The House met at 0900.
Legislative Assembly of Ontario · House
Thursday, November 5, 2026
The official record of the sitting, from Hansard, by section and topic. Passages link to the Assembly’s video of Members’ Statements and Question Period where it is posted.
Prières.
The Speaker (Hon. Donna Skelly)
Now, a moment of silence for inner thought and personal reflection.
Orders of the Day
Protecting Ontario’s Food Independence Act, 2026 / Loi de 2026 visant à protéger l’autonomie alimentaire de l’OntarioBill 109
Mr. Oosterhoff, on behalf of Mr. Jones, moved third reading of the following bill:
Bill 109, An Act to enact the Farmland Security Act, 2026 and to amend various Acts / Projet de loi 109, Loi édictant la Loi de 2026 visant à protéger l’autonomie alimentaire de l’Ontario et modifiant diverses lois.
Hon. Sam Oosterhoff
It is a great privilege to be able to rise on behalf of the good people of Niagara West, on behalf of agri-food workers, farmers and the agricultural sector across this great province to speak to this legislation. This is the first piece of legislation that I will have had the opportunity to speak to in my new role as Ontario’s Minister of Agriculture, Food and Agribusiness. I want to thank the Premier for the opportunity to work with farmers, with egg workers and with this great province to deliver a more sovereign, secure and self-reliant agri-food economy here in the province of Ontario. I do want to acknowledge and thank several people for their work, but I have to begin by saying that I will be sharing my time with the member for Hamilton East–Stoney Creek, the newly elected member, and the MPP for Algoma–Manitoulin, a strong champion for northern Ontario. Speaker, I have to also begin by thanking and acknowledging the incredible amount of work that has gone into this legislation by my predecessor the member for Chatham-Kent–Leamington, a true advocate, a fierce worker and a protector of farmers here in the province of Ontario, Trevor Jones. I have to thank him for his leadership over the years and all of the work that he did to bring this bill forward. I want to acknowledge that he is continuing that excellent work in a new ministry, the Ministry of Labour, Immigration, Training and Skills Development, but I know he will continue also in that new ministry to be a fierce advocate for agri-food and the provincial needs of farmers and agri-food workers. I also want to thank the former parliamentary assistant to Minister Jones—and for a few weeks there, also my parliamentary assistant—the member for Bruce–Grey–Owen Sound, for his leadership, his work, his tenacity and his vision. He is indeed someone who I believe has done fantastic work for farmers, as someone with an agricultural background himself, and of course representing farmers from not just that community but working with those from across the province, has made a big difference for this legislation. I want to acknowledge that as well. I am so grateful today, Speaker, to have the privilege of interacting and speaking to legislation that I hope this chamber will support, this House will support, as we reflect on the fact that it is the reflection of a collective effort, a collective partnership with many, many farmers, farm organizations, businesses, stakeholders and entrepreneurs from across the agri-food sector who have come together to provide their advice and their input on this legislation. Premier Ford has always said that it is vitally important that our government gets out into communities both large and small in this province to make sure that the legislation that’s coming forward isn’t an ivory-tower, downtown-Toronto idea, but is one that is reflected by main street Ontario, by everyday citizens and by those who actually work in the sectors that we are legislating on. I can tell you that this legislation does reflect what farmers have been asking for, what agricultural organizations have been asking for, and I can tell them as well, those who are listening, some who are even here today in the gallery watching who I want to acknowledge from the dairy advisory council for their incredible contributions and using their voice—I can assure them I will continue to listen, I will continue to work on their behalf and to bring forward policies that reflect their needs and their priorities. Direct communication and collaboration with those who feed our province is absolutely integral to the development of any good legislation, and I’m happy to say that the measures of the Protecting Ontario’s Food Independence Act were informed by the province’s farmers and food processors, the producers who have actually come forward to say, “This is what we need to develop strategic measures to support agri-food competitiveness and resilience.” We worked closely with farmers to understand their needs, and we will also be taking more actions in addition to this legislation as part of our ongoing efforts to ensure that stakeholders in the agri-food sector are directly informing our work. I appreciate these strong working relationships and will never take them for granted. To back up a little bit, I don’t think it’s any surprise to those who are in the chamber this morning and those who are watching via livestream that this has been a year with significant global uncertainty and ongoing trade challenges, and we need to be real about that. In the 2026 provincial budget, the budget is built to respond to those needs, to respond to that uncertainty with strategic investments to strengthen sector competitiveness and protect jobs during a time of economic uncertainty. A number of these investments include protecting Ontario’s agricultural and agri-food industry; for example, strengthening agri-food supply chains, enhancing competitiveness and attracting and growing our sovereign agri-food talent through the Grow Ontario Strategy. As one example, this year’s budget commits to agri-food research and innovation. There is an additional $61.5 million into Agricultural Research and Innovation Ontario. Just a few weeks ago, I had the privilege of joining the outstanding member for Wellington–Halton Hills as we announced the groundbreaking of an over $30-million poultry research facility to protect the incredible feathery friends that of course end up on many of our plates but also in so many ways provide thousands of good jobs across this province. It’s a demonstration of continued investment into research and innovation, which builds on an additional $41 million that was announced last year as well—a little over a year ago. That is over $100 million over the next 10 years that will be rolled into research and innovation here in the province of Ontario specifically to support strategic agri-food research infrastructure: 14 special research stations, 5,600 acres, more than 200 buildings of research excellence delivered by people who work in them and care for them. Now, we know that research and innovation are crucial to delivering solutions for farmers and they’re crucial to protecting Ontario’s food supply chains against emerging threats from invasive species and pests as well as animal diseases, which can be incredibly disruptive and can take all sorts of forms. We have seen reports recently of the spotted lanternfly out in Windsor, and we know the damage the spotted lanternfly can have for tender-fruit growers and on tender-fruit industries. More recently just across the border in the United States to the west of us, we’ve seen where avian influenza knocked out millions and millions of chickens, and that had a direct impact on consumers and, in their case, on the prices that were being paid. So we need to make sure that we are doubling down on research and innovation that deals with these emerging threats and that it’s responding to them for the sake of the livelihoods of those who are dependant on them, and also, ultimately, for the sake of those who rely on that strong, stable supply chain of food that of course we take for granted whether we go to a cafeteria or are packing our lunch pail. We can’t take these things for granted. We need to continue building relationships and investing in innovation against these types of threats. The budget also built out and identified relationships with retailers and food service companies throughout Ontario. I want to talk about that because it is incredibly important that we look at how we can diversify our markets, and that’s a key area of focus. The Premier was very candid with me. He said we need to make sure that we’re expanding access to new markets, that we’re not as reliant on the United States, that we are doing more domestic production but also more domestic consumption. It’s one thing to grow products here; it’s another to what I call “grow and go.” You may have heard of the concept of ripping and shipping of critical minerals. This is something that we hear the Minister of Energy and Mines talk about regularly. He talks about how, here in Ontario, we’ve had this history of extraction of critical minerals and resources, and then we ship them in many cases to the United States, and then we purchase back the value-added goods. We need to change that in that sector. But in agriculture, I call it “growing and going,” where we have products—as an example, let’s take something like soybeans or corn—that are incredibly important commodity groups. We’re never going to stop that export. We know how important those export markets are. But if we’re able to diversify the offtake agreements for those farmers for more markets—so they’re able to get better prices for their product and also be able to provide more domestic consumption. For example: You look at soybeans, you look at soy milk, you look at tofu as an example of a product that is being consumed globally in vast quantities. If we’re able to produce more of that here, not just on the growing of the soybeans but also the jobs and the security that comes with the value-added work that goes into making tofu—just as one example—that’s good for Ontario jobs. It’s good for Ontario farmers. That’s why the Sustainable Canadian Agricultural Partnership is so important. It’s a plan, in collaboration with the federal government, that says we need to be strategic. For the future of agriculture and food in Canada and in Ontario, as we face trade disruptions, we need to be focused on protecting food independence. We want to make sure that our agri-food sector is self-reliant, that our supply chains are domesticated and are resilient, and that farmers are also empowered. Because we do have what the world needs. The amount of respect that there is internationally for our agricultural products is unparalleled. One example I’ll give—and maybe this is just a fascinating little story. I’m sorry it’s not in my notes, and I told the Minister of Sport I was going to try to stick to my notes today but I’ll give an example—is Canadian corn. You might not realize this, but one of the fastest-growing markets for Canadian corn is Ireland, because Ireland has a lot of dairy production. And what do Irish dairy producers like? They like Ontario corn. Some of that is because of our excellent growing conditions, which actually means we have lower rates of vomitoxin in the corn, which is good. It’s good for cows if they’re able to eat essentially very clean, very healthy corn. Okay, so what happens? They end up producing—sorry, it’s just a little story. So Ontario corn goes to Ireland, gets consumed by Irish milk cows, which then gets sold—the milk—to a place like Italy, who then produces parmigiano. So what happens? We all love our Parmesan. We then import the Parmesan, which comes from Ontario corn. So you look at the cycle of global markets and the importance of diversifying our trade away from just the American markets into new markets—it’s a fantastic story, and it’s one where next time you eat Parmesan, you’re going to start thinking about Canadian corn and Ontario corn. But I can tell you, that’s just one little example of the incredible supply chain and the opportunities that farmers have built up over time, and that they need government partners to be able to broaden those markets and increase that access. I think of Hensall, just as one little example, again going back to the bean conversation—I know I talked about tofu and soybeans—but as an example of global markets. So if you go to the UK and you eat Branston beans—Branston beans is the number one brand in the UK. Heinz is number two. I think Heinz is number one in Scotland, if my memory is correct. Where do all those beans come from? They come from Huron–Bruce, from Hensall Co-op. So next time you’re there and you’re thinking, “This is as British as baked beans,” remember they come from Ontario.
