Marjorie Michel (Lib.)10:05 a.m.
moved that Bill S-5, An Act respecting the interoperability of health information technology and to prohibit data blocking by health information technology vendors, be read the second time and referred to a committee.
She said: Mr. Speaker, I am very pleased to rise today to speak to Bill S-5, the connected care for Canadians act. Timely and secure access to personal health information is critical to saving lives and improving care for Canadians. This act is part of our government's plan to build up and protect the health care system and empower Canadians to have more control over their health.
The main focus of Bill S-5 is patient safety. When health care systems are not interconnected, they are not only inefficient, but they also pose a clinical risk for Canadians. Things like undetected allergies, incomplete medication history and lost or delayed test results can lead to misdiagnosis and potentially life-threatening consequences.
Even today, fewer than 13% of Canadians say they have electronic access to all their medical records. In Canada, in 2026, the fax machine remains the primary means for sharing health information between health care facilities. Only 52% of health care providers say that they share their patients' health information electronically outside their office. The main obstacle they cite is a lack of interoperability. Consider what that means for patients.
Patients should not have to remember their entire medical history or repeat it every time they consult a new health care provider. Furthermore, health care providers should not have to rely on incomplete information to make clinical decisions. A survey by the Canadian Medical Association found that 92% of practising physicians in Canada said that the lack of coordination between health care systems was hindering their ability to provide care. That is unacceptable, and it needs to change.
Through Bill S-5, we can make technology work for Canadians, improving lives, improving care and building a more efficient health care system ready for the future. Australia and the European Union have already implemented similar legislation or regulations. Their residents have benefited from connected health care for years. If we act now, we can ensure that Canadians have access to the connected care they need and deserve.
I would like to clarify what this bill would do. At present, the sharing of health information in Canada is hampered by the lack of common standards across the country. Bill S-5 would promote interconnected health care by requiring IT vendors in Canada's digital health sector to adopt common data standards. It would also prohibit data blocking.
Data blocking means restricting access to, use of or sharing of health information among authorized parties, such as patients and their health care providers, when privacy laws would otherwise permit it.
In other words, Bill S-5 would help identify the barriers preventing patients and their health care providers from securely accessing the health information they need, when they need it.
All of this would be achieved while preserving existing privacy protections and personal information safeguards.
Access to health information is not a matter of convenience. It is a necessity. Data saves lives, especially when a full medical history is needed in an emergency.
Let me share the stories of real patients and their families. They have experienced the devastating consequences of disconnected care in Canada. Theresa lost her son, Dan, who was only 17, after two visits to the emergency department. She believes real-time access to his file would have helped the family flag critical details sooner.
Another patient requiring an urgent surgical procedure outside her home province was compromised because the local medical team could not access vital records from her home province. Without this essential medical history, clinicians were unable to safely perform the procedure.
There is the story of Greg Price, whose legacy has been an inspiration for many of us working on this legislation. Greg was a healthy engineer from Alberta who faced systemic failures in our health care system. Like many others, he experienced delays due to poor coordination and inaccessible health information. He died of cancer in 2012. He was 31.
This is why today's legislation is so important. We need to break down those silos, so we are changing the rules and we are building the health data infrastructure Canadians deserve.
Bill S‑5 would also reduce the day-to-day administrative burden on our health care professionals. According to a survey conducted by the Canadian Medical Association, physicians report that they waste an average of 86 minutes a day searching for patient data. That is almost an hour and a half a day. Time spent printing and sorting documents is time that health care professionals do not spend on what they should be doing and what they want to do: caring for people.
Several OECD countries modernized their data laws years ago to allow for the secure transmission of health data, but Canada is lagging behind. This is important not only for patient care but also for the future of innovation within our health care system.
Canada has implemented a near-universal medical records system. Things have to change, especially in light of artificial intelligence. Realizing the transformative potential and the growing importance of artificial intelligence, the Government of Canada recently published Canada's new national artificial intelligence strategy, known as “AI for All”. Health and life sciences are one of the priority sectors under the strategy, given AI's potential to improve patient care, accelerate diagnostics and support the development of new treatments.
However, AI's effectiveness depends on the quality of the data it uses. To unleash AI's potential in the health care field, it must have access to anonymized, standardized high-quality data that can be used responsibly and shared in total safety.
With Bill S-5, we can create the standardized database that is essential to a modern health care system.
Fragmented digital health systems lead to costly requirements across various regions. Health information technology vendors have to build customized models to make their products work in every province and territory. This limits their ability to grow in the Canadian market. Vendors have been clear about the need to address interoperability challenges in Canada.
By establishing clear and consistent national requirements, Bill S-5 would make Canada more predictable and attractive for businesses in the digital health sector. Rather than having to adapt to different requirements in each province and territory, vendors could operate within a single internationally harmonized framework. This would reduce complexity while encouraging innovation and investment. It would also help Canadian businesses grow domestically and compete globally.
Canadians must also be able to trust that their personal medical records will be secure and protected. That is exactly what Bill S-5 aims to do. The bill would not amend federal, provincial or territorial laws governing the use of personal health information. Access to personal health information would continue to be governed by existing privacy laws, and only authorized users would be able to access their patients' medical records.
It is important to note that Bill S-5 also respects indigenous data sovereignty and will in no way alter the ownership, control or governance of the health data of first nations, Inuit, and Métis peoples.
As technology evolves, it is essential to protect Canadians' privacy. That is why our government has also introduced Bill C-36, the protecting privacy and consumer data act, to modernize Canada's private sector privacy legislation for the digital age. Bill C-36 reinforces our commitment to responsible innovation, economic growth, and the protection of Canadians' rights in the digital age.
Co-operation with the provinces and territories is key. I am already working with my provincial and territorial counterparts to develop the regulations. However, the federal framework will not apply to provinces and territories that already have similar conditions. I welcome our shared commitment to interoperable digital solutions that enhance connectivity in our health care system.
Gaps in access to and sharing of health data create unnecessary and unacceptable risks. Canadians continue to face challenges when navigating the health care system.
Canadians strongly support change and want better access to their own health data.
This bill is part of our government's plan to build up and protect the health care system and empower Canadians to have more control over their health.
This is great news for our country. That is why I am calling on all members of the House to work together to pass Bill S‑5.
I want to thank the Senate for voting to pass it.
Matt Strauss (CPC)10:30 a.m.
Madam Speaker, the minister 's enthusiasm for the bill is very well appreciated. The issue of health information technology is very near and dear to my heart, and not always in a happy way. Without naming any names of any particular institutions, one of the hospitals that I worked at for a long time foisted on physicians a health information technology solution without asking the physicians, the pharmacists or the nurses if they should do this or whether it was a good idea. They spent millions of dollars on it, and it frankly ruined our professional lives when it did not work at all.
It is important to have good intentions. It is important to be enthusiastic about those intentions, but it is really important that the solutions that end up hitting the ground actually work for the people who use them and for the people those professionals serve. We have to be really careful about a bill like this. The possibility of causing more problems than it solves is a real and present danger.
It is always a great honour to be in the chamber. It is always a great honour to speak on behalf of the people of Kitchener South—Hespeler. It is a great honour to give the Conservative response to the minister 's speech. This is, I believe, the first piece of legislation pertaining to health care in the 45th Parliament.
It has been a long time coming. It has been a year and a half. I am a bit sad to say this is a bill that is warmed over from the last Parliament, when it somehow did not make it through. It has been years coming, and for that reason I would hold it to an even higher standard than if it were invented de novo.
The bill before us today, Bill S-5, has the admittedly laudable goal of making it illegal for health information technology companies to engage in what the bill defines as data blocking, that is, stopping the exchange, or impeding the exchange, of personal health information between authorized health information technologies.
In sharp contradistinction to many of the government bills that we have been debating over this past month, or even this past week, this is a very short bill. I commend it for that reason. It is perhaps only five pages long, in one language. Even though it is easy to read the bill, which I am grateful for, it is very difficult for me to understand how it could, in fact, work.
I spent 95% of my clinical career in hospitals. There are three electronic medical record vendors that hospitals in Canada use very commonly: Epic, Cerner and Meditech. All three, I am sorry to say, are American companies. All three are subject to a 2016 law passed by the Obama administration called the Cures Act. My understanding is that the Cures Act is very similar, both in its intent and its operations, to the bill before us today, Bill S-5.
Of course, it would be ideal, internationally, that all three of these systems be able to transmit patient health information between each other, obviously with the consent of the patient involved, but it is a really hard problem. This morning, for instance, my office printer was on the fritz. I was unable to send data, this speech, from my computer to the printer in my office. I had to get a friend in the lobby to print it for me, and that is a much simpler problem than all of the health information in all of Canada.
Software vendors and Bill S-5 can have the best of intentions, but the problem of data interoperability is just a hard problem. Let us take, for instance, Meditech. Currently, Meditech has multiple products, multiple product families and different versions of each currently operating in the wild. There is Meditech 6.0, Meditech 6.1, Meditech Expanse, Meditech Expanse 2.1, Meditech Expanse 2.2. Different hospitals may choose to invest more or less money, or use one product family over another. They may choose to update whichever product family they are using often or not, depending on their own IT and human resources.
I imagine it is a full-time job, nay several full-time jobs, at Meditech headquarters just to make sure that its own systems can communicate with each other in an interoperable fashion. That is not for a lack of trying. How much work, how many people and how much money will it take to make the Meditech system talk to the Epic system, to make both talk to Cerner and to make all three talk to the 10 to 15 major players in the European market? How much of a barrier of entry to one day starting a Canadian competitor would all of this entail?
Let us drill down on a small part of the problem to understand the full scale of the problem. In my work as an ICU physician, any individual patient might have literally tens of thousands of data points stored in the EMR from just one day. Just their vital signs, such as heart rate, oxygen saturation, respiratory rate, body temperature and blood pressure, might be recorded and time-stamped continuously, providing thousands of data points before we even speak of medications, diagnostic imaging, clinical notes, blood work, etc.
Each of these data points has to be filed or coded in some agreed upon, legible way in order to be interoperable. Even to zero in on just blood pressure, there are multiple numbers that go into a blood pressure reading and different numbers one might want to store, such as the systolic, the diastolic and the mean arterial pressure. There are different ways of measuring a blood pressure, namely a sphygmomanometer or a blood pressure cuff, or invasive arterial monitoring. Sometimes we are measuring both continuously throughout the day.
One system might store, code and display the cuff systolic and the intra-arterial map every 15 minutes. My system might store, code and display only the cuff three times a day, or when an intra-arterial pressure is available, it might store that, superseding the other. It seems almost impossible to have a government regulatory body come in and say which one is correct. The sphygmomanometer, the intra-arterial blood pressure monitor, the EKG and the pulse oximeter all measure a patient's heart rate, and three of the four measure it continuously. How do we impose a system that ensures that each health vendor will store those in mutually comprehensible ways?
