Reading plans could require grade retention

Summary#

SF-178, “Fixing reading failure,” would amend Wyoming’s education laws, including the reading assessment and intervention program in W.S. 21-3-401. Its stated goal is to improve students’ reading performance; it did not become law because it failed third reading, so these changes are not in effect. The current versions of the laws being amended were not supplied, so I could not verify which program rules would be new and which would continue existing law.

  • Districts would follow different reading-screening and intervention rules depending on whether they meet the bill’s “high performing” test: at least 60% of grade-three students scored proficient or advanced in at least two of the previous three school years.
  • For districts not meeting that test, the bill would require screening at least three times a year in kindergarten through grade three, evidence-based reading instruction and interventions, and individual reading plans for students identified as needing further help.
  • The bill would set parent-notice and reading-plan rules, and, on a phased schedule, provide for retention in grade three or four in specified cases. Some plans could include private tutoring, but only with a parent’s written consent.
  • Parents could sue districts over missed notices or required plans, or plans they say do not reasonably address a student’s reading difficulties. Courts could order specified remedies; some damages would be capped.
  • The bill would create an operations research staff inside the Department of Education, not a separate agency. The state superintendent could assign its work, select districts for management audits, and use certain hiring powers outside the state personnel system.

What it means for you#

  • Students and parents: In districts not identified as high performing, parents would get screening results when a student shows signs of reading difficulty or lacks appropriate reading competence. Individual plans would begin on a phased schedule. Parents could comment on plans and ask to include grade retention in kindergarten through grade two; grade-three and grade-four retention rules would start later.
  • Parents of students in grade three or four: For specified basic or below-basic assessment scores, districts would have to invite parents to discuss a reading plan. In a non-high-performing district, if the parent and district cannot agree on an alternate grade-three plan, the plan must include retention. Grade-four plans must include retention, with exceptions for certain students.
  • School districts: Districts would have to meet the screening, intervention, notice, planning, and reporting duties that apply to their status. The bill would also expose districts to the lawsuits described above.
  • Teachers: A certified teacher who fraudulently, dishonestly, or unfairly helps students perform on reading screeners or state assessments could face suspension or revocation of certification. The bill provides for a hearing, subject to an exception referenced in the amended law.
  • Taxpayers and the public: The Department of Education would have an operations research staff and broader staff-management powers for the superintendent. The bill does not create a separate front-line reading service.

Money#

The bill authorizes staffing and some district-paid interventions, but no total cost estimate is in the available material.

  • The superintendent could use Department of Education staff and transfer funds for the staff’s duties. Outside consultants could be used only to the extent funds are appropriated.
  • Reading plans could include private tutoring, with parent consent; the bill says the district would secure and pay for it when included.
  • Some successful parent lawsuits could lead to district payments. Damages for certain failures are capped at the prior year’s average Wyoming state and local spending per pupil; attorney’s fees and court costs are capped at $10,000, with no attorney’s fee award if the parent’s fee depends on the case’s outcome.

What is unclear#

  • The current text of the laws being amended was not provided, so the available material does not show how much of the reading program or teacher-certification rule is new.
  • The bill does not define several important terms, including “effective,” “appropriate reading competence,” or what it means to “read well enough.”
  • It does not set out a full process or timeline for resolving parent-district disagreements before a lawsuit.
  • It does not estimate staffing, intervention, tutoring, or legal costs, or specify how much funding the operations research staff would receive.
  • The bill sets different duties for high-performing and other districts, but does not explain how those requirements would interact with other existing programs.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to identify reading difficulties early and require regular screening and interventions, rather than waiting for later grades.
  • Individual reading plans could set out a student’s specific needs, goals, services, and progress checks.
  • Parent notice, opportunities to contribute, and court remedies could give families a way to address missed duties or plans they believe are inadequate.
  • The high-performing-district category could allow different program choices for districts meeting the stated performance measure.

Case against#

  • Required grade retention for some students, especially when a parent and district cannot agree on an alternate grade-three plan, could limit flexibility to choose another intervention.
  • The bill creates potential lawsuits over notice and plans without fully specifying how disagreements should be handled first; that could add costs for districts and families.
  • The performance cutoff and undefined terms may leave important decisions dependent on rules or later judgments not set out in the bill.
  • The new staff, hiring exemptions, and authority to transfer funds could shift resources and decision-making within the Department of Education, but the bill gives no cost estimate or detailed oversight process.

Votes

2 recorded votes on this bill, newest first.

  1. Division No. 1487679

    Defeated30 members voted

    3rd Reading:Failed 6-24-1-0-0

    AGAINST · 24FOR · 6

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    24Against

    • Republican22
    • Democratic2

    6For

    • Republican6

    1 member was paired and sat out the vote.

  2. Division No. 1482712

    Passed5 members voted

    S04 - Education:Recommend Amend and Do Pass 3-2-0-0-0

    FOR · 3AGAINST · 2

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    3For

    • Republican3

    2Against

    • Democratic1
    • Republican1