Hon. Sam Oosterhoff
That’s just one example. It’s millions of tonnes, right? It’s an incredible story, but it’s an incredible story because it takes time to go to those shows to bring those connections. Farmers are doing that, agricultural commodity groups are doing that, but governments need to be partners along the way. That’s why efforts like the market diversification and trade initiative, which is an important program that was funded through the Sustainable Canadian Agricultural Partnership, matters because it gives the resources, the tools for folks in those businesses to be able to go around the world and to close purchase orders at the end of the day, which is good for domestic jobs and ultimately good for our economy. I apologize about going into some of those stories there, Minister, but I’m just very proud of the work of our farmers, and we need to make sure that they understand that that’s what we’re trying to safeguard. We’re trying to support and protect that kind of dominance in agricultural excellence under this legislation. We need to maintain control of our foodland. We need to maintain control of the acreages that we have here in the province, which, you know, the good Lord is not making a whole lot more of. We need to make sure that which we have is being treated with respect, that we are stewards of the land we’ve been given and that farmers also can know that they’re going to have protections when it comes to our foodland. The concept of protecting local ownership of farmland is not a new one. We know that five other provinces already have legislation in place which actually restricts the amount of farmland that foreign entities can acquire. Manitoba, Quebec, Saskatchewan, Alberta, PEI: They all have protections in place for farmland, and we want to do the same thing. What we don’t want to do—and I want to be very clear about this in this legislative process—we’re not trying to stop people who come from other nations with a vision of becoming farmers here in Ontario. My family came here after the Second World War. My great-great-grandfather was a dairy farmer, my great-grandfather was a dairy farmer, my grandfather was a dairy farmer, became a turkey farmer, then my dad became a pig farmer. Anyway, there’s a whole bunch of agriculture. What’s the point? The point is they came from overseas. They came here because—as we approach Remembrance Day, we’ll acknowledge that the Canadians liberated the Netherlands. And when they liberated the Netherlands, people like my grandparents said, “I want to go to a place where people, like those people, are willing to go across the sea to people who they can’t communicate with in the same language, they don’t know their language, but they are willing to go and fight and die and be willing to stand up for their freedom.” That was why they came to Canada, because they saw how Canadians were when they liberated the Netherlands and how incredible those contributions were. When they came here, they came to work hard and to farm. They were able over time to purchase farmland and to be able to begin that process. I can tell you there are many, many of those stories, because if we’re not Indigenous, we’re all from somewhere at some point, and we came here, and that includes our farming communities. I want to just acknowledge that what we’re not trying to do is stop that kind of a success story. We want people who have a vision of a brighter future to come here from wherever you are coming in the world. You are welcome to come here to invest, to build, to grow and to get involved in agriculture. We need more people in agriculture. What we do not want is large, foreign, multinational entities, who don’t have a vested interest in the success of this province, purchasing land to sit on land. Because I can tell you, if you look at history, farmland in Ontario is a great investment. Farmland in Ontario has gone up, historically—I mean there are ups and downs like with any market. MPP Vanthof was speaking about this in his community and the history of some of the land prices in your area. It goes up and down, but overall, if you look over a 40- or 50-year time frame, there’s a fantastic return on farmland because, again, God is not making any more of it, we need it to be able to produce incredible crops, and we have incredible entrepreneurs. But the reason it’s valuable is because of those entrepreneurs and those visionaries, those risk-takers, those farmers who invest in their land and add value to that. We want those people to be able to continue to do that. But we don’t want people to come in, purchase land, bid up the price against domestic producers who are going to use that land for a good reason and have it lie fallow, just have it there as a—“You know, we’re going to hold onto it for 20, 30, 40 years and eventually, who knows what we’re going to do with it.” We can’t have that kind of speculation. We need domestic ownership for our food security, for our food sovereignty and for our self-reliance as a province. So that is what we’re proposing in the Farmland Security Act. It’s legislation that would enable the province to restrict foreign ownership of farmland. I do want to be clear, we have this legislation in front of us as a House, but it’s enabling in nature, which means you’re still going to see regulations come forward about the specific details of how that would be operationalized, and we want to make sure we get it right. We’re going to cross our t’s, dot our i’s and consult on proposed regulations before it comes into effect. I want to assure people who have questions about, “How is this is going to be operationalized?” “What would this mean in practice?” that you will see very clearly the proposed regulations. We’re very open to feedback, and we’ve been talking about that, the parliamentary assistants and I, even just this week. Now, because we value the insights of farmers, of farming organizations, of municipalities and of people from around the province, we did consult on this legislation, which will also inform the development of the regulatory framework to follow. We received 30 submissions from members of the public this spring. We held significant hearings. Between July 28 and August 12, the members of the Standing Committee on the Interior held public hearings across this province. I have to acknowledge and thank again the MPP for Algoma–Manitoulin, who I know was, I think, at almost every single one of those meetings, if my memory is correct, and just led the charge in terms of fantastic questions for the public, asking them to build out their thoughts at times, and also encouraging colleagues from all sides who had great questions about that. I want to acknowledge and thank the committee members. In the middle of the summer, to go out and to do that type of engagement with the public is so important, and I know that there were many comments that we’ve been reviewing as well as a result of that. Now, this is forward-looking legislation. It’s going to take effect once the regulatory framework is complete. It will apply to farmland acquisitions at that time, which means once the regulations are in place and the act is in force, we will have the requirement to comply with this act, and we’ll need to ensure that anyone acquiring farmland confirms that they meet the requirements of the act. Without confirmation, bluntly, the land transfer registration wouldn’t proceed. It’s that simple. If you can’t demonstrate that you are able to meet the requirements, you can’t transfer. However, this will not apply to Canadian citizens or permanent residents, and we will also clarify how this act applies to corporations, to partnerships and other entities. I want to be clear that this act would not impact current owners of farmland. I’ve had folks reaching out who already own farmland wondering what this would mean. This will not impact current owners, and we will recognize that there’s some flexibility that is needed in certain instances, and that’s why we’re going to actually bring forward a plan that will allow for certain exemptions to the restrictions. We need to be reasonable. We can’t just be dogmatic; we have to be practical. So we’re going to see some of those exemption processes articulated through regulation, perhaps around items that would be smaller parcels of land or that type of transaction, and we’re going to make sure that we’re making those decisions in the best interests of the people of Ontario. More generally, this act will also set out a framework to support the administration and the enforcement of the legislation, including requirements related to the collection and use of information, as well as inspection, investigation and compliance. You’ve heard about the why—why we need to do this to protect those incredible products that we rely on coming from our amazing farmers here in the province—but it is really part of an agenda that the Premier has articulated for self-sovereignty, of recognizing Ontario within a strong, united Canada as a place where we really do kind of have it all. I was thinking this again—the Premier has talked about this—but we all watched the mid-terms, I’m sure, and you see the various states, and you have the peach state, the auto state, the corn state, and they all have their own thing that they’re known for. You drive around Ontario, and you have all of it; you really do. If you’re driving from New Liskeard to Niagara to Windsor to the port of Goderich and everywhere in between—I forgot eastern Ontario; I apologize—up to Glengarry-Prescott, that area as well, you’re going to have a fantastic diversity of commodity groups, a fantastic diversity of production capacity, and it is really unique. There are not a lot of places, at least from what I can tell, anywhere in North America that have that level of diversity, and we need to protect that. Now, another way that we are showing as a government that agriculture is a priority for this Premier and our province as a whole is through the Grow Ontario Strategy. It was first launched in 2022, and I want to acknowledge the former minister from that day, Lisa Thompson, for her leadership and her hard work in bringing that forward. While I’m at it, I have to say, I know Minister Rob Flack had a tremendous role in enacting and bringing forward more of the policies that would inform that strategy. It’s an aggressive timeline, 8% a year—one 8% doesn’t sound like that, that much, but I’m telling you—we all know about compound interest and how that works: you do 7%, I think you double every 10 years or something like that, so you look at the math on 8% and that is a massive amount of increase. We’re seeing success already through those targets and making sure that we’re being nimble. Now, we are reviewing that strategy. We’re in a different era—2022 doesn’t feel like that long ago to some of us, but it was a different era. We didn’t have Trump; we didn’t have those trade threats. We were in a different geopolitical era when it came to even energy. Look at the world that we’re in, for example, with the war in Iran, and even with our partnerships with the federal government. The federal government is now more responsive and understanding of the needs, I believe, of agriculture here in Ontario, but of other industries as well. We need to make sure we’re working with them as they seek to support provinces. PA Rosenberg, the member for Algoma–Manitoulin, is going to be speaking more about the northern Clay Belt and the incredible opportunities that exist in the north, but I do want to just highlight it in glowing terms for a moment if I may, Speaker, because it’s something not a lot of people know about. In the northern Clay Belt, the opportunities that exist there are absolutely massive. There are millions of acres in the north that have potential. I think of beef farmers who I met with who were talking about grazing opportunities.