Let us consider a patient on continuous EKG monitoring. Literally every beat of their heart comes with multiple measurable waveforms depending on which EKG is looked at. Each monitoring system will come with different alarms and different ways of storing who responded to each alarm, how long the alarm went off, who turned it off and why they turned it off.
I cannot imagine setting one standard for how all of this ought to be captured. This is not like saying all smart phones have to use a USB-C plug. There are so many more inputs and outputs to a human body that constitute health information. When I speak of monitoring vital signs, I am speaking of a fraction of a fraction of all the forms of data that go into health and health care.
I have just now been speaking about electronic medical records, only one of the types of software we would find in a hospital. There are also prescription management systems, diagnostic imaging systems and scheduling systems, all of which contain personal health information. By the way, health care centres like hospitals are just one sort of organization that uses some classes of devices and some sorts of information technology on those devices.
Bill S-5 seems to seek to regulate all sorts of other devices. For instance, I am wearing an Apple Watch. It went off, and the Speaker got mad at me. It also stores personal health information of mine on it, such as my heart rate. If someone has a CPAP machine at home or a blood sugar monitor, the bill would seem to make demands on those device manufacturers as well.
This is just the present state of things. Health information technology is changing now at a faster and faster rate. A friend of mine runs an AI-powered ultrasound diagnostics start-up company for use by combat medics to see if a soldier in the field has a pneumothorax in real time. It is a pocket-sized device. It is an amazing invention. He worked so hard on it. He employs so many fantastic Canadian scientists who are designing it and making it better every day. I understand that he spends about 0% of his time making sure that whatever data is stored on that device in a battlefield somewhere can talk to Cerner, Epic and Meditech. He is trying to save lives by making something that has never existed before. How can he expect that whatever data his invention ends up outputting 10 years from now will be legible by these legacy systems?
I am hoping that this House will take seriously the scale of the problem that Bill S-5 is trying to make go away. As I said earlier in my speech, the bill closely follows the approach that the Obama administration took in 2016, 10 years ago. Did this approach work in that milieu?
If it pleases the House, I would love to table at some point a paper from November 2025 published in the Journal of the American Medical Association and written by Everson et al., entitled “EHR Interoperability Experiences Reported by Family Physicians”. The scientists surveyed more than 8,000 family doctors, asking them what their experience with health information interoperability has been like eight years after the Cures Act. I am sorry to say that despite the best of intentions, the results in this paper are dismal. Only 8% of the family doctors surveyed reported ideal interoperability. From my reading of the paper, it seemed that a majority of the doctors went so far as to give up on accessing outside clinical documentation. I hope we can talk more about this study at committee. Perhaps we could invite the authors of it to committee, should the bill succeed at second reading.
If it is the case that the U.S. administration, after eight years of trying, largely failed to regulate the big American health information technology vendors I mentioned, Cerner, Meditech and Epic, how can we expect that the Canadian federal government would succeed in regulating those same American health information technology vendors into making their systems interoperable? As I said, most Canadian hospitals use information technology from these American providers. Many of the Canadian hospitals I have personally worked at, however, cannot afford to use the latest systems or subscribe to the most up-to-date features from each of these vendors.
Is it really possible that Canadian regulators will be able to bully these gigantic corporations? Cerner is, in fact, by the way, the health information branch of Oracle, one of the largest tech companies in the world. Are we going to be able to demand that Oracle change what it is doing into solving what I fear may be an unsolvable problem when we are currently shopping in its bargain bin? Is it the case that the federal government has a good track record generally in the field of IT systems management? Who among us here could forget the $2.6-billion boondoggle that we now call the Phoenix pay system? Who could forget the $60-million arrive scam scandal? Who could forget the most recent scandal of all, the $300 million blown on the unworkable PrescribeIT program?
I, for one, am not going to forget the PrescribeIT scandal. I think anyone who is familiar with my parliamentary work knows about PrescribeIT by now, because it has been the biggest part of what I have been working on over the last year. In brief, not to belabour the point, as I know the health minister is very familiar with it, it was a 10-year-long attempt by an organization called Canada Health Infoway, which receives funding both from provinces and from the federal government, to solve a simple problem.
Ten years ago, when she introduced the legislation that gave the money for PrescribeIT, the minister of health at the time, Jane Philpott, called it the axe the fax program. Members are aware, of course, how much Liberals like rhyming three-word slogans such as axe the fax.
Right now, in our country, physicians fax prescriptions to pharmacies. That was the case in 2016 when Jane Philpott introduced the legislation. Canada Health Infoway spent $300 million and took 10 years to make just this small class of health information transfer digitally between a doctor's office or hospital and a pharmacy. We have investigated this matter at committee in some detail. To this day, I do not understand how it is that Canada Health Infoway invented something other than a digital fax, which has existed since 1998. Indeed, by its own admission, it invented nothing. It gave Telus $80 million to provide and manage the software platform, which already existed. That was a good deal for Telus. To this day, our study of this matter at committee having been truncated, I still have no idea what became of the other $220 million. It had a $300-million budget. It bought the software and had Telus managing it for $80 million. I do not know where the $220 million went.
After all of that money and all of that time, physicians and pharmacists in our country, by and large, refused to use the solution. Canada Health Infoway seems to have spent a decade designing, or not designing but ordering, a software solution from Telus, without bothering to check in with frontline workers whether they liked the product or whether they would agree to use the product. The product was free, and still over 95% of physicians in our country declined to use the product. That is really bad and frankly activates my PTSD from my home hospital, which had foisted an information management system on us all those years ago. Of all the dogs that have never hunted, the PrescribeIT dog really did not hunt. It was a free solution that 95% of physicians and pharmacists declined to take up.
With Phoenix, arrive scam and PrescribeIT, there is not a good track record. Maybe the federal government is about to turn over a new leaf and provide IT systems that work and that people want to use. I wish I could believe that, but do members know who it plans to put in charge of Bill S-5? Can anyone in the House guess? It is Canada Health Infoway, the totally corrupt organization that just blew $300 million on a failed solution. I know this is the Liberals' plan by word of mouth, but I also know it from Senate testimony. This bill is called Bill S-5 because it came from the Senate. It has already gone through Senate committee hearings, and that has been the clear message. They had the now interim CEO of Canada Health Infoway give testimony. It is their intention to oversee the regulation of this perhaps unsolvable problem.
For those who have not heard, Canada Health Infoway just fired its CEO because he came to the health committee to answer questions about PrescribeIT. He refused to answer the most basic questions about what he accomplished with his nearly $1-million salary. He would not even answer what his salary was. We had to get that information by other means. Its current CEO is the former vice-president, whom he hired.
The $300-million PrescribeIT boondoggle is not even Canada Health Infoway's total spend over the last decade. I believe the organization was in receipt of $1 billion of public money over this time, yet when we had the chair of the board at the health committee and I asked him what it accomplished with the other $700 million, he was unable to describe a single tangible achievement. This is a big problem. Even acknowledging that PrescribeIT did not work, acknowledging that the CEO of Canada Health Infoway was a big problem and acknowledging the extent to which the health minister took credit or did not for his dismissal, even after all that occurred, she planned to reward Canada Health Infoway with another $50 million of funding this year.
I came to question period week after week and asked why she would give it this money. To her credit, the minister halted that funding, acknowledging that this organization is in a serious state of disrepair. This is a big problem when we talk about Bill S-5. It is, to my understanding, still the Liberals' intention to have Canada Health Infoway lead the charge on regulating into existence a solution that is maybe not even possible when they have not accounted for the last $1 billion they spent.
Do I support Bill S-5 in principle? Of course I do. Of course health information technology should be interoperable. Of course no patient should ever have their care suffer because data transfer between institutions is hard. Do I believe that the government, with its track record of IT boondoggles and its track record with Canada Health Infoway, will succeed in getting this job done with this piece of very short legislation? I fear I do not. I want to hear more about it at committee. I certainly want to hear more from Canada Health Infoway on what its plan was, but I cannot say that I have great faith that it will work out.
Solving a problem like the one I have described is not a matter of intention. For instance, I do not want anyone in this country to be sad. If we were to make a law that no one is allowed to be sad anymore, it would not work. That was the question I asked the minister. She said it seemed to be the case that Bill S-5 would not even apply to Ontario because Ontario already has legislation with this intention. However, the reality in Ontario, as I described in my question, is not that health information technologies are interoperable. In the discussion and debate we have in this House, I would love for the government to explain why it will succeed where Ontario has failed if it already has similar legislation.
Marie-Hélène Gaudreau (BQ)11:00 a.m.
Madam Speaker, setting aside any knee-jerk reaction I might have as a Quebec sovereignist to Ottawa's centralizing tendencies, there remains the broader issue of administering care and, above all, administering health care. I fully recognize that the sharing of information is critically important in health care. We need to be able to prevent epidemics, understand population movements and anticipate the long-term effects. I fully understand the importance of having an accurate picture of the public health situation. Take HIV/AIDS, for instance. In a study currently being conducted by our committee, officials from the Public Health Agency of Canada told us yesterday that they were having difficulty compiling data on the current situation in Canada.
That is why I encourage the provinces to work together and, with Ottawa's support, establish an effective framework for information sharing and exchange.
Quebec, whether as a province or as a country, has every interest in having access to reliable public health data at the North American level. That said, we should not ask Ottawa to dictate to the provinces how health care should be managed. Let us leave that to the provinces, public health agencies and health departments to determine together whether a common road map is the best way to collaborate.
The ideal would be for them to pool resources and expertise, because responsibilities are shared and solutions are developed collaboratively. That is the beauty of sharing.
Bill S‑5 could simply be based on a truly asymmetrical relationship and an uneven partnership, one that is more natural and in keeping with our federation.
In this case, it is the means I am questioning, not the end. Federal legislation that forces us to take on a subordinate role tells Quebeckers that the federal government wants to be the master in their house, whereas we want to be masters in our own house.
On this budget day, I would like to remind the House that “Maîtres chez nous” is more than a slogan. It represents the hopeful spirit of the Quiet Revolution, our collective drive as Quebeckers to assert ownership of the tools to build a modern, forward-thinking state that is committed to social progress.
The Trudeau government essentially stole our ideas. One might say that it drew inspiration from ideas such as child care and pharmacare. What we are seeing from the current government is something altogether different. It is appropriating symbols of national aspiration and collective emancipation. That is profoundly insulting.
When Quebec chose to take its destiny into its own hands, it did not wait for the federal government. It just did it. We have been proving that for decades. We built our own institutions, established our own frameworks and charted our own course. Now that the work is done, the federal government wants to tell us what to do. It should do the opposite and ask the provinces how this worthy objective can best be achieved. Instead, the same old reflexes persist. Unless the government is prepared, and this is important, to amend its bill to include a preamble stating that Quebec remains the primary architect of its health policies, we cannot support such a bill.
