Abortion rights shield bill would limit state interference

Summary#

Wyoming HB-138, the Reproductive Freedom Act, would create new sections of state law and repeal several existing sections. It would limit state interference with abortion before fetal viability or to protect a person’s life or health; its stated goal is to protect reproductive rights. The bill failed, so it did not change the law.

  • The state, including its agencies and political subdivisions, could not deny or interfere with abortion in those circumstances. The bill also declares rights to choose or refuse birth control and abortion.
  • A provider acting within their scope of practice could provide an abortion as allowed by the bill. Providing an abortion outside those limits would be a misdemeanor, punishable by up to one year in jail, a fine of up to $5,000, or both.
  • The state could regulate abortion only when a rule is medically necessary to protect the patient’s life or health, consistent with established medical practice, and the least restrictive available option.
  • If a state-funded or state-administered program provides maternity care, it would have to offer substantially equivalent benefits, services, or information to eligible people seeking to end a pregnancy.
  • A person or private medical facility that objects could not be required by law or contract to take part in an abortion. Employment and professional privileges could not be denied because someone participates or refuses.
  • The bill would repeal several existing statutory sections. The available material does not include those sections, so their current effect cannot be verified.

What it means for you#

  • People seeking an abortion: If enacted, the bill would bar state interference before viability or when abortion is needed to protect the person’s life or health. The bill does not set out an application or approval process. It says a person on whom an abortion is performed or attempted cannot be criminally punished under this act.
  • Providers: Physicians, physician assistants, advanced practice registered nurses, and other health care providers acting within their scope of practice could provide abortions allowed by the bill. A provider’s good-faith judgment about viability or risk to life or health would be a complete defense in a case under the act.
  • People and facilities that object: The bill would not require a person or private medical facility to participate in an abortion if they object. It would protect people from employment or professional-privilege discrimination based on participation or refusal.
  • People using state programs: If a program provides maternity care, the state would have to provide substantially equivalent abortion-related benefits, services, or information to people otherwise eligible. The bill does not specify what those services would be.
  • State and local government: The bill would restrict abortion regulations and prohibit discrimination in the regulation or provision of benefits, facilities, services, or information related to the stated rights. It does not create a new agency.

Money#

No cost estimate is provided. No publicly available information.

  • The bill would require certain state programs that provide maternity care to also provide substantially equivalent abortion-related benefits, services, or information. The cost is not stated.
  • The bill provides no appropriation, staffing estimate, or estimate of possible fines collected.

What is unclear#

  • The supplied material does not include the current text of the sections the bill would repeal, so it is not possible to verify what changes those repeals would make to current law.
  • The bill does not define “health” or specify how a person’s health risk would be assessed.
  • It does not say how the state would decide whether benefits, services, or information are “substantially equivalent.”
  • It does not set out oversight, reporting, complaint, or appeal processes.
  • It does not explain how the birth-control rights stated in its public policy section would be enforced.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to protect access to abortion before viability and when needed to protect a person’s life or health, while setting limits on state interference.
  • Requiring abortion-related benefits in programs that provide maternity care could make those programs offer options for both continuing and ending a pregnancy.
  • Limiting regulations to medically necessary, established practices and the least restrictive available option could reduce rules that impede care without protecting health.

Case against#

  • The bill leaves key terms and implementation details open, including what counts as a health risk and what makes program benefits “substantially equivalent.”
  • A provider’s good-faith judgment would be a complete defense in a case under the act. The bill does not explain how that standard would be assessed before a case reaches court.
  • The bill would repeal existing statutory sections, but the supplied material does not show what protections, restrictions, or processes those sections contain.