Protect Student Expression in Schools

Summary#

HB-159, “Safeguarding personal expression at K-12 schools,” would create student-expression protections and amend the Wyoming Governmental Claims Act. Its stated goal is to protect speech and expression by students at schools. The bill failed, so it did not become law.

  • A school could not discriminate against or penalize a student for religious, political or ideological speech when other similarly situated students may speak in the same time, place and manner and to the same extent.
  • Students could express those viewpoints in class, assignments, gatherings, clothing and jewelry, subject to the bill’s limits and, for assignments, ordinary academic standards and legitimate pedagogical concerns.
  • Student clubs could get the same access to facilities, benefits and privileges as other school-authorized clubs. Schools could not discriminate based on a club’s viewpoints or its rules for leaders and members to affirm its beliefs, follow its conduct standards or further its purpose.
  • The bill would let a person or student club whose rights were violated sue for relief, including attorney fees and damages. A successful claimant would receive at least $5,000 in damages.
  • The bill would make a school liable for damages for a violation and waive immunity for related suits in federal court.

What it means for you#

  • Students: If enacted, the bill would protect specified expression at school, but would not require any student to speak or join a club. Schools could still restrict expression that is not protected by the First Amendment, meets the bill’s harassment standard, or involves certain disruptive conduct.
  • Student clubs: Clubs could seek equal access and benefits and could set rules for leaders or members based on the club’s beliefs, conduct standards or purpose. A club whose rights were violated could bring a claim.
  • Schools and school systems: They would have to follow the bill’s rules and could face lawsuits and damages for violations. The bill does not create an application, complaint-review or appeal process within schools.
  • Private schools: The bill’s definition of “school” excludes privately run schools.

Money#

No cost estimate is provided in the available material.

  • A school found liable could have to pay damages, attorney fees and costs. The bill sets a minimum award of $5,000 for a successful claim.
  • The bill does not specify new funding, staffing or a public program.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not define “ideological” expression or “legitimate pedagogical concerns.”
  • It does not set out how schools should handle complaints or decide whether expression crosses an exception.
  • The bill refers to another education-law provision to define schools, but that provision and current law were not supplied. I could not verify how the bill’s coverage compares with existing law.
  • The bill’s relationship between the $5,000 minimum and damages under the Governmental Claims Act is not fully clear from the supplied text.
  • The bill does not explain how its federal-court immunity waiver would apply to different kinds of schools.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to prevent schools from treating students differently because of religious, political or ideological viewpoints.
  • Equal access rules for student gatherings and clubs could give students a clearer basis to organize and express views at school.
  • The bill expressly allows schools to address certain unprotected, seriously harassing or disruptive expression, rather than making all expression immune from school rules.
  • A right to sue could give students and clubs a way to seek a remedy when the protections are violated.

Case against#

  • A possible concern is that undefined terms such as “ideological” and “legitimate pedagogical concerns” could leave schools and courts uncertain about what the rules cover.
  • The minimum $5,000 damages award, plus possible attorney fees and costs, could expose schools to significant legal costs; the bill provides no estimate of those costs.
  • The bill does not provide a school-level process for resolving disputes, so disputes may proceed directly to legal claims.
  • The broad protections for club membership and leadership rules could create conflicts with other school policies; the bill does not explain how such conflicts would be resolved.

Votes

3 recorded votes on this bill, newest first.

  1. Division No. 1642244

    Passed59 members voted

    3rd Reading:Passed 52-7-3-0-0

    FOR · 52AGAINST · 7

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    52For

    • Republican50
    • Democratic2

    7Against

    • Democratic4
    • Republican3

    3 members were paired and sat out the vote.

  2. Division No. 1638045

    Passed8 members voted

    H04 - Education:Recommend Do Pass 7-1-1-0-0

    FOR · 7AGAINST · 1

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    7For

    • Republican7

    1Against

    • Republican1

    1 member was paired and sat out the vote.

  3. Division No. 1633744

    Passed61 members voted

    Introduced and Referred to H04 - Education 46-15-1-0-0

    FOR · 46AGAINST · 15

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    46For

    • Republican44
    • Democratic2

    15Against

    • Republican11
    • Democratic4

    1 member was paired and sat out the vote.