It is worth noting that Quebec already has its own digital health information system, known as the Health Booklet. This system allows all Quebec patients to access their list of medications, medical imaging and lab test results, and the services they have received since May 2026. Quebec has begun rolling out digital health records in the Mauricie region, the Centre-du-Québec region, and the northern part of the Island of Montreal. This project will enable the Quebec health care system to gradually phase out outdated technologies such as—I am embarrassed to say—the fax machine, and contribute to the digital transition of Quebec hospitals.
Going forward, patients will be able to access their medical information, appointment history and medical records through Mon dossier santé.
If the federal government really wants to support health care, I have an idea: Release the money. Unfortunately, the federal government cannot manage our emergency rooms, our CLSCs, our labour relations, the delivery of care or the priorities of our health care system, so we have a request. Every single year, we ask for more money in the form of health transfers. We firmly believe that 6% a year, for a total of $14 billion over five years, is not too much to ask, given all the tax dollars collected by Ottawa.
Yes, it is no secret that Quebec's health care system faces challenges, but it is up to the Quebec government to make its own decisions in the best interests of Quebeckers, in consultation with stakeholders on the ground who understand the real needs. My riding of Laurentides—Labelle has three hospitals, the Mont-Laurier hospital, the Rivière-Rouge hospital and the Sainte-Agathe-des-Monts hospital. They have enormous funding needs. In all three cases, private foundations are stepping in to make up for the funding shortfalls. Why? It is because, unfortunately, the federal government is not doing its part.
When it comes to equipment, it is quite remarkable that the community had to mobilize all its efforts just to secure access to an MRI machine, and even a CT scanner, only a few years ago. Rather than allocating funds for patient care, the federal government is just managing programs and telling others what to do. The federal government does not run a single clinic. Everyone has their own area of expertise.
When I talk to people, I ask them whether they would prefer option A or option B. Option A involves adding another layer of administration to Quebec's health care system. Option B involves Ottawa sending Quebec money so that we can provide care. Option B wins every time, both among health care professionals and among the public. People know that they pay more in taxes than what is transferred back to Quebec, so it is simple. Unless amendments are made, the Bloc Québécois will be voting against Bill S-5.
I will conclude as I began it. The government needs to let Quebec and the provinces manage their own health care systems and make their own decisions. Yes, let us work in partnership, but not by making Quebec and the provinces subordinate. Let us not go further down the road of an imposed federalism. We have had enough encroachments on provincial jurisdiction. As I always tell my colleagues, whenever provincial jurisdictions are at stake, I will be relentless, and my answer will always be no.
Mario Simard (BQ)11:15 a.m.
Madam Speaker, before I start my remarks, I would like to note a recurring trend. We are seeing more and more bills here in the House that originated in the Senate. As members know, the time allocated for debate on a bill is not unlimited, so I find it somewhat curious that the government continues to place so many Senate bills on the agenda.
Let me turn now to Bill S-5. As my colleague from Laurentides—Labelle said earlier, its objective is certainly commendable. No one can argue with it. Unfortunately, however, this bill reflects a familiar tendency to believe that Ottawa knows best, that Ottawa knows better than the provinces what is good for them in areas under their jurisdiction, and that Ottawa possesses more expertise when it comes to implementing policies. I must say, it is getting a bit tiresome.
There is a major problem, as my colleagues have pointed out. Despite what the Minister of Health said earlier, nowhere does this bill explicitly recognize Quebec's and the provinces' exclusive jurisdiction over the organization of health care delivery or the fact that Quebec can choose to develop its own digital infrastructure. If the Bloc Québécois is to support such a bill, it must include an explicit recognition.
I would like to point out that, as my colleague from Laurentides—Labelle said earlier, the Government of Quebec has already indicated its intention to deploy its own digital health infrastructure. Unfortunately, this bill in no way reflects the autonomy that Quebec claims with respect to health care. Moreover, to my knowledge, Quebec has not committed to following the pan-Canadian interoperability roadmap. The major stumbling block in Bill S‑5 is that it does not respect jurisdictions.
To convince my colleagues of this, I will reread clause 7(1), which my colleague from Montcalm referred to earlier. I hope the Minister of Health will listen to us.
The Governor in Council may, by order, make any provision of this Act or the regulations applicable in any province or territory if the Governor in Council is satisfied, after applying the criteria and the process provided for in the regulations, that the province or territory does not have requirements that are substantially similar to or exceed those established under this Act.
What does that mean, ultimately? It means that Ottawa is leaving the door wide open to tell the provinces how they should act. That is why I said in my introduction that this is, once again, a form of centralizing federalism. I will not use the term “predatory federalism”, but this is yet another form of federalism that is heavily focused on allowing Ottawa to define what is right and what constitutes good health care within the provinces' areas of jurisdiction.
This is very clear, and I want to make that point clear to the minister. In theory, Bill S-5 might not apply to Quebec, as my colleague said, but we must still speak out against clause 7, which would allow the government, by order, to effectively override provincial laws in areas that fall under provincial jurisdiction.
Unless the government is willing to amend its bill, I do not see how the Bloc Québécois can support it. At the very least, a preamble should be added that clearly specifies that Quebec remains in charge of its health care.
However, today is budget day, and we are always happy on budget day. This bill gives me the opportunity to talk about something that is central to the Canadian federation, and we will see it reflected in the budget: the perennial problem of health transfers. If we want to fix health care, we need to solve the funding problem. Year in and year out, and during every election campaign, when Quebeckers and Canadians are asked what their priorities are, health care is usually one of their top priorities.
I want to go back to the issue of health transfers because, in the great history of Canadian federalism and the injustices and inequities in relations between Quebec and Ottawa, one thing is glaringly obvious. I am talking about the infamous fiscal imbalance.
For those who do not remember what that is, I will explain. The Government of Quebec delivers virtually all social services and, in fact, Ottawa delivers very few services. There is EI, but that is paid for by workers. There is OAS, which is a social program. Ottawa participates very little in terms of social programs, although it takes up 60% of the tax room.
In the end, Ottawa always has much more money than its responsibilities require, while Quebec and the provinces never have enough because they have a smaller tax base. That is the fiscal imbalance in a nutshell.
Instead of piling on more and more health initiatives, encroaching on an area under provincial jurisdiction, Ottawa should focus on making health transfers more predictable and unconditional.
We will see whether there is any good news in the budget and whether health care transfers will live up to the expectations of Quebec and the provinces. Right now, if we look at the big picture, Quebec is spending about 42% of its total budget on health care. Back in the 1960s, when the public health care system was first established, 50¢ of every dollar invested in health care came from the federal government and 50¢ came from the provincial government. Today, the federal government's share is estimated at barely 22%. That means that, for every dollar invested, 22¢ comes from the federal government. Quebec has to cover the rest, and the infamous fiscal imbalance comes into play, as I mentioned earlier.
That said, 42% of the Government of Quebec's budget is a huge share. That means that Quebec has only about 58% of its total fiscal capacity left to address essential priorities, such as education, poverty, infrastructure, municipalities and support for Quebec businesses. We have been fighting long and hard over health care transfers in Canada. In 1980, the Mulroney government made the first drastic cuts to health transfers.
Then came the famous Liberal era, when there were budget surpluses. Where did those budget surpluses come from? They came from the recurring cuts Paul Martin made to health care. In the wake of the 1997-98 referendum, $2 billion in recurring funding was cut from the provinces. Jean Chrétien boasted to the G7 that he had balanced the budget, which is pretty cynical, really, because he got his surpluses by cutting transfer payments to the provinces. He added that he would not have to pay the political price for this, because the public believed—members may recall Lucien Bouchard's shift toward outpatient care—that the governments of Quebec and the other provinces were to blame for the shortcomings in health care services. However, it was the federal government that had just insidiously cut transfer payments and that was not shouldering its share of responsibility for health care.
It is budget day. I hope the federal government will see the light. It needs to put an end to the predatory federalism and accept its share of responsibility for health transfers.
Maggie Chi (Lib.)11:30 a.m.
Madam Speaker, it is great to see you here today. I will be sharing my time with the member for Bourassa.
I rise today to support Bill S-5, the connected care for Canadians act, which is crucial to establishing a connected health care system in Canada.
In Canada, health information is fragmented and is scattered among hundreds of health information systems across family doctor offices, hospitals, walk-in clinics and pharmacies. Bill S-5 would break down these digital barriers so a patient's health information could move securely and seamlessly wherever they receive care. It means that patients would no longer have to physically carry medical records from one doctor's appointment to another or repeatedly explain their medical history every time they seek care.
Bill S-5 is also about making the health care system work better for Canadians. It would unlock the potential of standardized and anonymized health data to accelerate medical breakthroughs and improve health outcomes for all Canadians. Health information in Canada is often stuck in separate digital systems that cannot be easily shared, first, because of data blocking, a practice that prevents authorized users from accessing health data even when privacy legislation allows it, and, second, because of a lack of common standards. For example, one hospital's database could record a patient's blood type using a numeric code, another could use an alphanumeric code, and a third hospital might use a written description. All three could mean exactly the same thing, but without common standards, their computer systems might not recognize each other's blood type entries.
To address this, Bill S-5 would require health information vendors in Canada to adopt common standards and would prohibit vendors from data blocking. These standards would be set out and maintained through regulations, with requirements that would ensure secure access for patients within the protection of existing security law. This is the approach used in other jurisdictions as well, such as Australia, the United States and the European Union.
Bill S-5 would build on the shared pan-Canadian interoperability road map, already endorsed by provinces and territories, and on the working together to improve health care for Canadians plan, which committed nearly $200 billion over 10 years, with modernizing health data as one of four shared priorities.
When somebody sees a new doctor, they are asked for their medical history. Bill S-5 would enable patients and their doctors to access health records electronically, no matter where in Canada patients receive care. This is connected care. Doctors' being able to access electronic health records is critical to the continuity of care. Without a seamless exchange of information between systems and providers, the burden of health information falls to patients and their families. Moreover, the lack of access to a patient's medical records increases the risks of misdiagnoses, medication errors, duplicate testing and treatment delays.
Take, for example, patients in rural and remote communities or patients with very complex conditions who are referred to hospitals in major urban centres for advanced diagnostic procedures, complex treatments and highly specialized medical care. Oftentimes these patients arrive in serious condition, usually with photocopies of their health records, and the information is often incomplete. Patients with a language barrier or limited medical familiarity shoulder the burden of coordinating their own care because there is no digital connection between our health information systems. In all these cases, important health information is often missing or inaccessible. Unfortunately, this happens very often.
Bill S-5 would help support these patients with a more coordinated and integrated health care system, with accurate and accessible data so doctors can make clinical decisions with complete information and provide the health care Canadians deserve. In today's rapidly evolving world of medical research and innovation, large, high-quality data sets are the foundation of medical breakthroughs such as accelerating drug discoveries and enabling earlier disease detection. For example, the quality, quantity and representativeness of the data sets largely determines how accurately a health AI model performs in real-world settings.
