County Could Receive Forest Service Land

Summary#

H.R. 3187, titled “To require the Secretary of Agriculture to convey a parcel of property of the Forest Service to Perry County, Arkansas, and for other purposes,” would create a one-time property transfer, not amend an existing Act. Its stated goal is to transfer about 0.81 acres and its improvements to Perry County. The bill has reached the Senate calendar but is not yet law.

  • If Perry County makes a written request within 180 days after the bill becomes law, the Agriculture Secretary, acting through the Forest Service Chief, must convey the United States’ ownership interest in the parcel.
  • The transfer would be without a purchase price, by quitclaim deed (a deed that transfers the government’s interest without guaranteeing the title is free of problems), and subject to valid existing rights.
  • The exact acreage and legal boundary would be set by a survey satisfactory to the Secretary.
  • The Secretary may set other terms and conditions considered appropriate to protect the United States.
  • The County must pay all costs associated with the transfer, including any needed survey and required environmental, resource, and historic-preservation analyses.
  • The Secretary would not have to provide an environmental covenant or warranty for the property and improvements.

What it means for you#

  • Perry County: If it requests the property on time, it would receive the United States’ interest in the land and improvements without paying a purchase price. It must pay the transfer costs and would receive a quitclaim deed without the specified federal environmental covenant or warranty.
  • People with existing rights in the parcel: The transfer would remain subject to valid existing rights. The bill does not identify those rights.
  • Other residents and taxpayers: The bill would transfer federal ownership of this parcel. It does not set public access rules or directly change services, taxes, or benefits.

Money#

No cost estimate is included in the supplied material; no publicly available information is provided there about the likely total cost.

  • Perry County must pay the costs associated with the conveyance, including specified surveys and analyses when required.
  • The bill sets no purchase price for the property.
  • The material gives no estimate of the County’s costs or the federal government’s administrative costs.

What is unclear#

  • The bill gives no deadline for completing the transfer after the County requests it.
  • The exact acreage and boundaries depend on a survey satisfactory to the Secretary.
  • The Secretary may set additional terms to protect the United States, but the bill does not list those terms.
  • No publicly available information is provided in the supplied material about the parcel’s environmental condition, the existing rights attached to it, or the likely cost of required reviews.
  • The bill does not say what happens if the County does not request the transfer within 180 days.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that it would let Perry County obtain the parcel and improvements without paying a purchase price.
  • The County would gain ownership rather than have the Forest Service retain the property, while the Secretary could set terms to protect the United States.
  • The bill assigns the transfer’s costs to the County rather than specifying a federal payment for them.

Case against#

  • The United States would transfer its interest without receiving a purchase price, and the bill does not explain why that is the appropriate arrangement.
  • The County’s costs are unknown and could include surveys and several types of required analysis.
  • A quitclaim deed and the absence of a required federal environmental covenant or warranty leave the County without those assurances from the federal government.
  • The bill does not specify the Secretary’s additional terms or the transfer’s completion timeline.