—the governor and attorney general to investigate and prosecute illegal activity by banks, asset managers and other financial institutions, and to join other states’ efforts.
  • It would request that the state treasurer seek asset managers focused on returns and shareholder wealth, and ensure state investment proxy votes serve Wyoming’s financial interests.
  • The resolution points to existing antitrust and consumer-protection enforcement powers; it does not create a new offense, ban ESG investing, or authorize a lawsuit by itself.
  • Its recitals describe alleged collusion and harm to Wyoming industries. Those statements are not findings established by the resolution.

What it means for you#

  • Wyoming residents and taxpayers: Because the resolution failed, it creates no new duties or direct changes for you.
  • Governor and attorney general: If adopted, they would have been asked to use legal tools already available to investigate and prosecute illegal activity, and to join other states’ investigations or lawsuits. The request is not a legal command.
  • State treasurer: If adopted, the treasurer would have been asked to seek managers with the stated investment focus and to ensure proxy voting serves the state’s financial interests. The resolution does not set out a process for doing this.
  • Financial institutions: The resolution creates no new legal exposure merely for considering environmental, social or governance factors. Its request concerns alleged illegal activity, including collusion.

Money#

No cost estimate or appropriation appears in the supplied material.

  • The resolution requests investigation, litigation and changes to investment management and proxy voting, but gives no staffing or spending amount.
  • No publicly available information on possible litigation, staffing or investment-management costs is supplied.

What is unclear#

  • The resolution does not define “nonpecuniary” or “ideological” factors, or explain how officials should distinguish them from financial considerations.
  • It sets no rules for choosing asset managers, deciding how proxy votes serve Wyoming’s financial interests, or overseeing those decisions.
  • The materials do not include the laws the resolution refers to, so the scope of the existing antitrust and consumer-protection powers cannot be checked here.
  • The resolution does not explain what evidence would support an investigation or when Wyoming should join another state’s case.

Case for#

  • The resolution appears intended to protect the financial returns on public funds and Wyoming industries from unlawful collusion.
  • A possible argument for the approach is that it asks officials to use existing legal tools, rather than creating a new ban or offense.
  • Joining other states’ investigations or lawsuits could let Wyoming pursue alleged conduct that involves large financial institutions operating across state lines.

Case against#

  • One concern is that the resolution’s terms for nonfinancial or ideological investing are not defined, leaving unclear what conduct officials should target.
  • The resolution asks the treasurer to ensure certain investment and proxy-voting outcomes but supplies no decision rules or oversight process.
  • Litigation and investigations can use public resources, but the resolution gives no cost estimate.
  • Because it requests action rather than requiring it, the resolution does not ensure officials will act or explain what they must do if they do not.

Votes

2 recorded votes on this bill, newest first.

  1. Division No. 1485443

    Passed30 members voted

    3rd Reading:Passed 28-2-1-0-0

    FOR · 28AGAINST · 2

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    28For

    • Republican27
    • Democratic1

    2Against

    • Democratic1
    • Republican1

    1 member was paired and sat out the vote.

  2. Division No. 1479106

    Passed5 members voted

    S02 - Appropriations:Recommend Do Pass 5-0-0-0-0

    FOR · 5

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    5For

    • Republican4
    • Democratic1

    0Against