Our government's national AI strategy, AI for all, recognizes data as a strategic national asset that must be responsibly stewarded and mobilized to support innovation and productivity across the economy. Our health care system generates a vast amount of health data, spanning diverse populations, medical conditions and care settings.
By leveraging our standardized and anonymized health data, Canadian researchers have an opportunity to become global leaders in medical research and health innovation, driving medical breakthroughs and improving health outcomes for all Canadians. Currently, much of this data remains fragmented in disconnected systems. By securely unlocking its potential by applying common standards, our medical researchers can drive breakthroughs in disease detection, treatment and improved hospital efficiency.
For example, in my riding of Don Valley North, we are fortunate to have North York General Hospital, Canada's top-ranked community academic hospital. It partnered with a Canadian health AI company, and by leveraging the data it has collected from the emergency department, it has trained an AI model that analyzes real-time patient vitals, waiting times, triage assessments and hospital capacity to identify where patients can receive care sooner. This has cut the average emergency wait time by nearly 28%.
Data can save lives. The knowledge that can be unlocked from our health data sets has the power to transform our health care system. Better health data means a more accessible and innovative health care system. That is why Bill S-5 is such a consequential piece of legislation, and I believe it is a practical path forward that would serve the best interests of all Canadians.
Abdelhaq Sari (Lib.)11:40 a.m.
Madam Speaker, I am pleased to have the opportunity to speak to Bill S-5.
I want to begin by having members imagine the following scene: A mother from Montreal North arrives at the emergency room with her son in the middle of the night. She knows his allergies, medications and most recent visits by heart, but the doctor on duty does not see any of that information on the patient's record. His record exists, but it is somewhere else, in another system, not in the system of this clinic, this CLSC or this hospital. It is in a different software program or sitting on a fax machine somewhere. As a result, his mother has to repeat the information over and over again. While she is doing that, time is being wasted, and sometimes much more than just time is lost.
Today, information can travel around the globe in a second, but it is still difficult for a patient's health records to make it across the street. Bill S-5 seeks to remedy that issue. We are talking here about what I would describe as the cost of working in silos, which can be explained in numbers, and those numbers speak for themselves. Four out of five patients want to be able to access their health care records digitally online. However, only 39% are able to do that, and often they can access only some of the information. In 2023, 42% of Canadians reported gaps in the coordination of their care because of systems that do not communicate with one another. Behind those numbers are tests that had to be redone, delayed diagnoses and doctors who are searching for information instead of providing care. There are also families that carry their own health records around in an envelope or even a plastic bag—I have seen it happen—because the systems do not communicate or share data.
Consider the people who provide care. Our doctors, nurses and pharmacists already work under tremendous pressure. Every hour spent filling out forms, waiting for a fax—yes, I did say a fax—or calling another clinic is an hour less spent with a patient. That is really the important thing. That is the service that we want to provide to our citizens. In a system low on resources, unnecessary paperwork is not just a detail; it is health care time wasted.
I would also call this compartmentalization an “opportunity cost”. It is a collective cost. It prevents us from fully understanding which policies work and which performance indicators are best for the work at hand. It prevents us from knowing where shortfalls exist, where to look for the best impact indicator, or how to locate the best efficiency indicator, simply because the systems do not communicate; they exist in silos, with less integration. When systems operate in silos, information is not only less integrated, but the lack of interoperability prevents us from attaining the global perspective we need to measure them properly. Without seeing a situation clearly, it cannot be corrected. Without a global view, improvement is impossible. What cannot be measured is difficult to quantify or even to improve.
Of course, inequalities still remain. Bill S‑5 does two simple but essential things.
First, it requires interoperability. Health information technology vendors will need to ensure that the systems they sell, license or supply as a service can talk to each other and communicate according to common Canada-wide standards, including information security standards.
Second, it prohibits data blocking. A vendor will no longer be able to lock a patient's information to keep its clients captive. Health data belongs to a patient's continuum of care, not to a vendor's business model.
Let us consider a simple example. When people switch phone providers, they get to keep their phone number. No one would consider that revolutionary today. It is taken for granted. It is simply the way things work. Why, then, should we accept that a person's medical history remains trapped in a particular software platform or IT solution? If we demand number portability for our phone service, then we certainly can, and should, demand the same for the health of our families.
I have spent a good deal of my career in IT governance and in business and corporate architecture. To be honest, technology is rarely the problem. More often than not, the problem and the challenge are cultural, including the absence of common rules. People build islands and then act surprised when there are no bridges connecting them. Bill S-5 represents an obligation and an opportunity to build those bridges.
Building bridges involves creating connections. However, connecting systems does not mean we want to expose our data. Some people will ask where Bill S‑5 stands on privacy. The answer is clear: It makes no amendment to any federal, provincial or territorial privacy law. The current rules on the collection, use and disclosure of data continue to apply as they always have. Only authorized users will have access to records. Bill S‑5 does not mandate the sharing of data. It allows for the secure transfer of information where such transfers are already permitted by law.
To reiterate, connecting systems does not mean data will be exposed. On the contrary, data will be better protected. Experts also see data integration as a way to enhance data security. When data is distributed, or even scattered, across multiple siloed systems, redundancy can result in inaccurate information being shared without the knowledge of the individual concerned.
We need to stop relying on a patchwork of systems that, in Quebec and elsewhere, are unfortunately quite outdated. The government is not trying to take control; it is proposing a partnership.
I want to speak directly to my colleagues from Quebec: Health care falls under provincial and territorial jurisdiction, and this bill respects that. It acts as a safety net where similar legislative measures do not exist. Quebec already has a well-developed interoperability regime, and common standards will be clarified in consultation with the provinces and territories.
We are not starting from scratch on this. Federal, provincial and territorial governments are already working together to develop a pan-Canadian interoperability road map, and Bill S‑5 does not seek to supplant that. Its purpose is to support, assist and accelerate the process.
There is also a real economic benefit. Adopting common standards reduces barriers to entry and enables Canadian digital health companies to grow, innovate and compete. Greater competition can foster more modern and potentially less costly solutions for our public health systems.
As for my Conservative colleagues, I know they share our commitment to improving the quality of data in order to make better-informed decisions. Bill S-5 is an essential step toward that objective. Let us be clear: The bill does not require anyone to adopt a single system, nor does it replace the tools that are already in use. It requires them to communicate and exchange information with one another. That approach is simpler, more flexible and more respectful of what each province has already built.
For me, this is a matter of fairness, first and foremost. When information does not follow the patient, it is always the same people who bear the consequences: seniors who are seeing multiple specialists; families living in rural and remote communities; and newcomers, including many in my own community. For a family in a rural or remote community, an electronic prescription, a referral to a specialist sent in a matter of seconds or a remote consultation with the correct medical records to hand can save them hours of driving, days of waiting and a great deal of worry.
In closing, let me go back to the mother from Montreal North who went to the emergency room in the middle of the night. Thanks to Bill S‑5, she will no longer have to be the system's memory. The doctor will have the information they need and her son will receive safer, faster and better coordinated care. Data saves lives and so does integration.
The Senate has carefully studied this bill. In the House, all the parties are saying that they want modern care. We need to ensure that we have the means to achieve our ambitions. Let us work together to pass Bill S‑5 quickly.
Tamara Kronis (CPC)11:55 a.m.
Madam Speaker, I will be splitting my time.
This bill is very easy for the people of Nanaimo—Ladysmith to associate with. To be diagnosed with a chronic illness in Nanaimo—Ladysmith really is to find out how transportation works in British Columbia, because we inevitably need to receive treatment not only in Nanaimo but also in Victoria, in Vancouver or sometimes in other places on the island. We know very well what the consequences are of medical information not being available where we receive our medical care. Those consequences include misdiagnoses, non-diagnoses, wrong medication and lower quality of care as a result.
The reason we need to receive health care all over the island and the mainland, and in some cases why we need to go to other places in our community, is that the Nanaimo Regional General Hospital, which is the main hospital in Nanaimo and the area, has about 345 hospital beds. However, I cannot remember a day when the number of patients in the hospital, when I have been there either visiting someone or for another reason, has been below 400.
This means that we travel for health care, and we know what happens when our medical records are not available. We understand the problems that come with needing to stop, find information and have it faxed over from one place to another. In B.C., in fact, we have more than 40 different electronic medical record systems, which are used across health authorities, specialists and family practices. We understand the consequences when those systems do not talk to each other.
The BC College of Family Physicians reports that more than 78% of doctors use between two and five systems. Believe it or not, that is actually by design, and it puts our lives in danger.
What this bill deals with is a phenomenon known in the health care world as “data blocking”. The minister admitted and said in her speech this morning that 92% of doctors in Canada have said that a lack of access to patient medical records hampers their ability to provide care. Health Canada has reported that only 29% of primary care providers share patient information electronically outside of their practice. That is one of the reasons the Canadian Medical Association and other medical health organizations have been calling for a decade or more for electronic medical records to be available where and when health care providers need them.
Dr. Margot Burnell, who is a previous Canadian Medical Association president, has described this as doctors facing “an uphill battle trying to provide timely patient care when they are routinely dealing with health systems that cannot communicate with each other”. That makes this bill a very long time coming. In fact, it is not the government's first attempt to bring this forward. Bill C-72 died on the Order Paper in the last Parliament because the Liberals decided that it was more important for them to go to an election.
We ask two questions on this side of the House. The first question is, what took the government so long? Why has it taken this long to bring in a bill that Canadians so badly need and that has been called for by patient advocates, by medical professionals and by patients? The other question is, why did it take the government 18 months to introduce this bill in the House when this bill so clearly needs to be implemented to save lives?
The next question we need to ask about a bill like this when it is being brought forward by the government is, what do we need to do to make sure it will get this right? We cannot afford another software debacle or failure in this particular case. We cannot afford for Canadians' medical records to become unavailable or get scrambled the way we have seen with so many other programs the government has tried to implement in the software space. Whether it is PrescribeIT, Cúram, or some of the other problems that we have had, we cannot afford to see that happen in this space.
In that context, it is distressing to have learned from the Senate's testimony here, and I believe my colleague recounted this earlier, that the government is considering hiring Canada Health InfoWay to administer this particular program. That is a situation where, given the management issues and health care issues with that organization, specifically those related to health care software in the past, Canadians may have some very reasonable concerns.
A second issue that I really believe we need to deal with at committee is a number of definitional concerns. The idea of contextual interoperability can mean different things in different circumstances. We must ensure that the data that travels in between systems, when the software interoperability is implemented, is seamless, is not another data dump, is readable on the other end and is usable.
Similarly, we need to ensure that there are clear definitions for terms such as “data blocking”, “good enforcement mechanisms”, and “real remedies for failure”. The Competition Bureau pointed out in 2022, which is another reason why we are asking why this is taking so long, that electronic medical record vendors were, in fact, blocking data deliberately. This bill is now targeting those problems, including vendor lock-in, data blocking and the unreadable data dumps I just discussed, so it is very important that the bill expand the information-blocking penalties to include hospital networks and authorities that sit outside of these systems and may further hamper interoperability.