Hon. Sam Oosterhoff
Some of that has been held up because it can take a really long time to get your lease. I believe 84% of the land in northern Ontario that would be deemed under the Clay Belt is considered to be crown land, which means there’s a process by which the MNR would consider your eligibility, and it takes a while. Let’s be honest, it takes a long time. We need to cut that down, we need to have a condensed timeline, and we’re going to be working very closely with the Ministry of Natural Resources to ensure that we have a process that’s still robust, that respects the need for consultation, that respects Aboriginal rights and the importance of respecting First Nations, but also strengthens our rural economies in the north and brings more folks into northern Ontario, as well as respecting the value that’s already there, for example, in mining claims, forestry uses, existing land uses. We recognize that, but we do see huge advantages. I can tell you, the heat unit changes that you see, not just in northern Ontario but other parts—eastern Ontario again. There are crops there that are growing that never used to be able to grow 15 or 20 years ago. And so there are negative consequences to that in some parts of the province. There’s a reason why our government is investing tens of millions of dollars into irrigation infrastructure in Niagara, out in west St. Catharines and Lincoln and Niagara-on-the-Lake, as well as tens of millions of dollars into southern Ontario, in Leamington and some of those areas, bringing water from our Great Lakes and from water sources to our farmers so they’re able to produce because we have had more droughts over the past couple of decades. So there are downsides, but there are also opportunities, and we can’t be closed-minded to that. We need to be looking forward to how we can take advantage of those opportunities to grow the jobs and prosperity of our great province. So with the Clay Belt, we’re going to simplify the rules, we’re going to establish guidance and create a one-window contact to allow applicants to better unlock the potential the land offers, and I want to thank both the Ministry of Northern Economic Development and Growth and the Ministry of Natural Resources for their collaboration. I will say, Speaker, there are a lot of grants I could run through here about the various investments that have been made in a whole number of areas, including the Northern Ontario Heritage Fund Corp., which has invested, since 2018, in over 700 agri-food projects, $165 million in additional outside investment being brought in through those. But I’m going to go back to the specifics of Bill 109 because that is in fact what we are debating and I’m running close to time. The Beef Farmers of Ontario is an organization which represents 19,000 beef farmers. It’s a lot of beef farmers. Every—I was going to say every one of our ridings, but I realized that’s probably not true for a number of our ridings. Most of our ridings that are outside of a large urban centre would have beef farmers, and they could be small. There are folks who are registered beef farmers, right? They have two, three, four, five steer, maybe, that they’re growing. It’s not always big. I think we think sometimes of beef farmers as the large feedlots. You might see that in some parts of the province, but there are a lot of small producers. I think in my riding, if my memory is correct, and I’d have to go back, I heard there were 300 producers just in my riding alone, which is a substantial number of producers. Their dedication is evident: 55,000 jobs are tied into the beef supply chain and $3 billion in GDP. In this legislation, the BFO has requested a change to how the organization’s licence fees are collected, which was voted upon by the membership of this organization. They’re asking for these changes to the fees, and so these fees are being used to advance promotional marketing, identify opportunities in new trade markets—we talked about the importance of supporting diversification in trade. But right now, when beef farmers process some or all of their own cattle or have someone else do it, they actually don’t have to have the licensing fee collected for that animal. What it really means is that some farmers are paying in; all the farmers are getting the value. All the beef farmers would be getting the benefit of the fees that only some of the producers are paying in. So this is really about levelling the playing field and making sure that everyone is paying their fair share into the beef cattle marketing fees. This will ensure that we have a more equitable collection of those fees. That’s also going to be part of this legislation. I hope folks will support that. I will say, an additional measure that we’re bringing forward and one that the Premier talks about all the time is the need to cut red tape and streamline administrative processes. I love the Minister of Red Tape Reduction’s important comment that she makes regularly, which is that we can’t buy people time. There’s a lot of things that governments can do, but we can’t buy people time. But we can save them time if we’re able to streamline the amount of hours that they have to spend on paperwork. That’s one of the reasons we are consolidating the Agriculture, Food and Rural Affairs Appeal Tribunal and the Normal Farm Practices Protection Board into one tribunal called the Agriculture and Agri-Food Protection Tribunal. Why is this needed? What’s the problem that we’re trying to solve? Currently, if there’s a resolution in a dispute between parties, if there’s a need for a resolution for a dispute—it could be perhaps a neighbour and a food processor, as an example—you would have to go through two processes, and you wouldn’t actually be sure who is going to hear your concern or complaint. We heard about this. We heard about confusion—“Are we going to the agriculture, food and appeal tribunal? Are we going to the Normal Farm Practices Protection Board? Which one is it? Who am I supposed to go to? Am I supposed to do both simultaneously?” We’re going to clear that up. We’re going to make it straightforward. Those two boards and quasi-judicial bodies are now going to be one. So that’s part of this legislation, as well, which I believe will improve efficiency and ultimately save people time. Speaker, I have to tell you this: A little over a hundred years ago, there was a fellow by the name of Ernest C. Drury who was elected as the Premier of Ontario, leading the United Farmers of Ontario—the UFOs. It was 1919. Ontario was coming out of the Great War, the war to end all wars. And who did they look to? They looked to the farmers. They looked to the agricultural workers. They looked to the producers of this great province to lead them into a brighter future, to build out a strong economic powerhouse here in the province of Ontario. And I think they did a really good job. You look at the foundation of our industrialization, you look at the foundation of our economic might here in the province—a lot of that was laid in the early 1920s by the United Farmers of Ontario. Look it up. It’s a fantastic history. We’re a little over a hundred years later, and although we can be thankful that we are not coming out of a shooting war, we are coming out of a trade war. We are in a trade war, and once again, coming out of this kind of war, the people of Ontario look to the farmers; they look to the agri-food producers; they are looking to the leadership of agriculture and to the agri-food sector—one in nine jobs, 852,000 jobs in that sector, $53 billion of economic input. They are going to be the leaders who once again are going to lead us into a brighter future; a stronger, a more prosperous and a more free Ontario. That won’t happen without support from all members of this Legislature. And with that, I want to acknowledge one of those members, a champion for the north, a champion and a friend—Bill Rosenberg, the MPP for Algoma–Manitoulin—to continue debate this morning.
The Acting Speaker (Ms. Jennifer K. French)
I will remind all members that we refer to each other by our ridings or ministerial titles. I recognize the member for Algoma–Manitoulin.
