Privacy right would be added to constitution

Summary#

SJ-9 is a Wyoming Senate joint resolution proposing a constitutional amendment; it does not amend an existing statute. Its stated goal is to protect individual privacy, by adding a new section to the Wyoming Constitution saying the right “shall not be infringed.” The resolution is listed as failed, so it did not amend the Constitution.

  • The proposal would add a right of individual privacy to Article 1 of the Wyoming Constitution.
  • It would take effect only if two-thirds of the members of each legislative chamber approved the resolution and a majority of voters ratified it at the next general election.
  • If the amendment went to voters, the Secretary of State would have to endorse a statement about the proposed amendment.
  • The proposal does not set out specific rules, remedies, or enforcement powers for the privacy right.

What it means for you#

  • Wyoming residents: The resolution is listed as failed, so it did not change your constitutional rights.
  • Voters: Under the proposal, voters would decide whether to ratify the amendment, but only after the required legislative approval. The bill does not specify a particular election date.
  • People and organizations whose actions might affect privacy: The proposal does not define “individual privacy” or say which actions would count as an infringement. It does not create a complaint or court process.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill does not state how much it would cost to put the proposal before voters or to carry out an amendment if ratified.

What is unclear#

  • The proposal does not define “individual privacy” or explain what “shall not be infringed” would cover.
  • It does not specify who could enforce the right, what remedies would be available, or how it would apply to government actions or private conduct.
  • It does not explain how the proposed right would interact with existing constitutional rights or laws.
  • The text does not give a specific date for the proposed election.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to make individual privacy an express right in the Wyoming Constitution.
  • A possible argument for the amendment is that placing the right in the state constitution would give it explicit recognition in that document.
  • The proposal states that individual privacy is essential to the well-being of a free society.

Case against#

  • The proposal does not define the right or explain how it would be applied, leaving its scope unclear.
  • It does not set out procedures or remedies, so the text does not show how a person could enforce the right.
  • A possible concern is that courts and government bodies would have to interpret a broad constitutional statement without guidance in the amendment.