The Senate committee on this bill recognized that vendors are only one part of a wider health data system and recommended that the government consider extending responsibility as I have described. I would recommend that the House committee that examines this bill take a look at that gap, because software can only make the record available. Someone still has to complete the referral, the transfer, and get it to the clinician who is taking over care.
Privacy is also something that needs a very precise answer with respect to this bill. Section 5 of the bill says that the interoperability duty does not require access, use or exchange where privacy law prohibits it, but clause 6's data-blocking prohibition has no equivalent expressed privacy law exception. I would note here that the Office of the Privacy Commissioner supports interoperability, but recommends that the ban be subject to privacy law. Therefore, the committee should examine and close that gap where appropriate so that a vendor is not treated as blocking information for refusing an exchange the law, in fact, forbids.
There is also a need to ensure that compliance costs are not so high as to prevent entry by new providers.
What I would say in closing, is that Bill S-5 would not build the tower that Nanaimo needs. It would not add the staff beds or the cath lab we need north of the Malahat. I will continue to advocate for those things both here in Ottawa and with provincial decision-makers in Victoria. However, this is a good start. I hope we will see the committee do good things with this bill and that it will come back to the House in a format we can support.
Jagsharan Singh Mahal (CPC)12:10 p.m.
Mr. Speaker, today, I rise on behalf of the great people of Edmonton Southeast to discuss Bill S-5, the connected care for Canadians act.
No Canadian needs reminding of the challenges facing our health care system. On this side of the House, we believe Canadians deserve timely, world-class health care when they need it, regardless of their financial circumstances, yet too many Canadians are waiting for a family doctor, a specialist appointment or a procedure that would allow them to return to work and live without pain. Canadians need better care. In many cases, their lives depend on it. While provinces and territories are responsible for delivering health care, the federal government has a responsibility to work constructively with them to improve access and support better outcomes.
Bill S-5 presents an opportunity to address one part of this challenge, the difficulty of sharing health information between the professionals responsible for a patient's care. The principle of this legislation is common sense. However, much more work is needed to ensure that this bill would deliver meaningful improvements for patients.
In Alberta, we know that a gap in communication can have serious consequences. In 2012, Greg Price died at just 31 years of age. A subsequent inquiry found that poor communication between providers and breaks in the continuity of care contributed to his death. His family has since worked to ensure that others learn from their tragic experience.
More recently, tragedy struck closer to home. Last December, Prashant Sreekumar, a 44-year-old father of three, died at Grey Nuns Community Hospital in Edmonton Southeast after he waited nearly eight hours to see a doctor for chest pain. These cases involved different circumstances, and we should be careful not to suggest that one piece of legislation could have prevented everything that went wrong, but these stories demonstrate why this issue is important.
When patients are referred to specialists, they should know whether their referral has been received and who is responsible for following up. When important test results become available, those results must reach the right professionals and therefore be acted upon. A patient dealing with a serious illness should not have to chase records and coordinate communication between medical offices. That responsibility should not fall on a family already worried about the health of someone they love.
Bill S-5 would require health information technology vendors to ensure their systems can communicate with one another. It would also prohibit data blocking, subject to regulations. Put simply, a patient's information should be able to follow them securely through their care. A commercial interest in keeping customers tied to one software system should not prevent the appropriate sharing of information needed to treat a patient. It is a practical goal that Conservatives support.
According to the Canadian Institute for Health Information, in 2024, only 68% of hip replacement and 61% of knee replacements were completed within the recommended six-month benchmark. Median waits for MRI scans were also 15 days longer than they were in 2019. These delays have consequences. For a person waiting for knee replacement, it may mean months of difficulty in walking, working or caring for their family. For someone waiting for a scan, it can mean prolonged uncertainty about a potentially serious condition.
Better information sharing can help prevent unnecessary repeat tests and the delay caused by missing records, but connecting computer systems will not on its own add more doctors or create additional surgical capacity. Canadians need a broader effort to improve access. The government must explain how this legislation will contribute to that work and how its results will be measured.
We must also consider the people delivering care. Doctors enter medicine to help patients, yet too much of their working time is consumed by unnecessary administrative tasks. A joint survey by the Canadian Medical Association and the Canadian Federation of Independent Business estimated that physicians in Canada spend nearly 20 million hours each year on unnecessary administrative work. Disconnected records are only one part of that burden, but that is a part we should address. When clinic staff repeatedly request the same records or a physician must enter information already held in another system, valuable time is lost. That time could be used to see patients.
The question is whether Bill S-5 would make that work easier. Would referrals become simpler to track? Would doctors spend less time searching for results? Would small clinics receive the training and support needed to adopt new systems? We cannot promise less paperwork while creating another complicated process for doctors to manage. Frontline professionals must be involved in developing these requirements.
Furthermore, Canadians must have confidence that their personal health information is protected. Health records contains some of the most sensitive details of a person's life, including their mental health history, prescriptions and diagnoses. Patients share that information because they trust their health care providers. That trust must be maintained.
Protecting confidential information must not be confused with improperly withholding it for commercial reasons. During the Senate committee review, stakeholders recommended baseline security requirements for vendors, including encryption, strong authentication and records of who accesses information. These recommendations deserve serious consideration. Doctors should not be expected to become cybersecurity experts to determine whether a vendor's product is adequately protected. Vendors must have clear responsibilities for maintaining safeguards, and patients need clear answers about how their information can be used and what happens if it is compromised.
Finally, much of this legislation would depend on regulations developed after it were passed. These regulations would address standards, enforcement and the legislation's application within provinces and territories, which may also require careful examination. Provinces, health care professionals and patients deserve clarity about what would be required, what it would cost and who would be accountable.
Conservatives believe in health care that delivers for its patients, but ultimately what Canadians need are shorter wait times, reliable follow-ups, seamless information transfers, and doctors who have more time to practise medicine rather than working on endless paperwork.
Brendan Hanley (Lib.)12:25 p.m.
Mr. Speaker, I will be sharing my time with the member for Québec Centre.
I am pleased to speak today to Bill S-5, the connected care for Canadians act, and its role in supporting a more connected health system.
Bill S-5 may seem rather technical, and indeed it is. However, I cannot emphasize enough how important this bill is for patients, physicians and indeed all cadres of health care professionals, for caregivers and for the people responsible for the planning and administering of our health care systems.
What is the bill about? Well, Bill S-5 would advance connected care by mandating the adoption of common data standards for health information technologies used across Canada. It would also prohibit data blocking, the practice of restricting access to health information for authorized users such as providers and patients, when privacy laws would otherwise permit it.
In other words, Bill S-5 will allow for the secure sharing of health information between patients and their health care professionals at the time and place that it is needed.
Data that is reliable, accurate and accessible saves lives, and the standards established by this bill would help make that possible. Research shows that patients who have access to their health information are better able to participate in treatment decisions, identify potential errors and manage chronic conditions more effectively. Improved access to health information would also support the more than four million Canadians who serve as informal caregivers in Canada. Today these individuals often devote countless hours to tracking down test results, coordinating records and repeating medical histories on behalf of their loved ones, often while balancing their own work, family and responsibilities.
When patients and their caregivers do not have access to their complete medical records, they finds ways to compensate. They rely on memory, keep physical records, take screen shots and repeat their medical history to every health care provider that they see. Canadians do this because the system does not do it for them. These are creative and ingenious solutions, but they are also time-consuming and stressful and they can lead to misdiagnosis, delays in care or worse.
Thirteen per cent of Canadians say their care was negatively affected due to poor information sharing between providers. The consequences can be profound, even tragic. Indeed, according to a recent physician survey conducted by the Canadian Medical Association, 92% of physicians reported that disconnected health systems, such as the inability to share patient records, test results and clinical notes, affected their ability to provide care. Two-thirds of those physicians say this happens often, highlighting the extent to which the lack of interoperability shapes day-to-day clinical practice. When providers do not have access to a patient's complete health history, they are forced to make decisions without the full clinical picture. This increases the risk of delayed care, misdiagnosis, adverse drug interactions and unsafe treatments.
Bill S-5 would enable a seamless and secure exchange of patient health information to support better collaboration among health care providers. For example, a family physician could securely share a patient summary with a specialist, helping support more timely assessments and better continuity of care. The bill would also strengthen team-based primary care, where timely information sharing is foundational to the way care is delivered. Similarly, for Canadians living with complex or chronic conditions and seeing multiple providers across multiple points of care, connected systems are a necessity. This is indeed true for Yukoners, who in many cases are in touch with providers across different jurisdictions.
Harms resulting from disconnected care are especially high for people travelling in Canada, whether from northern, rural and remote communities, across provincial and territorial borders for treatment, or simply for work or vacation. For example, an elderly individual became ill while visiting family in another province. Although antiviral treatment was recommended, it could not be provided, because the lab result required to confirm eligibility for treatment was trapped in the patient's provincial digital health system.
One service provider explained that, at a hospital in a border region, patients admitted from a neighbouring province are often seriously ill. However, because the provincial health systems are not connected, patients typically arrive with photocopied and incomplete medical records.
When systems cannot communicate, the result can be duplicated tests, delays in care, unnecessary costs, and frustration for patients and families. Bill S-5 would help bridge these gaps by mandating the standards that enable information sharing across the health care system. Importantly, disconnected data puts health care providers in the position of having to make clinical decisions with incomplete information. Bill S-5 would help to address this by enabling health care providers to access their patients' complete health care information in order to provide safe, high-quality care.
The purpose of the bill is to improve patient safety. However, patients are not the only ones who stand to benefit. Bill S‑5 also offers significant benefits to our valued health care professionals.
Interoperable health systems can help reduce administrative burden associated with charting, forms, sick notes and tracking down test results. Today, valuable time is spent manually entering data and copying information from one system to another, instead of spending time with patients. Artificial intelligence is already supporting providers by reducing repetitive administrative tasks and improving access to information, and its use will only expand.
However, these tools depend on reliable and connected data systems. Bill S-5 would help establish the secure data foundation needed to support that progress. For example, studies have found that physicians spend an average of 86 minutes a day searching for patient data due to a lack of interoperability. Now, 20 million physician hours are wasted annually on unnecessary administrative tasks. This unsustainable level of administrative work can lead to burnout, fatigue and low job satisfaction. Results from the CMA's 2025 national physician health survey showed that 46% of physicians and residents report high-level burnout.
Providers also mentioned the personal distress associated with the fear of making clinical decisions based on incomplete information. This affects their mental health, self-confidence, and ability to provide safe care.
Dr. Ewan Affleck, a physician who has spent most of his career in the north and is a leading Canadian expert in digital health information, likens running a health system without connected data to flying blind, which, in his own experience, has cost patients their lives.
To address this crisis, we must transition to working with digital health information within systems that can connect with one another. This will ensure consistent data transfer and reduce errors, which will help health care professionals provide high-quality care and, ultimately, improve patient safety.