MPP Bill Rosenberg
Thank you, Minister. It’s always a pleasure to listen to him. It just gives us all energy when we’re listening to the minister speak. And I’d just like to congratulate him on his new ministry. We have a great team, and that shows in just the first few meetings that we’ve been involved with. I’m glad to have the chance to stand here today to continue the conversation on the Protecting Ontario’s Food Independence Act and to build on what my colleague has already shared. When you look at this act, it is really about fairly straightforward goals: making sure Ontario can feed itself, support the people who grow our food and stay strong in a world that’s becoming more unpredictable every day. We’re seeing global pressures, supply chain disruptions and rising costs. In this kind of environment, we can’t take our food system for granted. We have to be intentional about protecting it and making it stronger, and that’s exactly what this legislation will do. Ontario’s agri-food sector is already a major strength in this province. As the minister said, it contributes $53 billion to our economy and supports one in nine jobs. The goal here is simple: Keep our agri-food system strong; modernize regulations and processes, where we can improve them; and make sure our farmers and producers have the right tools and the support they need to succeed. Today I’d like to describe some of the key pieces of this bill, including its actions on dairy modernization, veterinary services modernization and drainage infrastructure. I’ll start with dairy. I have deep roots in the sector. My grandfather started a dairy farm and, like many of the farms in my riding of Algoma–Manitoulin, celebrated being a century farm. The processes have certainly changed significantly since that time—genetics and robotics, just to name a couple. However, one thing remains the same: Our farmers are committed today, as they were, and remain proud of what they do. And they are not afraid to go out and work in the dirt every day. The dairy sector plays a significant role in Ontario and it is one that the people across the province take a lot of pride in. One of the proposed changes is to update the definition of regulating products under the Milk Act so it includes more types of milk products, including ingredients such as milk powders. That might seem like a small, technical matter, but it matters significantly. In Canada, milk is priced based on what product it’s going to be used for, whether that is cheese, yogurt or butter. For instance, the system seems to keep prices fair and predictable for both farmers and processors, but over the years the industry has evolved. For example, some processors use fresh milk or liquid milk, while others use components or ingredients. That has created situations where similar products aren’t always treated the same way, because these milk ingredients can be purchased at a changing market price, effectively outside our supply management system. In this situation, you start to lose that sense of fairness in the system. What this proposed change would do is to create a more level playing field across the board. It will make sure that no matter what product is made, the same pricing rules apply to them. That helps increase fairness for producers and helps protect the integrity of the supply management system. What does this mean for the rest of us? It means continued stability and delivery of high-quality milk from Ontario farms for processing right across the province. Ensuring there is consistency in how milk products are priced across Canada also aligns with our broader commitment to remove interprovincial trade barriers. It is important to get this right, because the dairy sector isn’t small. We’re talking roughly 115,000 jobs and $7.4 billion in GDP tied to that value chain. That includes farmers, processors, transporters and retail that make up the ecosystem. Making sure the rules are fair and consistent across the board really matters. Again, we do not want things to be complicated. This proposed change would make sure the system works in the way it is supposed to. While we are on the subject of dairy, we also have a proposal to modernize a matter under the province’s Milk Act. This act has been around since 1965, and while it has served its purpose, the industry today looks very different from how it did at that time. Part of what we’re proposing is to move the food safety and quality elements of the Milk Act to be under the Food Safety and Quality Act, in short because safety requirements belong under the legislation that is designed specifically for food safety. Right now, that responsibility sits with the body focused on marketing, not food safety standards. This change puts the responsibility for this crucial work under the right authority. It will create a more consistent system, align dairy with how other foods are regulated and make sure things are easier to understand for producers and processors. It will bring all types of milk—whether cow, goat or sheep milk, for example—under one framework. This clarification is important because the industry has expanded today to include so many more types of milk than it used to. To put it simply, these updates are about keeping the reputation and high standards of our dairy system strong. People trust Ontario food. They trust its quality and its safety. This proposed change will help make sure we keep earning that trust. Now, shifting gears from dairy to another important component of our agri-food system, I’d like to talk about veterinary professionals. Veterinary professionals play a crucial role in supporting Ontario farmers, and their work in protecting the health and welfare of farmed animals is essential to the success of the agri-food sector. That’s especially true in rural and northern communities, like my riding of Algoma–Manitoulin where access to veterinary services can be more limited and the need is often greater. That is why our government has been taking steps to support the profession and to build capacity where it’s needed most. Through the Veterinary Incentive Program, for example, we are helping increase the number of veterinarians in underserved areas by providing support to newly licensed vets who choose to practise in our communities, helping to address ongoing shortages in food animal services. We have also launched the collaborative doctor of veterinary medicine program in partnership with the University of Guelph and Lakehead University, which expands training opportunities and helps build a stronger pipeline of veterinary professionals. Through the Ontario Agri-Food Innovation Alliance, a partnership between the ministry, the University of Guelph and Agricultural Research and Innovation Ontario—ARIO—we continue to support veterinary education and research through the Veterinary Capacity Program. And we have the Veterinary Assistance Program, led by the Ministry of Northern Economic Development and Growth, which helps offset costs for large-animal veterinary services in eligible communities, including travel, continuing education and temporary coverage. The need for large-animal vets is felt all over Ontario, but it is magnified in the north where long travel distances can create challenges to accessing veterinary services. This is really important, especially in the north for continuing our herd health as we move forward. The Veterinary Professionals Act helps modernize veterinary care by reflecting the modern, team-based approach to veterinary practice. This includes the formal recognition of veterinary techs and the role they play in providing animal care. Our government has been working since late 2024 with the College of Veterinarians of Ontario to explore updates to the regulatory framework of that profession. Through that process, we saw that parts of the Veterinary Professionals Act could be updated to support the implementation of the legislative framework and future regulations. The proposed changes to this act, if passed, would make rules clearer and strengthen how the profession is regulated in the public interest. Most of these changes simply set the groundwork for more detailed rules to come later through regulations. With continued discussion and continued communication together with our producers and stakeholders, we can make it right for today’s producers. At the end of the day, this is about making sure the system can keep up with how the profession is evolving and that veterinarians are supported in providing the care that farmers depend on. Next, I want to touch on something that may not immediately come to mind when thinking about agriculture, but is incredibly important to our farming communities, and that’s drainage. Good drainage makes a big difference when it comes to crop yields, protecting the environment and making sure farmland stays productive and financially sustainable over our time. Through the Agricultural Drainage Infrastructure Program, the province supports major investments right across Ontario, helping to bring together about $40 million each year from municipalities and landowners. These projects help reduce flooding, improve safety and avoid costly damage to farmland and infrastructure. Last year, at the Rural Ontario Municipal Association conference, the government announced an additional $18 million over three years, $6 million each year, to help extend the program and keep up with demand. With our government’s continued investment in drainage, more than 74,000 acres of farmland are improved every year. Drainage is a key part of the infrastructure that supports farming and food production right across the province. It plays an important role in both environmental and economic sustainability, and it’s becoming even more important as farmers deal with more extreme and unpredictable weather. The Ministry of Agriculture, Food and Agribusiness will keep working closely with our farmers and municipalities to better understand the future needs of the program to protect our farmland and keep it productive. Reviewing drainage infrastructure is also a key part of the Grow Ontario Strategy, which focuses on making long-term investments in this sector. Good drainage infrastructure helps make sure farmers have the tools they need to handle both dry conditions and heavy rainfalls while continuing to improve productivity on our farms. In my own riding of Algoma–Manitoulin, because of tile drainage, we have seen several farms now resort from being beef pastures—and they’re growing production of a lot of grains substantially, like corn, beans and canola, that just less than five years ago was not even a thought to grow up in northern Ontario. Moving on, our government also understands it’s important that legislation be reviewed from time to time to ensure it reflects the current environment. That is why we will be consulting on three statutes relating to livestock and poultry that have been on the books in Ontario for many years. These are the Protection of Livestock and Poultry from Dogs Act, the Pounds Act and the Innkeepers Act Laws like the Protection of Livestock and Poultry from Dogs Act or the Pounds Act may not come up often in this chamber, but they do matter to people right on the ground. These statutes deal with a range of real-world situations, from animals wandering off and causing damages, to cases where animals are being boarded, to instances where livestock may be injured or killed by domestic dogs. Our goal in consulting on these laws is to hear directly from the people affected so we can update them in ways that reflect how things work today. That feedback will help us improve clarity and fairness and make sure that the language in these statutes is current, practical and easier to understand.
The Acting Speaker (Ms. Jennifer K. French)
I recognize the member for Hamilton East–Stoney Creek.
MPP Bill Rosenberg
At this time, Madam Speaker, I’d like to turn the final remarks over to the member for Hamilton East–Stoney Creek to continue the presentation on Protecting Ontario’s Food Independence Act.
Mr. Jeff Beattie
I’m pleased to rise today in support of Bill 109, Protecting Ontario’s Food Independence Act. This legislation represents another important step forward in our government’s work to build a sovereign, secure and self-reliant agri-food sector. I want to offer a special thanks to the minister for his work on this file. It’s great to be part of the farm team. I know sometimes the farm team is the second tier, but we are the top tier, and I’m looking forward to working with the minister on this file. With the Premier’s mandate, we are strengthening Ontario agriculture, supporting Ontario farmers, protecting our food supply and ensuring that future generations can continue to build successful businesses in one of our province’s most important sectors. Before I speak about the details of the bill, I want to begin by explaining why agriculture is so important to me personally. Long before I entered public service, agriculture was my livelihood. My family and I operate a greenhouse and garden centre operation in Stoney Creek, a business that my grandfather started 73 years ago in 1953. It gets better: That’s on land that my great-grandfather purchased in 1890, and we’ve farmed ever since, alongside other growers, suppliers, landscapers, truckers, logistics experts, retailers and other farm families who depend on a strong and successful agricultural economy. Those experiences have shaped my understanding of what agriculture means to Ontario. When you work in the sector, you quickly learn that farming is more than a profession, it is more than a business; it is a commitment, it is a lifestyle and it’s built around hard work, resilience and a willingness to adapt to challenges that are often far beyond your control. Farmers cannot control the weather. They cannot control global markets. They cannot control disease outbreaks or invasive pests. Yet, with all of these uncertainties, they continue to get up every single morning and do the work necessary to feed our province, our country and consumers around the world. Over the years, I’ve met countless producers who take incredible pride in what they do. They were the innovators, they