Literacy screening mandated for early grades

Summary#

HB-142, “Literacy screening assessment and intervention,” would create a new literacy law and repeal the existing reading assessment and intervention program in Wyoming law. It would require school districts to screen students, provide literacy instruction and interventions, and report progress. Its stated goal is for 80% of students in kindergarten through grade three to be at low risk for reading difficulties; that is a goal, not a guaranteed result. The bill failed and did not become law.

  • Districts would screen all students in kindergarten through grade three three times a year. Students in grades four and five would be screened if they scored below proficient in English language arts on the prior year’s statewide assessment.
  • Districts would provide evidence-based core literacy instruction in kindergarten through grade five and evidence-based interventions for students identified as at risk. Interventions could not take place during core literacy instruction.
  • For a student at the highest risk level, the district would have to offer the most intensive intervention and an individual reading plan, but only with written parent or guardian consent. Without consent, the student could receive classroom-based supports.
  • Districts would keep intervention records and report screening results, student risk data, and literacy resources to the state. Schools missing the 80% goal, or not improving toward it over three years, would need improvement plans.
  • The state superintendent would identify approved screening tools and recommended diagnostic assessments. The bill would also require literacy professional development and, starting in 2029–30, districts to employ or consult at least one person with a specified literacy endorsement.

What it means for you#

  • Students and families: Families of students whose results show high risk would receive the results and an explanation. The most intensive intervention and individual reading plan for a student at the highest risk level would require written consent. Students with an IEP or English language plan that addresses reading difficulties would not need additional documentation under this provision.
  • Schools and districts: Districts would have new screening, instruction, intervention, record-keeping, reporting, and staffing or consultation duties. The bill would require districts to collect and report data, but does not set out an application or appeal process for families.
  • Teachers and other district employees: Some employees providing instruction in kindergarten through grade five would need at least 14 hours of annual literacy professional development until they obtain a specified endorsement. Starting in 2026–27, employees who provide or support instruction in those grades, and employees holding the listed endorsements, would need at least 3.5 hours every three years.
  • State government: The state superintendent would make rules, identify screening tools, and set procedures for corrective action against districts that fail to improve after three years on an improvement plan.
  • Current law: The bill would repeal the existing reading assessment and intervention program, but the current law’s text was not supplied. I could not verify which requirements would be new compared with that program.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill would require districts to provide staff professional development and, from 2029–30, employ or consult a person with one of three literacy endorsements. It gives no cost estimate or funding source.
  • It would require the state education department to collect statewide data and the state to develop rules. No staffing or cost estimate is provided.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not define “evidence based,” “high risk,” or “low risk” in the supplied text. Rules would guide screening-tool selection, but the bill does not spell out all criteria.
  • It is unclear what happens if a parent or guardian does not consent to the most intensive intervention beyond the option of classroom-based supports.
  • The bill does not specify how districts should handle differences in screening tools or ensure results are comparable across districts.
  • The bill does not give details on how corrective action would work, or what consequences it could include.
  • The current text of the repealed program was not supplied, so the extent of the change from existing law is unclear.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to identify reading difficulties early through repeated screening, then connect students identified as at risk with targeted interventions.
  • A possible argument for the bill is that requiring core instruction in specific literacy skills across grades could give districts a clearer statewide direction.
  • Regular reporting and improvement plans could help districts and the state see where students are not meeting the stated goal and what instruction or professional development districts plan to change.

Case against#

  • One concern is that the bill would create substantial district duties for screening, records, reporting, training, and staffing without providing a cost estimate or funding source.
  • The bill’s most intensive intervention and individual reading plan for students at the highest risk level would depend on written consent. A possible trade-off is that the bill’s strongest intervention requirement would not apply without that consent.
  • The 80% goal and corrective-action process could put pressure on districts, but the bill does not fully explain how risk levels are set or what corrective action means.
  • Because the current program’s text was not supplied, it is unclear whether the bill would add major new requirements or replace requirements that already exist.

Votes

The recorded vote on this bill, member by member.

  1. Division No. 1630917

    Defeated60 members voted

    Failed Introduction 30-30-2-0-0

    AGAINST · 30FOR · 30

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    30Against

    • Republican30

    30For

    • Republican24
    • Democratic6

    2 members were paired and sat out the vote.