Bill S-5 would also support the broader use of digital tools that help patients connect with their providers, including secure platforms for booking appointments, requesting prescription refills and communicating with their care team.
Transformation of any system requires investment. Whatever the cost it takes, the cost of inaction is likely to be far greater than the cost to do this work. As it is, we are already paying a staggering price for disconnected health data, estimated up to $9.4 billion annually. Beyond the financial cost, the consequences I have talked about today can hardly be measured in dollars but in patient safety, quality of care and the well-being of the health care providers who support them.
Bill S-5 is a technical bill but its purpose is straightforward: to connect data to prevent patient harm. Canadians turn to the health care system seeking care and relief. I would encourage my fellow members to join me in supporting the bill so that all Canadians can receive safe health care that is informed by accurate data and is accessible wherever and whenever decisions are made.
Jean-Yves Duclos (Lib.)12:40 p.m.
Mr. Speaker, I am pleased to rise and speak to the House on Bill S‑5, the connected care for Canadians act, and on the collaborative approach that we intend to use to implement it.
I would like to remind the House that the bill's objective is to establish a connected health care system, in other words, a system that provides fast, easy, reliable and secure access to health information for the people who need it.
To ensure fast, secure access, Bill S‑5 requires health information technology vendors to adopt technical and data-related standards and establish clear rules that prevent data blocking. By prohibiting harmful data-blocking practices, this bill will pave the way for health data networking, which offers considerable benefits for patients and professionals, not to mention its social, economic and, obviously, health benefits.
Data saves lives, and it also has the power to transform our health care system. However, our current health care system remains siloed, fragmenting care and putting patients at risk. As a result, 13% of Canadians say that the quality of their care has been compromised by a lack of communication between providers, and 8% report poorer health outcomes because their care team could not access the health information they needed. This situation obviously puts patients' lives and health at risk.
This becomes even more problematic when patients need to seek care in other provinces or territories. Take, for example, patients who rely on cross-border care, such as a truck driver with a chronic illness whose work takes him across provincial borders, a student at an educational institution outside their home province or even just a person who lives in either Gatineau or Ottawa and wants to receive treatment in one province or the other.
Canadians can experience real harm when their health care providers do not have timely access to the information that they need. A lack of connected data exposes patients to increased risks, including misdiagnosis, medication errors, delays in treatment and unsafe procedures. Health care providers regularly express frustration at being unable to access lab reports and results when they need them. Reliable access to this type of information is essential across the country so that health care providers are fully aware of a patient's medical situation when making urgent and often delicate clinical decisions.
This bill also supports research and innovation, which, as we know, lead to new treatments and which will obviously stimulate economic growth in a sector with a very bright future. That is why interoperability is not just about technology. It is a strategic issue that will make the health care system fairer, improve access and enhance its quality and viability.
As part of our efforts to improve access to health data and the sharing and use of such data, the Canadian government is working with the provinces, territories and key stakeholders to move forward and to implement pan-Canadian interoperability. Significant progress has been made to date.
The federal, provincial and territorial governments are working together, and have been for quite some time now, to implement a shared road map. Progress has already been made in Nova Scotia with the One Person One Record initiative and in New Brunswick with MyHealthNB. These collaborative efforts have improved patients' access to their health information, among other things.
However, the progress that has been made at the national level has been variable and inconsistent, and voluntary approaches have their limits. That is why it is essential to pass a law to help the provinces and territories, where appropriate, to harmonize the enforcement of standards and prevent data blocking so that everyone can benefit from health data interoperability.
To fully realize the benefits of interoperability, Bill S‑5 will be implemented and operationalized through regulations that will require health information technology vendors to meet a set of data sharing standards; prevent data blocking, which is the practice of preventing authorized users like patients and health care providers from accessing health data when they need it; and establish a system of administrative monetary penalties to ensure compliance.
These regulations will be developed in close co-operation with provinces, territories, indigenous partners, health care system stakeholders, vendors and patients to support a practical and co-ordinated implementation approach that takes Canadians' needs into account and supports interoperability across the country.
In developing this legislation, we looked at examples from other countries with similar approaches. The lessons learned, connections made and discussions carried out with the United States and some members of the European Union focused on the importance of adopting consistent standards and prohibiting data blocking. Based on the experience of these countries, voluntary approaches alone are insufficient to achieve widespread and effective interoperability, underscoring the need for clear legislative and regulatory requirements for these technologies and these companies.
The law will also serve as a safety net in provinces and territories that do not have similar legislation in place. Provinces and territories will have ample time to harmonize their own laws with the objectives of the federal framework, if necessary and if they deem it appropriate.
In closing, one important lesson to be learned from the health care system as a whole in 2026 is clear: Digital systems that are disconnected from one another pose a threat to the health and safety of all Canadians.
I believe that once implemented, Bill S-5 will save lives, improve the quality of care, reduce health care costs, and, more generally, make the work of health care professionals easier across the country.
Dan Albas (CPC)12:50 p.m.
Mr. Speaker, I think there is broad agreement in this place about the problem this bill is trying to address. Canadians should be able to access their own health information, and when they seek care, the people treating them should be able to get the information they need securely and with the appropriate privacy protections.
I support interoperability. In fact, I have spoken about this in the House before. In the previous Parliament, the former member for Cypress Hills—Grasslands brought forward Bill C-294. It dealt with the Copyright Act and interoperability, and it eventually became law. I congratulate that member, and I spoke in favour of it at the time.
The example I used in that debate was pretty straightforward. It was about a farmer who could own a tractor or combine and buy an implement made by a different manufacturer. It could hook up just fine. Mechanically, there would be no reason it should not work, but technological protection measures could prevent the two pieces of equipment from communicating with each other.
I said at the time, “real competition pits products and services against one another, rewarding innovation and productivity, not copyright and exclusivity.” I also said that the right to interoperability was critical for consumers. I stand by that. I still believe it today. However, health care is obviously different and considerably more complicated.
I want to be very clear: I believe in the importance of interoperability. Canadians should be able to access their personal medical information, and health care professionals should be able to get the information they need to care for their patients safely and with respect for privacy.
However, we need to make a distinction: Making software interoperable and making our health care system truly interoperable are two different things. I have some concerns in this regard about this bill.
Bill S-5 is principally about health information technology vendors. It would require the technology covered by the legislation to be interoperable according to established requirements, and it would prohibit data blocking by vendors. Those sound like very reasonable objectives to me. If a vendor is deliberately preventing health information from moving simply to keep a customer locked into its ecosystem, there is a legitimate role for Parliament, but I think we need to be careful about what happens next.
Canada does not just have one health system. We have provincial health care systems, and within those systems, there are health authorities, hospitals, laboratories, primary care providers and other organizations that have brought in different technologies at different times under different contracts to do different things. Some of those systems are relatively new; some are not. Some communicate reasonably well, and some require people to find workarounds just to move fairly basic information. If there were one health care system, one purchaser and one set of specifications, establishing common technical requirements might be simpler, but there is not.
I do not think the answer is to turn the federal government into the health care technology purchaser for the entire country, although I am sure there are some members on the opposite side who would enjoy that. Health care is principally administered and delivered by the provinces, like it or not. The federal government needs to respect that.
I will be fair about the legislation. There are provisions in the bill that recognize that reality. The federal requirements would not simply apply uniformly, regardless of what a province or territory is already doing. The bill would provide a mechanism that takes into account whether a province or territory has a substantially similar or stronger requirement.
I think that is completely sensible, but it also points to a larger problem. The federal government does not run the health care system. I hope we can all agree on that. Some Canadians might reasonably respond that they are not entirely convinced the provinces are running it either. We have seen in Nova Scotia and, more recently, in my home province of British Columbia that the Conservatives of those provinces actively ran for and won majority governments despite the old logic that Conservatives cannot speak to health care issues and only run away.
In my home province, there are wait times at the ER, that is if it is actually open. I heard from the daughter of 90-year-old woman that her mother had been kept in the hallway of the Kelowna General Hospital ER for days. She was literally unable to sleep with all the incoming patients, and the first responders and health care professionals trying to do their job while her mother was waiting for a bed.
Constitutionally and practically, the provinces administer and deliver health care regardless of how badly. They are dealing with hospitals, health authorities, physicians and procurement decisions, and much of the information is already in place. Therefore, I think this House should ask a fairly basic question: Why should we assume that the federal government knows best when it comes to procuring and implementing complex information technology when its own record does not exactly inspire confidence?
Let me give an example. We all remember ArriveCAN. The Auditor General of Canada could not even determine exactly what the application cost because the government's financial records and controls were so poor. She estimated the cost at approximately $59.5 million. She found that federal organizers repeatedly failed to follow good management practices in contracting, development and implementation, and concluded that the application did not deliver the best value for the taxpayer dollars spent. That deserves some reflection.
The federal government is now entering into another debate involving sophisticated information technology and procurement, yet in the case of ArriveCAN, or arrive scam depending on who we talk to, the Auditor General of Canada could not even establish the precise cost of the government's own application because the records were inadequate. That is not an ideological argument, but the Auditor General's finding.
Then we come to PrescribeIT. This example is arguably even more relevant because it was a health information technology project. The objective was straightforward. It is 2026; why are we still sending prescriptions around by fax? The goal of PrescribeIT was to move prescriptions electronically from prescribers to pharmacies. According to public reporting, more than $250 million was spent on PrescribeIT since 2017, yet fewer than 5% of Canadian prescriptions were being transmitted through the system. The centrally operated service ended this year after Canada Health Infoway concluded that national adoption had not been reached to the scale necessary for long-term sustainability. The organization has moved toward an open national e-prescribing standard instead. Let us think about that for a moment. The problem was not that no one could figure out how to make an electronic prescription. They could. The difficult part was getting a complicated health care system to use it. Adoption mattered. Existing information systems mattered. Costs, I would hope, mattered. Provincial participation absolutely mattered. The day-to-day practices of doctors and pharmacists mattered. Implementation mattered. ArriveCAN could teach us something about federal procurement. PrescribeIT should teach us something about health care technology implementation. Both should give the Liberal government a warning to show a little humility.
I am not saying the federal government has no role here. It does. Preventing genuine data blocking can be a legitimate federal role. Working with provinces on common technical standards makes sense. Removing legitimate federal barriers makes sense. The federal government can certainly demand results when it is spending taxpayer money. However, the Liberals on the government benches should be very careful about assuming that because they can pass a law about interoperability, they therefore know how to procure, integrate and operate health information systems better than the people delivering the care. Writing requirements in Ottawa is considerably easier than making technology work on the ground, and Canadians have paid enough money over the years to understand the difference.