are the problem-solvers, they are the entrepreneurs. They’ve invested in new technology, adopted new production methods and constantly look for ways to improve their operations. But what always stood out to me, Speaker, was their optimism. Even in difficult years, Ontario farmers continue to look ahead. That spirit is one of the reasons Ontario agriculture remains one of the strongest and most diverse agricultural sectors in North America. Speaker, agriculture is not simply another part of Ontario’s economy; it is fundamental to our economy, it is fundamental to our communities and it is fundamental to our food security. The agri-food sector supports hundreds of thousands of jobs across the province. It drives economic activity in rural communities, northern communities and urban communities alike. Whether it’s someone that works on the farm, at a processing facility, in transportation, in wholesale, in retail, in research, in equipment manufacturing or foodservice, agriculture touches nearly every part of the Ontario economy. But more importantly, agriculture provides something every Ontarian relies on every single day, and that is food. That is why supporting agriculture is not only an economic priority, it is a national priority. And as we know, a country who cannot feed itself cannot hope to defend itself. Madam Speaker, if we want Ontario agriculture continuing to thrive, we must think not only about today’s challenges but also about tomorrow’s opportunities. One of the most promising opportunities for future agricultural growth can be found in northern Ontario’s Clay Belt. And as the minister stated earlier, the good Lord is not making any more land. However, the Clay Belt contains millions of acres of fertile land stretching across the northern regions of our province. And for many years, farmers and agricultural experts have recognized the significant potential this land holds for agricultural expansion and economic development. Expanding agricultural activity in northern Ontario has the potential to create jobs, attract investment, support local communities and increase our domestic food production capacity. And I can tell you, Speaker, I’ve personally heard from farmers who are excited and optimistic for the opportunities that can be realized in this region. It can provide opportunities for new entrants to agriculture who may be otherwise finding it difficult to access farmland. It can help to diversify regional economies, and it can contribute to Ontario’s long-term food security. The reality is that as our population continues to grow, the demand for food will continue to grow. At the same time, global supply chains have become increasingly vulnerable to disruption. Over the last few years, we have seen how international conflicts, transportation challenges and economic uncertainty can affect access to products and materials. Those experiences demonstrate why maintaining a strong domestic food supply is so incredibly important. The more food we can produce here in Ontario, the stronger and more resilient our province and Canada become. That’s why supporting responsible agricultural expansion is such an important part of the conversation about Ontario’s future. Speaker, at a time when countries around the world are placing greater emphasis on domestic food production and supply chain resilience, Ontario must do the same. Food security is increasingly recognized as an important component of national security. A jurisdiction that cannot produce food for its people becomes vulnerable to disruptions that originate far beyond its borders, and we owe it to the consumers who are depending on a strong, reliable, locally produced food supply. The principles of growth, protection and long-term sustainability are reflected throughout Bill 109. This legislation contains practical measures designed to strengthen Ontario’s agri-food sector and improve its ability to respond to the challenges both today and in the future. One important component of this bill addresses plant health, and I can tell you, as someone who has spent years working in the horticultural sector, I understand how important plant health is to agricultural success. Ontario grows approximately 200 different agricultural commodities. This incredible diversity, as was mentioned earlier, is one of our greatest strengths. It allows producers throughout the province to participate in a wide range of domestic and international markets, as was mentioned. However, the same diversity can also create challenges. Plant diseases, invasive insects and emerging threats can spread very quickly if they are not properly addressed. When plant health is compromised, the impacts can be significant. Producers may experience lower yields, input costs may increase, market access can be disrupted and entire sectors can face economic consequences. Anyone who has worked in agriculture understands that prevention and preparedness are far less costly than reacting to a problem that has already taken hold. That’s why Bill 109 contains measures to strengthen Ontario’s ability to respond to plant health risks and improve overall preparedness. By providing stronger tools and a more effective framework that responds to threats, we can better prepare producers, preserve economic opportunities and support a resilient food system. Madam Speaker, supporting farmers also means ensuring that they can participate in a fair and reliable marketplace. Agriculture requires significant investment. Long before a producer receives any payment for their crops or livestock, they have already invested in substantial resources for their operation. For many producers, months can pass between making those investments and receiving the return on those investments through their commodities. That’s why confidence in the marketplace is essential. Farmers deserve to know that when they enter into a business transaction, the system is working fairly and effectively. Bill 109 includes measures to strengthen producer protection programs and support greater confidence across the agricultural marketplace. These measures will help protect these producers from financial uncertainty while enhancing fairness throughout the supply chain. That stability encourages investment, that stability encourages growth and that stability supports the long-term success of Ontario farmers. Speaker, there’s another component of the Ontario food system that deserves some important recognition, and that is the Ontario Food Terminal. As someone who has spent many decades in the industry, I know first-hand that producing is only one piece of the puzzle. Farmers also need access to efficient and reliable distribution networks to connect their products with consumers. The Ontario Food Terminal plays a critical role in making that happen. It serves as one of the most important food distribution hubs in the province and helps move fresh produce from growers to retailers, restaurants, institutions and consumers. Its importance cannot be overstated. Every day, products move through the terminal and into communities throughout Ontario. The facility helps improve efficiency within the food supply chain and supports both producers and businesses that rely on access to fresh food. Bill 109 contains measures that will support the continued effectiveness and long-term success of this important institution. By strengthening critical infrastructure within Ontario’s food system, we are helping ensure that our supply chains remain reliable and resilient. Speaker, when we look at all the measures contained within Bill 109, a common theme emerges: This legislation is about strengthening Ontario’s food independence. It is about ensuring that Ontario remains capable of producing, protecting and distributing food efficiently and effectively. It’s about supporting farmers. It’s about creating opportunities for growth. It’s about protecting farmland. And it’s about preparing for future challenges. Throughout my career, both in business and now in public service, I’ve had the privilege of working alongside some of the most hard-working and innovative people in this province, and I’m proud to call them my friends. Ontario farmers continue to demonstrate resilience in the face of challenges. They continue to invest in their operations, and they continue to adopt new technologies. They also continue to provide the food that all of us rely on every single day. They deserve a government that understands their challenges and is prepared to be a strong partner in their success. And that’s exactly what Bill 109 seeks to achieve. It strengthens food security. It supports economic growth. It protects our agricultural resources. And it helps to ensure Ontario remains a global leader in agriculture and food production. As the member for Hamilton East–Stoney Creek and as someone who has spent my entire life working in this sector, I am proud to support this legislation, and I encourage all members of the House to join me in supporting Bill 109, Protecting Ontario’s Food Independence Act.
Mr. Jeff Burch
I want to start by congratulating my colleague from Niagara, from the neighbouring riding, for being appointed minister. Niagara has over 1,600 farms, over 208,000 acres, and they support over 24,000 jobs, so I know there was a lot of excitement in the region in having a minister from Niagara. We have a lot of greenhouses in Niagara, and we also have some vertical farming and other kinds of farming. We have a pretty big vertical farming operation in Welland. I’m just wondering, with the foreign ownership component of this bill, how does that affect those operations in making sure that we maintain domestic ownership over those kinds of farms?
Hon. Sam Oosterhoff
I want to thank the member from Niagara Centre for his question. I worked in a few different nurseries and greenhouses in Vineland and Jordan and Beamsville as a teenager, so deep appreciation and respect for our agricultural community in the covered space. The greenhouse sector is one that’s growing. Great question—I would say this: We’re going to make sure that there aren’t unintended consequences to this legislation through the regulatory process to make sure that folks who are in that sector who may have investment that is coming from across the world into those facilities are able to continue. This won’t impact existing ownership or anything like that. So if you’re already working in partnership—I know that there are investors from various places in the world who have passive ownership, for example, in some of these types of greenhouses—that would still be able to continue. But if someone was going to come in and purchase a large amount of land and sit on it and not be productive in the use of that land, we’re not going to allow that. We want to see productivity gains from our investments and from also those who are supporting these types of industries.
Mme Lucille Collard
I understand that this very important bill for farmers contains some important protections from foreign ownership, and I think that’s very important. But also, we heard during the hearings that this is only part of the solution because in the bill, there are apparently no protections from domestic speculation and development. Having heard those concerns from farmers and community representatives, why is it that the government is not protecting farmland ownership from domestic development and speculation?
Hon. Sam Oosterhoff
I want to thank the member for Ottawa–Vanier, a riding where I know there probably aren’t too many farms, but there is definitely agribusiness and associated. Look, at the end of the day, the emphasis on this piece of legislation is, to your point, foreign ownership. If the member has ideas around what we should be doing to avoid unintentional consequences of other speculative practices—happy to hear from you. I don’t think we’re ever going to stop land speculation when it comes to just individuals in a market, as we’ve seen in the condo market in Toronto, as we’ve seen in other markets. The MPP for—from northern Ontario, the opposition critic—
Hon. Sam Oosterhoff
I apologize—Timiskaming–Cochrane spoke about some of the speculative practices that he had seen, and I understand that is a concern. I think there are market forces that do correct some of that when you have a domestic group of farmers or others who are looking at land in a particular area. But if you have ideas that came out of those hearings, I’d be more than happy to sit down and hear them.
Ms. Laura Smith
I want to thank the minister for his remarks. I really enjoyed the information about corn ultimately becoming Parmesan cheese, which is fantastic. Ontario corn being a part of that—I’m very grateful for that information. Agribusiness is very real, especially in my community. It provides a lot of prosperity for the community. And also there’s something that the minister is a huge supporter of, which is market diversification and the trade resilience fund. I wonder if you’d give us a few comments or a bit of information about how this is growing jobs across the province of Ontario.
Hon. Sam Oosterhoff
I have to say to the member from Thornhill, you are a fantastic example of a riding that, again, doesn’t necessarily have farms— Interjection.
Hon. Sam Oosterhoff
One farm. But I can tell you this: It has a massive amount of employment that is added the agri-food sector. We’re going to go and meet some of those businesses, I know. But I can tell you that the Market Diversification and Trade Resiliency Initiative is fantastic for a number of reasons. A $22-million fund was able to leverage 130 projects, 970 new jobs and tens of millions of private sector investment. That is called investment in new and emerging jobs. The other side of that is, again, a lot of those businesses actually take products that come from primary producers, turn them into higher valued-added products and then are exporting those both domestically to other provinces and also internationally. That’s good news for local jobs and it’s good news for producers, because they have off-takers for their primary production. I think that’s the kind of fund that’s going to really enhance our sector as a whole and protect jobs.
