Leasing reviews for large industrial projects

Summary#

HB-148, the Land, Water and Fiscal Integrity Act, would amend Wyoming’s state-land leasing statutes. It did not become law: its status is Failed. Its stated goal is to review certain large industrial projects on state lands for possible risks and benefits to state land trust beneficiaries.

  • It defines a “utility scale industrial project” as a project on state land, other than one producing coal, oil, gas or other minerals, with a capital cost of at least $15 million, a footprint of at least 320 acres, or both.
  • If county commissioners request it, the state Board of Land Commissioners must hold a public hearing in the county before leasing state land for such a project.
  • The Board could not authorize or renew a lease for such a project without the bill’s specified conditions and a written analysis of potential effects on nature-based tourism and local property-tax revenue.
  • The analysis would have to address viewsheds, national trails and private property; include a Wyoming Game and Fish Commission report on critical big-game migration corridors; and summarize submitted testimony from county officials and certain property owners.
  • If the project would extend above the natural horizon visible from a national historic trail, the applicant would have to submit a visual mitigation plan before lease approval. For a long-term lease, rules would also have to require a decommissioning-cost bond, with the amount set by the Board.

What it means for you#

  • The public: If county commissioners requested a hearing, the Board would have to hold one in the county where the state land is located. The bill does not require a hearing in every case.
  • Applicants and lessees: The requirements would apply to projects meeting either size threshold, except projects producing coal, oil, gas or other minerals. A lease would not be barred outright, but approval or renewal would be subject to the bill’s conditions. For long-term leases, the lessee would have to deposit a bond for decommissioning costs.
  • Nearby property owners and county officials: The Board’s analysis would have to summarize testimony they submit in the categories specified by the bill. The bill does not guarantee that their views would determine the lease decision.
  • State land beneficiaries: The bill identifies their benefit as a concern for review, but does not guarantee a particular financial or other outcome.
  • Current law: The supplied materials do not include the existing statutes, so I could not verify which review, hearing, or notice requirements already apply.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill would require a bond for decommissioning costs for long-term leases; the Board would determine the amount. No amount is given.
  • Applicants might have costs for a visual mitigation plan or radar-activated aircraft detection lighting, if required. The bill gives no cost estimate and does not say who decides whether the lighting system is required.
  • The bill gives no estimate of government staffing or analysis costs, and specifies no appropriation.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not define “material concern,” “material adverse impact,” or “long-term” for these requirements.
  • It does not explain how the Board would weigh the analysis, testimony, tourism impacts or property-tax effects when deciding whether to approve a lease.
  • It does not specify who decides whether aircraft detection lighting is required.
  • The bill requires summaries of testimony that is submitted, but does not set out a broader public-comment process or decision timeline.
  • The bill includes a 30-day notice requirement in the amended text, but the supplied materials do not show whether that requirement is new or already in current law.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that large projects on state land could affect public views, wildlife corridors, nearby property and local tax revenue, so reviewing those effects before leasing may help the Board make better-informed decisions.
  • County hearings and summaries of local testimony could bring information about planning, zoning and nearby property impacts into the decision.
  • A decommissioning bond could provide financial security for cleanup costs, though the bill does not specify its amount.

Case against#

  • The bill requires analysis and reports but does not set clear standards for how the Board must weigh them. That could leave important decisions to the Board’s judgment.
  • The bill does not require the Board to reject a project when the Game and Fish Commission reports a material concern; it requires written reasons if the Board approves it.
  • The project thresholds could cover projects based on cost or land area, but the bill does not explain why those particular thresholds are used.
  • The bill could add costs and delay for applicants and government offices, but the available material does not estimate either.

Votes

The recorded vote on this bill, member by member.

  1. Division No. 1633743

    Passed60 members voted

    Failed Introduction 36-24-2-0-0

    FOR · 36AGAINST · 24

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    36For

    • Republican36

    24Against

    • Republican18
    • Democratic6

    2 members were paired and sat out the vote.