Forest Service Land Would Go to County

Summary#

S. 3095 is an original bill that would require the Secretary of Agriculture, acting through the Chief of the Forest Service, to transfer a Forest Service property to Perry County, Arkansas. Its stated purpose is to allow the county to use the property for public purposes, such as education and youth development.

  • If the county makes a written request within 180 days after the bill becomes law, the Secretary must convey the United States’ interest in about 0.81 acres and its improvements at 1069 Fourche Avenue, Perryville.
  • The exact land area and legal description would be set by a survey satisfactory to the Secretary.
  • The transfer would be without payment for the property, by quitclaim deed, and subject to existing valid rights and any other terms the Secretary considers appropriate to protect U.S. interests.
  • The county would pay the costs of the transfer, including any needed survey and required environmental, resource, or historic-preservation analyses.
  • The property could be used only for public purposes. If its use no longer meets that condition, the Secretary may choose to have it revert to the United States.

What it means for you#

  • Perry County: The county would have to request the property in writing within the 180-day window. It would receive the property without paying for the land, but would have to cover conveyance costs.
  • County residents: The bill would allow public-purpose use, including education and youth development. It does not require the county to provide a particular service or specify how the property must be used beyond that limit.
  • Federal government and taxpayers: The United States would transfer its interest in the property if the county meets the request deadline. The bill does not set a sale price or require payment for the property.
  • Public and county: The conveyance would not include a federal covenant or warranty about the property and improvements under the specified environmental law. The deed would also be subject to valid existing rights.

Money#

The bill gives no estimate of the transfer’s costs or the property’s value.

  • Perry County must pay all costs associated with the conveyance, including listed analyses and any necessary survey.
  • The county would not pay for the property itself.
  • No publicly available information.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not state what public-purpose uses, beyond giving education and youth development as examples, would qualify.
  • It does not set a process for deciding whether a use meets the public-purpose condition or how the Secretary would decide whether to exercise the reversion power.
  • The final boundaries depend on a survey; the exact acreage and legal description are not yet stated.
  • The bill does not estimate conveyance costs or explain what other terms the Secretary might impose.
  • The bill is not law. The 180-day request period would start only if it is enacted; passage is uncertain.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that it would let Perry County use Forest Service property for local public purposes without paying for the land.
  • The county’s obligation to pay conveyance costs would leave those costs with the recipient rather than requiring a federal payment.
  • The public-use condition and the possibility of reversion could help protect the property’s public purpose.

Case against#

  • One concern is that the United States would give up its interest in the property without receiving payment for the land.
  • The bill does not require a federal covenant or warranty about the property’s environmental condition, while making the county responsible for required analyses.
  • The public-purpose condition is broad, and the bill does not spell out how compliance would be monitored or when the Secretary would use the reversion power.
  • The Secretary could impose additional terms to protect U.S. interests, but the bill does not specify what those terms might be.