Ms. Sandy Shaw
My question is to the member from Hamilton East–Stoney Creek. Thankfully, the government is finally recognizing the strategic and economic importance of farmland, but this bill does nothing to protect farmland itself from its biggest threat, which is the Conservative government and their connections to developers. A case in point is Hamilton, in fact. The Premier clearly broke his promise to Hamiltonians when they overruled our firm urban boundary. We’ve now been allowed to expand into the boundary, 1,600 hectares in the member’s own area. If we are so worried about food sovereignty and protecting farmland, why are we allowing this farmland—this critical, limited resource—to be gobbled up by developers and paved over, when we agree that farmland is important for our food sovereignty, for our provincial sovereignty? Losing it in this way is certainly a shame. Why does the member think that that’s okay?
Mr. Jeff Beattie
Speaker, through you: Thank you for the question from my colleague from the other side of Hamilton. I think what we are talking today about in Bill 109 is protections for foreign speculation on farmland. I know that the minister extended to continue that conversation. What we’re trying to do is protect foreign owners from investing in Ontario in a way that doesn’t lead to productive outcomes for our local producers. The more we can do to ensure that there’s a stable landmass for those producers continuing to expand up into the Clay Belt, as was mentioned, to offer new opportunities for producers to grow and expand into those areas—that’s, I think, the focus we’re trying to make today, and I look forward to continuing those conversations.
MPP George Darouze
Thank you to the minister for his remarks today. I look forward to seeing the great work he does in his new role as Minister of Agriculture, Food and Agribusiness. When Bill 109 went to the Standing Committee on the Interior for public consultations this summer, a well-respected farmer in my riding, Mel Foster, provided a delegation speaking about the importance of protecting our farmland. Can the minister elaborate a bit more on the proposed changes in schedule 3 that would prevent certain foreign-national people or corporations from acquiring farmland and the benefits it would have on preserving our farmland?
Hon. Sam Oosterhoff
Thank you, again, and I want to thank the member from Ottawa for his incredible advocacy for all farmers in the Ottawa region. There’s a massive number of farmers in your riding, but also across the whole national capital. I don’t think it’s always what people think of when they think of Ottawa, but there are a ton of farmers in the city of Ottawa. I know you have been a fierce champion and advocate for them. Thank you for being a voice for Mel Foster, and I look forward to meeting him. Listen, the protections we’ve talked about—and we articulated them this morning. We’re not trying to stop folks who have a vision and a dream of coming to Ontario, coming to Canada, investing in a farm, building up a livelihood for them and their family and contributing. That’s great. What we don’t want is large, multinational corporations coming in, bidding up the price of land or farms that they then sit on and they lie fallow. We cannot have that. We need to protect the land that we have; God’s not making any more of it. Let’s keep what we have and make sure it’s being used well.
The Acting Speaker (Ms. Jennifer K. French)
There is not enough time for another question and answer. Further debate?
Mr. John Vanthof
It’s always an honour to be able to stand in this House and particularly so today as the opposition critic for agriculture and agrifood—I think there’s something else in that title, but anyway—and as a farmer by trade. I really appreciate the opportunity to have time to talk about agriculture and talk about this bill. I’d like to start by congratulating the minister on his new post. I look forward to working with him as I’ve worked with all the previous ministers. I’d like to thank the previous minister particularly for presenting this bill as an agricultural bill; that way, we can actually talk about the issue, about the industry, about the sector, about our food, as opposed to sometimes, as in other bills—Bill 140 had all kinds of things in it. Some were divisive; some were not. As a result of that, you don’t have an actual debate about what’s really important in the bill. This bill is not like that. If you want an example of how to make government work, regardless of your philosophical bent, it’s presenting bills that are on one issue—lots of schedules, but the main core issue is the same. I’d like to really recognize the previous Minister of Agriculture for presenting this bill as that. It makes a big difference. When someone asks me, “What difference? The Legislature doesn’t sit as much as it used to, but it’s much more efficient.” Actually—
Mr. John Vanthof
The government House leader just said, “quality, not quantity,” but actually, he doesn’t have quantity and he doesn’t have quality either. That’s the problem. If Bill 140 had been five bills and we would have talked about—disagreed on some parts and agreed on others. If that had been five bills, you would have come up with five much better pieces of legislation. You wouldn’t have had to—as in some cases, your government has had to—rescind bills. Anybody remember Bill 124, the bill that never was? That wouldn’t have happened if you had actually taken the time to use the Legislature for the job that it was created. We—the left and the right and the middle—might never agree on some things, but I think we can all agree that Ontarians deserve to have good legislation. That’s what this place is for, and Bill 140—although it’s going to pass, likely, at the will of the Legislature, I think deep down we all know that that isn’t good legislation. It isn’t. It’s a mishmash. You’re hiding a few things. Wait till the good farmers of southern Ontario find out, in Oxford county, that they once again might be in line for a garbage dump. Wait till they realize that. The reason that that was stuck in Bill 140, as opposed to actually having a real discussion about what to do about recycling, because your recycling system isn’t working that well; what to do about garbage disposal; what to do about incineration—if we had a real good discussion about that, it would be much better for everybody. But that’s not what we have. We have a mishmash bill—
Wearing of pins
Mr. Anthony Leardi
Madam Speaker, if you seek it, you will find unanimous consent for members to wear forget-me-not pins in the House in recognition of people living with Alzheimer’s disease and other dementias across Ontario.
Protecting Ontario’s Food Independence Act, 2026 / Loi de 2026 visant à protéger l’autonomie alimentaire de l’OntarioBill 109
Third reading debate deemed adjourned.
Wearing of pins
The Acting Speaker (Ms. Jennifer K. French)
I recognize the member for Essex on a point of order.
The Acting Speaker (Ms. Jennifer K. French)
The member for Essex is seeking unanimous consent to wear forget-me-not pins. Is there agreement in the House? Agreed.
Members’ Statements
Veterans
MPP George Darouze
As we mark Veterans’ Week from November 5 to 11, we honour those who served, remember those who never returned and thank the veterans and members of the Canadian Armed Forces whose sacrifices secured the freedoms we enjoy today. I’m grateful to the veterans and military families of Carleton. Their courage, resilience and service continue to strengthen our communities. This year, I was honoured to join the Legion branches in Manotick, Richmond, Greely and Stittsville in celebrating the Royal Canadian Legion’s 100th anniversary, marking a century of supporting veterans and preserving remembrance. I would also like to congratulate Eric Coles of Osgoode Legion Branch 589 on receiving the 2026 Ontario Veterans Award for Community Service Excellence. His dedication to veterans, the Legion and the community embodies the spirit of service we recognize during Veterans’ Week. Throughout Veterans’ Week and on Remembrance Day, we stand together in gratitude and remembrance. To all veterans and military families, thank you for your service and sacrifices. Lest we forget.
Autism services
MPP Fatima Shaban
Care delayed is care denied, and that’s exactly what has happened to families waiting for autism funding in Scarborough Southwest and across Ontario. Parents come to my office, exhausted. They have filled out every form. They have made call after call. They have done everything they were told to do, and they are still waiting years for funding. Meanwhile, their children are growing up. They need help communicating, participating in school and getting through the day. They can’t put their lives on hold until this government gets around to funding their care. So parents try to make it work. They ask themselves, “Can we afford another month of private services? Can I cut back my hours and still afford to pay rent? What happens when I just can’t keep doing this?” No parent should be pushed to that point. And the workers supporting these families are stretched to the limit, without fair pay and reliable funding to keep doing this work. Speaker, a wait-list is not a service. An acknowledgement letter is not support. Telling a family to keep waiting is not a plan. This government has the power to act. Every year it fails to do so is another year it makes children and families pay for that failure.
Missing Black boys
MPP Andrea Hazell
Today, I dedicate my statement to Ontario’s missing Black boys, their families and the organizations fighting to bring them home. Across Ontario, Black boys as young as 12 are being lured, groomed, exploited and dismissed as runaways. Jay’siiah Webb-Long from Brampton was just 16—missing for over a year. He was found dead in Saskatchewan. To his family: We grieve with you, and we will keep saying his name. As a Black mother, this pains my heart. Many families are desperately praying for their boys to come home. On February 25, I wrote to the Solicitor General by email, hand delivery and Canada Post, requesting a meeting with him, myself and organizations that are working on this file. I crossed the floor three times to ask him personally. On May 26, I sent another letter. I finally received his response on June 2 at exactly 3:18 p.m., on the very day this House rose for 147 days. Our young Black boys are not simply running away. They are being targeted, groomed and exploited by criminals. My message to the Solicitor General today: I will not stop asking for this meeting. These families and organizations deserve to be heard. Our Black families matter. Our young Black boys matter.
Riding of Newmarket–Aurora
Mme Dawn Gallagher Murphy
It was a phenomenal summer in Newmarket–Aurora, with more than 250 events, meetings and announcements in which I participated—and, trust me, there was never a dull moment—starting with my third annual Seniors’ Expo, with a record number of visitors of over 400 coming through the expo. Thanks to the Newmarket Very Useful Theatre Company, who acted out a skit that the seniors really enjoyed. Thank you so much. And it was officially Seniors’ Month, so it was wonderful to announce $238,000 in seniors’ active living local programs for my community. Thanks to Experience Ontario, the province supported some amazing festivals with a total of $130,000 for York Pride, the Newmarket Summerfest and the Newmarket multicultural Asian heritage festivals. All were so successful. Tourism was at its peak in Newmarket–Aurora through the summer. Other announcements included $2.8 million in local non-profit organizations across my community, funding supporting Community Living Central York, Kerry’s Place Autism Services, Cornerstone to Recovery, John Howard Society and many more. It also included a visit to World War II veteran Jeff Reynolds, who turned 100 years young at the end of June. I would like to recognize his service and all veterans for their support in strengthening our great province. Lest we forget.
