Federal Penalties for Commerce-Related Violence

Summary#

The Freedom From Union Violence Act of 2025 would amend and replace the text of the federal Hobbs Act section on interference with commerce by threats or violence. Its title presents its goal as protecting people from union violence; the bill itself does not set out a separate goal statement. It has been introduced in the House and referred to the Judiciary Committee, so it is not law.

  • It would make it a federal crime to affect commerce through robbery or extortion, attempt or conspire to do so, or use or threaten physical violence to further a plan to violate the section. The maximum penalty would be a $100,000 fine, 20 years in prison, or both.
  • It would exempt conduct only if it meets all three conditions: it is incidental to otherwise peaceful picketing during a labor dispute; it consists solely of minor bodily injury or property damage, or a threat or fear of that minor harm; and it is not part of a pattern or coordinated activity involving violence.
  • It says conduct described in that exemption may be prosecuted only by state and local authorities. The wording also says the exemption means the federal prohibition does not apply to that conduct, leaving a potential tension about what “violation” state or local authorities would prosecute.
  • It would preserve federal jurisdiction even when the conduct also violates state or local law, or occurs during a labor dispute or in pursuit of a legitimate business or labor objective. It says the bill does not repeal, amend, or otherwise affect several named labor laws.

What it means for you#

  • Workers, unions, and employers: The bill would not require applications or create a process for reviewing labor disputes. But conduct tied to a dispute could still fall under the federal crime if it meets the prohibition and does not qualify for the narrow exemption.
  • People involved in picketing: The exemption is not a general protection for conduct during a labor dispute. All three listed conditions must be met. “Minor” harm and “incidental” conduct are not defined in the bill.
  • State and local authorities: The bill says they alone may prosecute conduct described in the exemption, though its wording about a “violation” is unclear.
  • The public: The bill would not create a new agency or program. It says existing laws named in the bill would remain in effect.

Money#

No public cost estimate is provided in the available material.

  • The bill sets a maximum fine of $100,000 for the federal crime, but does not estimate fine revenue.
  • It does not provide an appropriation or estimate the cost of federal or state and local enforcement.

What is unclear#

  • The bill replaces the existing Hobbs Act section, but the current section’s text was not supplied, so I could not verify which wording or rules would be new compared with current law.
  • The bill does not define “minor” injury or damage, “incidental,” “pattern of violent conduct,” or “coordinated violent activity.”
  • Its exemption says the federal prohibition does not apply to qualifying conduct, then says a “violation” involving that conduct may be prosecuted only by state and local authorities. The text does not explain this tension.
  • The bill does not provide a start date.
  • It does not explain how the new wording would interact in practice with the labor laws it says it does not affect.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that it would expressly allow federal prosecution of covered violence affecting commerce, even if the conduct also violates state or local law or occurs during a labor dispute.
  • The narrow exemption could leave ordinary, peaceful picketing outside the federal prohibition when any harm is minor and is not part of a pattern or coordinated violent activity.
  • The bill names labor laws it says it will not repeal, amend, or otherwise affect, which could help clarify that its purpose is not to replace those laws.

Case against#

  • One concern is that the bill allows federal jurisdiction over covered conduct during a labor dispute or in pursuit of a legitimate labor or business objective, while leaving key terms about the exemption undefined.
  • It is unclear how prosecutors and courts would apply the exemption’s three conditions, or resolve the conflict between exempting conduct from the federal prohibition and referring to it as a “violation.”
  • The bill does not estimate enforcement costs or explain how federal enforcement would work alongside state and local prosecution.