Lawsuits for Nonconsensual Intimate Image Capture

Summary#

The Sue VOYEURS Act would amend Title XIII of division W of the Consolidated Appropriations Act, 2022, by adding a federal civil lawsuit for certain non-consensual captures of intimate images. Its stated goal is to authorize affected individuals to sue; the bill is not law, and passage is uncertain.

  • A person could sue if someone captures their intimate visual depiction without consent, knowing they did not consent or recklessly disregarding that fact, while they had a reasonable expectation of privacy.
  • The claim would also have to meet at least one listed federal connection: for example, travel or communications involving interstate or foreign commerce, a related payment, use of equipment that traveled in commerce, or conduct in or affecting commerce. The list also covers conduct in U.S. maritime or territorial jurisdiction, territories, and possessions.
  • “Capture” includes recording by any means and electronically broadcasting an image. The bill defines intimate depictions to cover specified private areas, bodily sexual fluids, and sexually explicit conduct, with limits for images made in public.
  • A successful plaintiff could seek actual damages or $150,000 in liquidated damages (a set amount), for each depiction captured, plus reasonable legal fees and litigation costs. A court may also order a person to stop displaying or disclosing the image.
  • For a person under 18, incompetent, incapacitated, or deceased, specified representatives may assume the person’s rights. A defendant cannot be appointed as that representative. The bill excludes surveillance by law enforcement under a lawfully issued warrant.

What it means for you#

  • People whose images are captured: If the bill became law, you could bring a federal lawsuit if the bill’s consent, privacy, knowledge or recklessness, and commerce conditions are met. The bill does not require you to show that the image was shared publicly.
  • People who capture images: You could face a civil claim and, if liable, damages, legal fees, costs, or a court order restricting display or disclosure. The bill does not create a criminal penalty.
  • Family members and other representatives: In the listed cases involving a person under 18, incompetent, incapacitated, or deceased, an eligible representative could bring the claim on that person’s behalf.
  • Courts: A court may allow a plaintiff to use a pseudonym as part of an order protecting confidentiality; this is not automatic.
  • Current law: The supplied material does not include the 2022 Act’s current text, so it is not possible to verify what related protections already exist or how this new claim would interact with them.

Money#

No publicly available information.

  • The bill sets possible private damages at actual damages or $150,000 per depiction, and allows recovery of reasonable legal fees and litigation costs. It provides no estimate of how many cases or awards there might be.
  • The bill does not state a government spending amount or provide funding for staffing or enforcement.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not set a filing deadline or explain how courts should count separate depictions for the $150,000 amount.
  • It does not define “recklessly disregards,” “incompetent,” or “incapacitated.”
  • The bill does not explain how this claim would interact with existing federal or state claims. The supplied material does not include the amended Act’s current text.
  • The bill does not set out a process for claims beyond filing in an appropriate federal district court, or specify how courts should assess actual damages.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that it gives people a direct civil remedy for non-consensual intimate-image capture, not only for later sharing.
  • The ability to seek an order stopping display or disclosure could address ongoing exposure of an image.
  • Allowing recovery of reasonable legal fees and litigation costs may make it more practical for an individual to bring a claim.
  • The bill allows representatives to act for people who cannot bring a claim themselves, including minors and deceased people.

Case against#

  • One concern is that the set award of $150,000 applies per depiction, which could result in large liability when more than one depiction is involved; the bill does not explain how courts should count them.
  • The bill reaches a broad range of conduct connected to interstate or foreign commerce, including use of equipment that traveled in commerce or conduct affecting commerce. How those conditions apply in particular cases would be for courts to decide.
  • The bill does not explain how the new claim would overlap with existing laws, making the total legal consequences unclear from the supplied material.