I have been thinking of all of this because of two conversations I had on my Finding Solutions podcast. One was with Dr. Stuart Edmonds of the Canadian Cancer Society. We were talking about clinical trials and why they matter to cancer patients. I think most Canadians understand generally what a clinical trial is, but it looks rather different when we think about it from the perspective of somebody who has cancer and may be running out of treatment options. There may be a clinical trial available for that person, but somebody has to know that patient exists. They have to know what kind of cancer that person has. They have to know what treatments have already been tried. They may need pathology results, diagnostic information or other testing. Then they have to determine whether that patient might qualify for the trial. At that point, interoperability stops being a debate about software and becomes a question of whether the right information can get to the right people when it matters. With cancer, I do not think I have to tell members, time matters.
I had another conversation on finding solutions with Louise Binder, a long-time patient advocate working with the Save Your Skin Foundation. We talked about the postal code lottery in cancer care. We talked about clinical trials, access to new medicines, families travelling to receive treatment and what that all means for someone who is already dealing with a serious illness. We discussed this legislation on interoperable health information and the importance of a care team being able to see the full picture of the patient. That, to me, is the most persuasive case for what the government is trying to accomplish.
A cancer patient should not have to become the human interface between computer systems that cannot communicate. If someone from my communities in the Okanagan has to go to Vancouver for specialized treatment, that person should not have to reconstruct their medical history every time they encounter another part of the health care system. If someone has to travel to another province for care, that gets even harder. The relevant health information should not simply disappear because people cross the provincial boundary. The technology should work for the patient. The patient should not have to work for the technology to work.
I want to come back to the patient, because this law should exist for them. If I am a cancer patient, I do not care which company developed the software used in my hospital. I do not care what government bought the system. I want to know whether my doctor has the information he needs to treat me. That is all. If I need to go to another region or another province to obtain care, I want important information to follow me.
I therefore support interoperability. That said, passing an interoperability act and creating a truly interoperable health care system are two different things.
The government itself says that only 29% of health care providers share electronic information securely and seamlessly outside their offices. Obviously, that is not good enough, but that statistic also raises an uncomfortable question. We have been talking about digital health in Canada for years. We have spent money, billions of dollars. We have developed strategies. We have established organizations. We have announced initiatives. We have negotiated funding agreements. Where are the results?
This is not an argument against doing more. It is an argument for understanding why what we have already done has not produced the results Canadians reasonably expected. It comes down to this old political trap. There is a problem, something must be done and this is something. Therefore, we must do this. That does not mean Bill S-5 is inherently bad legislation. It means Parliament should not confuse legislative activity with health care results. Passing a bill is relatively easy. Writing regulations can be done. Holding a press conference can certainly be done. We know because we see it almost every day with the government.
However, the difficult work comes after that. How does this work with the systems provinces already purchased? What happens to older systems? How much will it cost to make them compatible? What happens when standards change? What happens when one institution is capable of exchanging the information, but another is not? What happens when the barrier is not the vendor? What happens when the problem is an existing contract, an institutional practice, a procurement decision made 10 years ago or simply an old system that is too expensive to replace? Those are not reasons to abandon interoperability. They are reasons to be honest about what this legislation can and cannot accomplish.
The federal government has a role to play, but having a role to play does not mean playing all the roles. The provinces administer their health care systems. They know their facilities. They make their own procurement decisions. They are responsible for delivering care. Ottawa can remove certain obstacles. The federal government can work with the provinces to establish common standards. It can prevent unwarranted data blocking. When it spends taxpayers' money, it can certainly demand results. However, a national standard cannot replace co-operation. Federal legislation alone cannot solve all the problems that exist in our health care systems.
There is another contrast that I think is worth considering. The federal government already knows how to sit down with provinces and reach agreements on specific health outcomes. The federal government has agreements with British Columbia, Manitoba, Prince Edward Island and the Yukon, covering a range of diabetes medications and contraception. Those are agreements with provinces and territories, yet there are only four. It seems to me that the government is pivoting away from the kind of approach that costs money and instead trying to find another problem to solve.
Interoperability, as I said, is a problem, but is that the best use of everyone's time? We need to start asking whether or not the Liberal government is seeking results or if it is just seeking to have announcements. I think the same approach should guide interoperability. What do I actually want to know about this bill?
First, would it stop vendors from blocking information that would legitimately be available? If it does, good.
Second, would these standards actually work with systems that provinces and health care providers already have? Telling everyone that tomorrow's technology must comply does not necessarily fix the equipment and the software that were purchased five or 10 years ago.
Third, how would the government work with provinces, not consult them so that someone can put a check mark beside consultation, but actually work with them?
Finally, what would the patient notice? Can they access their information? Can their doctor get the information they need? If I live in the Okanagan and go to Vancouver for treatment, can the professionals treating me see the relevant records? If I end up in an emergency room somewhere else in the country, what happens then? If I have cancer and possibly qualify for a clinical trial, will the information needed to identify that opportunity actually be available? Those are the questions I care about.
Frankly, I am less interested in whether a technology vendor can tell the federal government that it has complied with the regulation. I just want to know whether the thing actually works. Do not come back to Parliament in two years and tell us how many meetings were held. Do not tell us how many vendors submitted compliance paperwork. Do not tell us how many pages of regulations were published. Tell us what happened to the patient.
That is how we should measure success. Can patients access that information? Can doctors? If a patient moves away, can their information follow them? If a treatment or clinical trial is available, can the necessary information be accessed in a timely fashion?
Results are what matters. I do not just want to know if software is interoperable on paper. I want to know if the system works in real life.
I would just mention an incident that I had an occasion to ask a former minister of health about. In 2022, the prime minister at the time, the premier of my province, John Horgan, and the health minister, who is still a member today, reached an agreement on health care information sharing. Billions of dollars were announced. Now, that was four years ago and what has changed? Zip.
What I am saying to the government here is that it can make announcements and spend money, but that does not necessarily mean the job gets done. It should start to listen to the people who know the systems, start to put them in charge of the job and make sure that it is seen not only as an announceable, but a deliverable, and make sure the government is behind that.
After speaking with people such as Dr. Stuart Edmonds and Louise Binder, I see a case for this bill in health care very clearly, but we have learned enough from previous digital health projects and, frankly, from federal IT procurement more generally, to know that passing legislation is the easy part. Making it work is the hard part.
Let us make sure that doctors are not relying on faxes. Let us make sure that the government relies on facts. Let us not confuse passing the law with solving the problem.
Patients do not need another announcement about interoperability; they need a system that works. When a physician has to make an important decision, they should have access to the right information at the right time. Patients should not have to act as a go-between for two computer systems that cannot communicate with one another. That is the outcome we should be working toward.
Ultimately, this is not about databases. This is about people. I ask the government to really focus on the people more than the data and not to focus on the announcements, but on the actual results.
Danielle Martin (Lib.)1:20 p.m.
Mr. Speaker, I will be sharing my time today with the member for Winnipeg North.
When I was a health system and academic leader, we used to talk about having two jobs in health care. First was taking care of the patient of today. To do that work, obviously, we need access to the health data across a patient's journey, no matter where they are in the health care system. We also talked about having a second patient, the patient of tomorrow, and that is the work of supporting research, quality improvement and health system innovation.
Bill S-5 is a critical piece of legislation that would allow us to care for both the patient of today and the patient of tomorrow, and that is why I am proud to rise in the House today to speak in support of it.
All over Canada today, people are going to visit their family doctors. They are going to be talking about their mental health. They are going to be talking about their diabetes and their blood pressure control. They are going to be talking about their cancer journeys. They are going to be getting immunizations, prescriptions and requisitions for medical imaging. They might be getting a referral to a specialist. They might be referred for counselling or for physiotherapy. In pretty much every one of those family doctor's offices today, they are going to find their family doctor sitting and typing away on a computer, generating tasks for the physician or the health care worker and for the patient.
If a referral is made, the doctor is going to be typing away, generating forms inside that computer, and if that patient then goes to see a specialist, they are going to find the specialist sitting at their desk taking notes on a computer. If they end up in an emergency situation and have to go to the hospital, all the notes, the test results and the imaging results are going to be stored in an electronic record.
In my community of downtown Toronto, those places, the family doctor's office, the hospital, the emergency department and the specialist's office, might be just a few subway stops away from each other. Sometimes they are even in the same building, so one could forgive a patient for assuming those computers are talking to each other. However, it turns out that all too often, that is not the case. People could be forgiven for asking why, in a set of single-payer health systems across the country in any given province or territory, the data generated in the hospital, the data generated in the doctor's office and the data generated in the home care interface are sitting in separate silos, not talking to each other.
Bill S-5 seeks to remedy that. By requiring the vendors of the electronic systems we use in our health systems every day to meet interoperability standards and putting an end to data blocking, wherein vendors hold onto the data of Canadians under the mistaken view that they own the data about the health of our people, as opposed to the patient and the health system as a public good, we would be putting in place the necessary infrastructure for a modern health care system across the country.
It used to be that in order for electronic systems to talk to each other in a health care system, they had to actually be on the same system. I am pleased that this is no longer the case. We do not need all of Canada to be using a single electronic health record for data to flow in the ways that patients need, because technology has leapfrogged that requirement. When vendors meet those interoperability standards referred to in this bill, the data would be able to move in order for us to take better care of people. The hospital and the clinic would be able to securely share information that is relevant to the care of the patient.
To emphasize the importance of this bill, one need only quote the preamble:
the health information of Canadians is not easily accessible to them or to their health care professionals, which puts the safety of Canadians at risk;
There is broad consensus among stakeholders that the interoperability between health technologies and health information systems, as well as a prohibition of data blocking, are necessary to ensure patient health and safety, improve health outcomes and promote equitable care for Canadians.
For patients to make informed decisions about their own health, they must have easy, comprehensive and secure access to their health information. Their health care professionals and researchers must also have access to it.
Why does this bill matter? Why do we need health records to be interoperable, and why do we need health data to be treated as a public good?
I want to speak to primary use and secondary use and begin by talking about the delivery of clinical care and access to one's own records. We have covered well in the House today in this debate the necessity of interoperability of health records for patient safety in terms of clinicians being able to access critical information when a person comes in for care, so I want to focus my remarks on the two other critical aspects. First is the ability of Canadians to access their own health records. Second is the ability to use the data for research, quality improvement and system oversight.
The pan-Canadian OurCare consultations, led by Dr. Tara Kiran and an incredible national team of researchers and experts in public engagement and primary care, had conversations with hundreds of people living across Canada to understand what Canadians wanted from a better primary care system. In their conversations, a core refrain arose again and again: People in Canada are frustrated that they do not have access to their own medical information. People shared how not having access to their own medical records made it challenging to get the care they need when they had an emergency, when they moved to a different province, when their doctor moved or retired, when they did not have a doctor or when they were just trying to advocate for themselves or for their loved ones.
Through the OurCare consultations, people in Canada spoke clearly and consistently. They want access to their own health records online in a format they can share with clinicians and loved ones and where they can have confidence that the information will be kept private and secure, which is not a very radical or unusual idea. Countries around the world have already given people access to their own health records through an app, like the Nordic countries, for example, but also Estonia, Spain, Portugal, France, England and Australia, just to name a few.