Health care funding
Mrs. Jennifer (Jennie) Stevens
I’ve received 75 emails from St. Catharines residents, each sharing what access to local pain clinics means to their everyday lives. For some it means getting out of bed and going to work; for others it means driving without excruciating pain, caring for their children or simply buying groceries without spending the next two days recovering. Yet, this government is proposing changes to OHIP-funded pain treatments, including severe limits on numbers of treatments patients can receive each year. Not only does this threaten their quality of life; it puts the very clinics they depend on at risk of closing. One resident shared how, after a workplace accident, they struggled with oxycodone and addictions before finding relief through OHIP-funded nerve-blocking injections. Another wrote that these treatments help her get out of bed and overcome the depression that came with being confined there for chronic pain. These clinics provide very timely treatment while helping keep patients out of our already overcrowded emergency rooms. If these clinics close, where exactly does this government expect those patients to go? We are already facing an opioid epidemic, addictions crisis and hospitals stretch beyond their limits. I am calling on this Conservative government to pause these proposed OHIP cuts, consult directly with patients and pain specialists and guarantee that no patient loses access to medically necessary pain treatment today.
Protests in Iran
Mr. Logan Kanapathi
I rise today with a heavy heart to remember the thousands of innocent lives lost during the violent crackdown on protesters in Iran, which began on January 8 and 9, 2026. We stand in solidarity with Ontario’s Iranian community as they mourn those who lost their lives in the pursuit of freedom, human rights and democracy. As we approach this solemn anniversary, we honour the memory of those whose lives were taken away by the Iranian regime, including the many students, academics, professionals, and women and children. We also remember the families whose lives were forever changed by these heartbreaking losses. Their stories remind us of the importance of human dignity, freedom, peace and social justice. While time may pass, our responsibility to remember won’t. I would like to recognize the efforts of the Iranian Eternal Heroes Remembrance, a non-profit organization, and all those who work tirelessly to preserve the victims’ memory through education, storytelling and community engagement, ensuring that future generations never forget. Those who continue to carry this loss, please know that Ontario remembers. We mourn with you, we honour those you lost and we stand with you. May the memories of these innocent lives continue to inspire us to build a world rooted in compassion, understanding and respect for human rights.
Speaker’s Remembrance Day display
Ms. Sandy Shaw
This Remembrance Day, I want to bring attention to a very special exhibit that was curated by our own Speaker, Donna Skelly, to mark Remembrance Day. It’s a special exhibit in the east hall, and I think all of us should make sure to check it out because it features personal artifacts from members’ families that were collected over the years. The exhibit showcases artifacts from the families of MPP Dowie, Attorney General Doug Downey and MPPs Lee Fairclough, France Gélinas, Alexa Gilmour, Laura Smith, Jennie Stevens and Kristyn Wong-Tam. My Shaw family contribution is a memorial plaque that was awarded to my great-uncle Adam, who was killed in the First World War. These plaques were issued to all families who lost loved ones, and it is commonly referred to as a “Dead Man’s Penny.” My family has dutifully preserved Adam’s medal and his memory for over a century. I want to thank the Speaker, and I want to thank Erin Budra from the Ontario Legislature for her work researching and curating this display. She found information about Adam that my family didn’t know until this day, so it’s fitting that I end with her own words: “These items reflect the enduring importance of remembrance. They honour a young soldier whose life was cut short by war and whose memory has been carried forward through generations. We shall remember them.”
Housing
MPP Susan Lahey
I have great news for the residents of Bradford West Gwillimbury. Under the leadership of the Premier, our government, in partnership with the federal government, has awarded the local municipality funding through the Development Charge Reduction Program, a program that will reduce development charges and fund the critical infrastructure required for new homes. Under this program, the town of Bradford West Gwillimbury can receive up to $94.8 million. The town, in turn, can reduce development charges by up to 76%, which is estimated to reduce the purchase price of new homes by up to $36,500 per home. When combined with up to $130,000 in savings through our expanded HST relief on eligible new homes, families in Bradford West Gwillimbury could save over $166,000 off the cost of a new home. Alongside our government’s investments in housing-enabling infrastructure, this could unlock more than 29,000 new homes in Bradford West Gwillimbury. But it doesn’t end there; this investment will also support infrastructure projects in communities across Bradford West Gwillimbury. It will support the upgrade of plant D at Bradford Water Pollution Control Plant, increased municipal water storage at the John Fennell reservoir and the widening and reconstruction of the Line 8 corridor from Sideroad 10 to Barrie Street. Speaker, our government is investing in Bradford West Gwillimbury to support residents by making home ownership more affordable and strengthen local infrastructure to ensure that our community has what it needs to sustain growth.
Education funding
Mr. Lorne Coe
I’m honoured to rise today to speak to our government’s commitment to supporting Whitby students and their families by building new schools. Our government is supporting Whitby’s continued growth by investing up to $85.6 million to build a new west Whitby secondary school. Additionally, we’re investing $54.8 million to build two elementary schools, also in west Whitby. Speaker, with these investments, Ontario is creating 1,384 new secondary student spaces and 1,268 new elementary student spaces as well. For hard-working Whitby families, this will help ensure every child has a place to learn, grow and succeed. With the leadership of Premier Ford and the Honourable Paul Calandra, our Minister of Education, our government is committed to keeping pace with growth and ensuring Ontario families have access to the schools they need.
Remembrance Day
Hon. Steve Clark
If you seek it, you will find unanimous consent that immediately after the moment of silence this morning, members be allowed to make statements in recognition of Remembrance Day, with five minutes allotted to the government, five minutes allotted to the official opposition, five minutes allotted to the third party and two minutes allotted to the independent members as a group, and the Redeemer University choir be permitted to sing In Flanders Fields and O Canada following the statements.
The Speaker (Hon. Donna Skelly)
The government House leader is seeking unanimous consent that immediately after the moment of silence this morning, members be allowed to make statements in recognition of Remembrance Day, with five minutes allotted to the government, five minutes allotted to the official opposition, five minutes allotted to the third party and two minutes allotted to the independent members as a group, and the Redeemer University choir be permitted to sing In Flanders Fields and O Canada following the statements. Agreed? Agreed.
Introduction of Visitors
Ms. Sandy Shaw
It is an honour for me to be able to introduce the Redeemer University concert choir. It’s an unprecedented performance that we’re going to hear today. They are spectacular. I know that we are in for a great treat. They perform annually at the Canadian Warplane Heritage Museum in Ancaster, and it really is genuinely an honour for this House to hear them today.
Hon. Sylvia Jones
Please join me in welcoming Cathy Barrick, CEO of Alzheimer Society of Ontario, along with representatives from 26 local Alzheimer societies across Ontario. Please welcome them to the House.
Mrs. Jennifer (Jennie) Stevens
I want to introduce Cathy Barrick as well, CEO of Alzheimer Society of Ontario, along with Teena Kindt, CEO of Alzheimer’s Niagara, who are here with us today. Teena is a fierce local advocate who I have had the pleasure of working alongside with. Welcome to Queen’s Park, Teena.
Hon. Stephen Crawford
I’m pleased to have a good constituent of mine from Oakville, Sahand Pouladi, in the members’ gallery. Welcome.
Ms. Jennifer K. French
I appreciate that in the Speaker’s Gallery today, I am pleased to welcome my stepdaughter, Janelle Arnold. Welcome.
Hon. Ernie Hardeman
I would like to welcome the Alzheimer Society Southwest Partners to Queen’s Park.
Ms. Mary-Margaret McMahon
Good morning, Madam Speaker and everyone. I would like to welcome some residents from super Scarborough Southwest and beautiful Beaches–East York: the radiant Raposos, Jason and Jessica; outstanding Owen Carey Griffin; effervescent Ellis Ford—no relation, Mr. Premier—and jovial James Dann. Welcome to your House.
Mr. Mike Schreiner
I too want to welcome everyone from the Alzheimer Society of Ontario and give a special shout-out to CEO Cathy Barrick who grew up in Guelph.
Ms. Bobbi Ann Brady
I would also like to welcome to their House the Redeemer University choir. I have a special connection to this school as my youngest, Carter, is a student there, although he doesn’t sing. Welcome to the choir, enjoy your day at Queen’s Park and all the best in future endeavours.
Mr. Terence Kernaghan
It gives me great pleasure to welcome the CEO of the Alzheimer Society Southwest Partners, Steph Ouellet. Welcome to Queen’s Park.
Ms. Sandy Shaw
I’m delighted to welcome to Queen’s Park Abraham Reyes, who is the father of today’s page captain, Andrea Reyes Martinez. Welcome to Queen’s Park.
Hon. Raymond Sung Joon Cho
I am very happy to welcome my church members. They are Mr. Stanley Ha, Mrs. Elly Ha and Dakyung Jung.
Mr. Rudy Cuzzetto
Today, I would like to welcome my OLIP intern, Elijah Aedo-Castillo, to the House.
