Expanded family leave to cover more relatives

Summary#

The Caring for All Families Act would amend the Family and Medical Leave Act of 1993 (FMLA) and federal employee leave rules in title 5 of the U.S. Code. It would expand who employees may take leave to care for and add a separate leave entitlement for family and school-related needs; its stated goal is to allow leave for a broader range of family relationships and activities. The bill has been introduced and referred to committees; it is not law.

  • For FMLA-covered employees and federal employees, it would expand care leave for someone with a serious health condition to include domestic partners and a wider range of relatives, including adult children, in-laws, grandparents, grandchildren, siblings, aunts, uncles, nieces, nephews, and certain people with a family-like bond.
  • It would also include a child of an employee’s domestic partner in the definition of “child.” The bill’s expanded family definitions also apply to leave involving covered servicemembers.
  • It would create additional leave of up to 4 hours in any 30-day period and 24 hours in a 12-month period for certain school or community activities, routine family medical care, and care needs of an elderly person with a family-like bond. This leave is in addition to other leave under the relevant laws.
  • The new leave could be taken intermittently or on a reduced schedule. Employees generally must give 7 days’ notice, or as much notice as practicable if 7 days is not practical.

What it means for you#

  • Employees: If you meet the applicable law’s eligibility rules, the bill would let you seek care leave for the newly listed relatives and family-like individuals when they have a serious health condition. It would not create a process for every case to be approved automatically.
  • Employees and federal employees with school-age children or grandchildren: You could use the additional leave for qualifying activities sponsored by a school or community organization. The bill defines schools to include elementary and secondary schools, Head Start programs, and state-licensed child care facilities; community organizations must be private nonprofits representative of a community or a significant part of one.
  • Employees seeking family wellness leave: The leave can cover routine medical or dental appointments for you, your child, spouse or domestic partner, or grandchild, and care needs of an elderly person with a family-like bond, including visits to nursing or group homes.
  • Private-sector employers: For this additional leave, an employer may require use of accrued paid vacation, personal, or family leave. For the medical-care part, an employer may also require accrued paid medical or sick leave—but the bill does not require employers to provide paid sick or medical leave where they do not normally provide it.
  • Federal employees: You may elect to use accrued annual or sick leave for the additional leave. The bill does not give the employing agency the same power to require that substitution.
  • General public: The bill does not create a new agency, tax, or paid-leave benefit. It would amend existing leave laws and extend their employment and benefits protections to the expanded care-leave categories.

Money#

No cost estimate or fiscal analysis is included in the supplied material.

  • The bill sets leave entitlements but does not provide a public spending amount or funding source.
  • Employers may have to administer expanded leave and, in some cases, allow or require use of employees’ accrued paid leave; no cost estimate is provided.
  • Federal agencies would administer the new leave and substitution rules; the bill gives no staffing or cost estimate.

What is unclear#

  • The FMLA and title 5 parent statutes were not supplied, so the exact current-law baseline and all differences from current law could not be independently verified.
  • “Elderly” and a “significant personal bond” that is like a family relationship are not further defined. The bill does not set a decision process for determining whether a person qualifies under the family-like relationship test.
  • An employer may require certification for the additional leave, but the details depend on rules the Secretary of Labor may issue. The bill does not set those rules or a timeline for them.
  • The bill gives no start date and does not explain how the new leave would interact with other workplace leave programs.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that people may provide care to close relatives and family-like individuals beyond the narrower relationships named in existing law.
  • Separate leave for routine care and school or community activities could let employees address those needs without using the leave allotted for other FMLA purposes.
  • The annual and 30-day caps, notice rule, and scheduling requirement for medical-care leave set limits while allowing some flexibility.

Case against#

  • The family-like relationship test and the term “elderly” could be difficult to apply consistently, while the bill does not set a process for resolving disputes.
  • The additional leave is capped at 24 hours a year. That may not cover every need the bill recognizes.
  • For private-sector employees, the leave is not a new paid benefit; employers may require workers to use accrued paid leave, reducing the time available for other uses.
  • Employers and agencies may face added administration, including certification and eligibility questions, but the bill provides no cost estimate or detailed rules.