As we look to build national infrastructure and to become more self-reliant as a country and as we look to create the conditions for our country to thrive in the years to come, we need to invest in the most foundational of assets: the health of our people. Bill S-5 would open the door for people being able to access their own health records by ensuring that their data would be liberated from the vendors who may be holding on to it.
That brings me to secondary use and the patient of tomorrow. This is an aspect of data interoperability we should not neglect, because beyond the care of individual people, we need health data to do quality improvement, to do groundbreaking research, to engage in health system oversight and to develop artificial intelligence and apply it to the biggest problems facing the health of Canadians.
This is what we call secondary use of data, because health data is the raw material for improving care. Research and quality improvement teams use data to track people's health outcomes over time, to measure the impact of our interventions and to ask important questions that will lead to the next generation of breakthroughs.
Health data also contains the stories of important inequities and outcomes across the country. It helps us to understand whether people living in rural communities, people experiencing homelessness, indigenous people, Black Canadians and other groups are getting the care they deserve. This information can then drive our investments and programs as a government, but to understand the story, we need the data. Our superb Canadian researchers and health system leaders cannot do their jobs without it, and if it is being blocked sitting inside a vendor's records, we are going to be in trouble.
Finally, I want to say a few words about artificial intelligence. We are obviously at a new frontier. If we want to use AI to reduce wait times in emergency departments or wait times for specialist care, and if we want to use AI to improve the quality of care being provided to seniors in long-term care, to cancer patients in our cancer centres or to children in our family doctors' offices, we are going to need data and the data will need to be linked in order for us to do it.
Bill S-5 would regulate vendors. It would require them to play ball in ensuring that data can be shared across our health systems. Once the data is unblocked and interoperable, a lot of work still remains to be done. This bill would not replace the work ahead on sovereignty, commercialization, data export approaches and indigenous data sovereignty, all of which have been flagged by our colleagues in the Senate, but it would lay the foundation for all those things. Bill S-5 would lay the foundation for us to care for the patient of today and tomorrow. I am proud to support it.
Kevin Lamoureux (Lib.)1:35 p.m.
Mr. Speaker, it is a pleasure to rise and speak to Bill S-5 today. If we take a look at information nowadays, it has never been easier to access. It has become critically important that when we take a look at our health care system, we look at ways in which we can improve upon it.
I want to reflect on some of the days, going as far back as when I was the health care critic in the province of Manitoba, when I was meeting with patients and stakeholders. Even back then, they were talking about information gathered on behalf of clients or patients and how that information is retained and ultimately shared.
I remember that when I had to change my family doctor, as my first one made the decision to retire, I was given a yellow envelope to bring to my new doctor. A year ago or so, when I was with my family doctor inside the checkup room, he was sitting at a computer, which I could watch. It was truly amazing how he was able to connect my health care needs through the computer. I did not have to get a prescription issued from the doctor or a piece of paper. Rather, he told me that I could go to X place and that my prescription would be ready.
When I take a look at what Bill S-5 is all about, it is all about patients, whether directly or indirectly. That is why I would like to think that all members of the House will see the value of supporting the legislation.
I have listened to members opposite all morning talk about the concerns they have, and I am not going to marginalize their concerns. I suspect that all members have some concerns as we move into this area. It is a very challenging area; there is no doubt about it. Someone mentioned that while we could bring in legislation, it would not guarantee that the system is going to work and the patient is going to benefit. There are jurisdictional issues. To individuals who are genuinely concerned about the issue of which level of government is responsible for what, I will say that instead of that being the primary concern, the primary concern should be the patient.
If we view this through that lens, I believe we will see more co-operation taking place among institutions, private companies, non-profit companies and the different levels of government, if we are prepared to do what the minister has made very clear. In her statement, she talked about working with provincial and territorial jurisdictions and indigenous communities.
At the end of the day, information does matter. What takes place in our doctors' offices, our hospitals, our care facilities and our pharmacies really does matter, as does a person's ability to go into a facility, whatever type of facility it might be, and have a sense that a health care provider has access to the information that is so very important for that patient. If that were to be done right, where we get collaboration and get all systems onside moving in one direction, with the priority being the patient, we would see less duplication.
People would understand the differences in medications that might be being taken at one end versus at the other end. Some testing may not have to take place, or in some cases testing would take place, such as an x-ray, a lab test or whatever it might be. The different types of medications an individual takes throughout the year would be known. These are all important pieces of information. In working collaboratively with other jurisdictions, I would argue, as I said at the outset, and putting the lens on the patient, it is the patient who would benefit with the passage of Bill S-5.
I had the opportunity to ask members opposite some questions regarding the principle of the legislation. I am encouraged by the Minister of Health and the government's agenda to get this legislation through with fantastic support from the Senate of Canada. I am pleased with the general approach of the opposition, as the principle of the legislation appears to have been accepted. That being said, I suspect there might be a number of issues, based on what I have heard, that would come up at the committee stage.
I am sure there would be representation at the committee stage about issues related to things such as data blocking, which has been talked about a great deal. Data blocking is done far too often. Because of a vested interest, information is being retained by one vendor for reasons I will not go into today, but much of it would be driven by the dollar. Data blocking would be directly dealt with in this legislation, which is a very good thing.
Then there are interoperable issues. For example, in the province of Manitoba, there might be a care facility using a different technology system from what is being used at the Health Sciences Centre. Because of that, it is the patient who loses the most. That is one of the reasons the compatibility of technologies is so important in the legislation. The data would be able to be transferred. We hear a great deal about data, records and so forth, and it is important for us to recognize that with regard to data and technology, the government is very concerned with ensuring that privacy is respected. As we know, Canadians are very concerned about the issue of privacy, and understandably so.
Some provinces are further advanced than others, and I recognize that, but as we roll this out, what would end up happening is that the quality of health care services would improve for all Canadians. The health care worker, be it a nurse or a doctor, would have better opportunity to provide bedside care or to provide consultation, as a direct result of moving forward with Bill S-5. That is not to mention, as some have already pointed out, that it would also save lives.
Someone asked why it is taking us as long as it is. I think it is important to recognize that we have a very substantial legislative agenda. In the last 18 months, we have been pushing forward on a series of legislative initiatives. This bill is an important piece to it, because our health care matters in Canada. Canadians want us—
Kelly DeRidder (CPC)1:50 p.m.
Mr. Speaker, it is an honour to rise on behalf of Kitchener Centre to speak to this really important issue.
I think we can all agree that every Canadian should be able to access quality health care when they need it, without waiting and regardless of where they live and what they earn. Unfortunately, that is not the reality of our current health care system. Canadians are struggling to find a family doctor. They are waiting months if not years to see specialists. They join long wait lists for surgeries and imaging. Emergency rooms are overcrowded, and patients spend hours waiting even to be assessed. For too many Canadians, the challenge is simply accessing health care. While we can all agree that our health care system is worth protecting, it cannot mean defending something that is failing too many Canadians.
Canadian taxpayers spend an enormous amount of money on their own health care. Taxpayers will spend $57 billion in 2026-27, and Canadians are still left waiting for proper care for their investment. Do members know that Canada ranks last among 10 similar countries with respect to timely access to health care? Only one in four Canadians gets an appointment with a doctor or nurse the day they need it. Most Canadians wait two months or longer to see a specialist.
We have to ask ourselves how we can make our system work better. It is not just about how much money we put into health care. It is about its effectiveness. How do we support health care professionals, and how do we improve the outcomes for all Canadians?
Let us imagine that somebody from Kitchener decides to travel across this beautiful country to Alberta. Maybe they are visiting family, enjoying a family vacation or travelling for work. Then, unexpectedly, they have a heart attack. They are taken to the ER, and the doctors treating them need to know their medical history, such as what medications they are taking, if they have any allergies, if they have had any previous surgeries or if there are any underlying issues or conditions that could affect their treatment. The patient is lucky enough to have a family doctor in Ontario, but their medical records are not in the same system as Alberta's, and the hospital cannot access them.
What happens now? The patient literally cannot provide their health information if they have had a heart attack. They cannot give their history. They cannot give their allergies or the pertinent information the doctors may need in that exact moment. The doctors now are spending time trying to access the patient's information instead of immediately caring for them. Tests may be needed or repeated, and information is not available. All this is happening while the individual is not getting the care they need. Would it not make more sense if the patient's medical information could just follow them so surgeons would immediately be able to operate on them, potentially saving lives?
A colleague just shared a story with me. A man and his wife were travelling across the country, and they got in a car accident. Because of that car accident, the gentleman needed immediate surgery, and his wife was unconscious. Right on the roadside, penicillin was administered to the man during the operation, but unfortunately he was allergic to the penicillin and passed away. Data transfer can literally save lives in this country.
We have already invested in medical records across this country. More than 95% of physicians use electronic medical records today, but that is not the same as having a connected system. A doctor might have a patient's entire medical history on their computer, but if the doctor treating them next door does not have that same information, we have a problem. Only 29% of primary care providers make patient information available outside their own practice. Only a quarter of practitioners make that information available outside that practice. This leaves 75% of the population without records that can be immediately accessed so patients can get immediate care in the times they need it.
This costs Canadian taxpayers an extra $9.4 billion a year. Let us think about that. Billions of dollars are being lost because the information that already exists on a system somewhere is not being accessed by someone right next door. Patients are undergoing repeat tests. Health care professionals are spending extra time tracking down records. Important information is being missed when patients move between providers.
Doctors, nurses, pharmacists and other health care professionals should be spending their time caring for patients, and that is it. They should not be spending their time trying to access information that already exists on another system. It is a complete waste of, first, the physician's time and, second, the immediate access to care for patients who immediately need it. Not having to chase down medical records or repeat work that has already been done would only help the care of patients here in Canada. We should be giving physicians the tools they need to do their jobs, not making their jobs more difficult by repeatedly investigating the care that a particular person may need.
There is a tremendous opportunity with the bill, but there are a lot of questions behind the scenes. We do need to make sure that the details are right with this piece of legislation, because Canadians need to be able to access their own data, and we do need actual improvements for Canadians. This cannot just be another measure where we are saying that we are going to be doing something in Parliament but not actually working with the provinces and territories to make sure that it is implemented across Canada.
We have questions that we need to ask, and as we move forward, we will ensure that we ask these questions in committee.
Provinces and territories are responsible for their own health care systems. As the federal government, we need to respect the role of the provinces. We should be working with them to make sure that health information can be shared across provinces in a way that all provinces agree with. We have to ensure that we are not going to be encroaching on provincial territory when we are trying to implement a system to access care across systems. This is a key important piece of this legislation that we need to look at.
We need to understand how the bill would work with the systems that are already in place and make sure provinces still have a say in how these changes are made. We know that different practitioners use different systems, so what does that mean for the current systems that practitioners are already using? Are they going to be able to keep these systems or are they going to need to move to a different system? None of these questions have any answers to them yet, and these are the things we are going to look at.