Hon. Mike Harris
I thought today would be very fitting to give a quick update on a former page of ours, my son, Jaxon Harris, who is currently an aviator recruit at basic training with the Canadian Forces. We’re very, very excited and very proud in our family, and I thought everyone might like to hear that on a day like today.
Mr. Sheref Sabawy
I would like to welcome my mentor at George Brown, Dr. Khalid Danok; his daughter, Lames Danok; and his son, Youssef Danok.
Ms. Laura Smith
It is my very great pleasure to welcome Lisa Levin, CEO of AdvantAge Ontario, a Thornhill resident.
Mr. Logan Kanapathi
I would like to welcome Susan Martin from Iranian Eternal Heroes Remembrance. Thank you for your leadership and compassion for humanity. Welcome to Queen’s Park.
Mr. Jeff Beattie
A special welcome to my friend Connor Gibson, who knocked on doors with me in Hamilton East–Stoney Creek this past August and has just returned from beautiful British Columbia to help deliver the first Conservative government in BC in nearly 100 years.
Mme Lucille Collard
I want to welcome the OLIP interns who are here with us today, but a specific welcome to Jacob Colatosti, who’s my intern and is starting today.
Remembrance Day
The Speaker (Hon. Donna Skelly)
Members, if I could have your attention. In recognition of Remembrance Day, the House will now pause and observe two minutes of silence in honour of those who died serving their country in wars and peacekeeping efforts. I ask members to rise.
The House observed two minutes’ silence.
The Speaker (Hon. Donna Skelly)
You may be seated. I now invite members to make their statements.
Hon. Doug Ford
As Premier of Ontario, it’s an honour to stand in this House to remember, to reflect and to give thanks to those who have served in Canada’s military. On November 11, at the conclusion of Remembrance Week, we pay tribute to the brave Canadians who answered the call to serve. We remember the courageous men and women who served in both World Wars, the Korean peninsula, the Persian Gulf and Afghanistan, as well as those who participated in international peacekeeping missions, protecting those who were unable to defend themselves. This year is especially poignant following the devastating fire at CFB Wainwright, which claimed the lives of four service members while leaving dozens more in critical condition. I want to thank all the heroic Ontario health care workers who were deployed to support the recovery efforts, and we continue to pray for those impacted by the fire. In a world still marked by conflict, the Canadian Armed Forces play a vital role in protecting our nation and contributing to peace and security around the world. Remembrance Day is a reminder that freedom and democracy are not guaranteed. They must be safeguarded to be passed on to future generations. To our veterans, on behalf of the people of Ontario, I offer our deepest gratitude. To the men and women serving today, thank you for your dedication and professionalism. To the families and friends of those who serve, thank you for your support and sacrifice. And to those who gave their lives in service to Canada, we will continue to honour your memory and gratitude so that we can build a better province and country worthy of your sacrifice. Every year, Ontario also honours our First Nations, Inuit and Métis service members who have served and continue to serve our country with distinction. On November 8, National Indigenous Veterans’ Day, to preserve the legacy of Canada’s veterans and our country’s contributions to the Second World War, the Ontario government is honoured to donate $200,000 towards the Juno Beach Centre’s campaign to help preserve the history of Canada’s sacrifices and maintain the heritage lands of Juno Beach in Normandy, France. And this year, to encourage the people of Ontario to attend their local Remembrance Day service, Ontario is highlighting the stories of remarkable members of the armed forces and true Canadian heroes, including Air Marshal Billy Bishop, Sergeant Aubrey Cosens and Private Jess Larochelle, each of whom went above and beyond the call of duty in the service of their country. To Canada’s veterans, to every active service member and to all who never came home, Ontario will never forget your sacrifices. As Remembrance Week begins, I encourage everyone in Ontario to wear a red poppy in honour of our soldiers, to attend a ceremony and observe the moment of silence and to never take for granted the freedoms we are blessed to have today. To every veteran, service member and military family in our province, thank you. Ontario is proud of you. Canada is proud of you. Lest we forget. Thank you, and may God bless our men and women in uniform.
Mrs. Jennifer (Jennie) Stevens
At the 11th hour on the 11th day of the 11th month, the guns fell silent. But for thousands of Canadian families, the silence was only the beginning: a son who would never walk through the front doors again, a mother who would wait for the letter that would never come, a child who would know their father only by a photograph, a family left to carry a lifetime of unanswered questions. That is what we remember—not simply wars, not simply battles, but the people, the lives, the families and the extraordinary cost for our freedom. When we remember the First World War, remember the trenches, the mud, the cold, the relentless rain, the fear of the young Canadian who lay there wondering whether they would ever come home again—they were someone’s child, someone’s brother, someone’s sweetheart, someone’s entire world. More than 118,000 Canadians have made the ultimate sacrifice in military service throughout our history, from the South African War to the First World War and the Second World War, Korea, Afghanistan and the many peacekeeping missions and conflicts in which Canadians have served. We remember them all. We remember our First Nations, Inuit and Métis veterans, whose courage and service helped defend this country, even when they returned home to a country that did not afford them the equality they deserved. Their service must never be overlooked. Their stories must never be forgotten. We remember those we have lost this year, including the four Canadian soldiers who lost their lives during training at CFB Wainwright. Their families expected them to come home. They will not be coming home. We will remember them. We remember that service and sacrifice are not simply a part of the past; they are part of the present. To those serving overseas today, to those carrying visible and invisible wounds, to those training to serve for tomorrow and to every family waiting for their loved one to return safely, we see you, we honour you and we stand with you. Speaker, for me, this is very deeply personal. My grandfather served. My father served. And today, my son, Jonathan Lindal, serves as chief petty officer second class in the Royal Canadian Navy. When I think of my Jonathan, I think of the generations before him, of the promise that he has carried throughout our family to stand up for this country, to protect its people and to serve something greater than ourselves. I know that members in this House have their own stories—a parent, a grandparent, a spouse, a son or a daughter who served, who serves today or who is preparing to serve our country. To every one of those families, this remembrance belongs to you. Speaker, I want to recognize the member from Kanata–Carleton. Karen, you have donned the uniform. You understand the commitment and the sacrifice of service. Thank you. Thank you for what you have given our country and for continuing to serve in this House. And as the Royal Canadian Legion marks its 100th anniversary, we thank every member, we thank every volunteer and every branch that has spent a century keeping our promise to remember. One day, the voices of those who witnessed these wars will be gone, and when that day comes, it will be up to us. It will be up to us to tell the stories, to speak their names, to teach the children and to make certain that remembrance is not reduced to a ceremony, a wreath or a moment of silence, because remembrance is a responsibility. To those who fell, we owe our remembrance. To those who returned, we owe our gratitude. To those who serve today, we owe our unwavering support. To those who will serve tomorrow, we owe a country worthy of their courage. I stand here as a proud Canadian. I stand here as a daughter of a military family and a mother of a son who serves. I know that the freedom we enjoy was not freely given; it was protected by ordinary Canadians who did extraordinary things, by people who left everything they loved, not knowing whether they would ever return. So let us never take that freedom for granted. Let us never forget the families who waited, the lives that were lost or the generations who carried the weight of that sacrifice. Let us make one promise here in this House, and to those who have donned the uniform: Your service mattered, your sacrifice mattered and your life mattered. We remember the past. We honour those who serve in the present. We have the duty to protect the future they fought to give us. May we never forget who paid the price for our freedom. May we always be worthy of their sacrifices. And may every generation that follows know without hesitation that Canada remembers; that we gratefully, that we profoundly and fiercely are proud to be Canadian, and that we will never ever forget. Lest we forget.
Mrs. Karen McCrimmon
Every year on November 11, Canadians pause to remember those who served, those who sacrificed and those who gave their lives so that we could live in freedom. It’s a time for reflection, for gratitude and for honouring the extraordinary courage of ordinary Canadians who answered the call when their country needed them. Behind every service member is a family whose life is changed forever—thank you, Jen. I’ve always believed that when a member of the military serves, the entire family serves and worries. For some of these families, that worry becomes an unimaginable loss. We were reminded of that terrible reality just recently with the tragedy at CFB Wainwright with the loss of Sergeant Morgan Wong, Private Shaun Farrell, Private Aidan Goulding and Private Hayden Lykkemark and the serious injury of so many more. All of them were Canadians who stepped forward to serve their country. We must retell the story of Private Aidan Goulding. His mother shared that Aidan had left a steady job as a mechanic to join the Canadian Armed Forces. He told her that he had only one life to live and he wanted to dedicate it to protecting his country. Speaker, think about that. A young Canadian with his whole life ahead of him deciding that protecting his country, his fellow Canadians and the freedoms we enjoy was worth dedicating his life to. What an extraordinary sense of duty, what an extraordinary commitment to something greater than oneself, and what a heartbreaking reminder that the courage and sacrifices we honour on Remembrance Day are not confined to the history books; they are alive in the hearts of young Canadians today. As we remember all those who served, whether in the trenches of Europe, on the beaches of Normandy, in Korea, Afghanistan, on peacekeeping missions and on operations around the world or here at home, we must remember what they were fighting for. They fought for a country where people could live in freedom; where the rule of law would prevail over the arbitrary exercise of authoritarian whims; where people would be treated fairly, with dignity; where the rule of law prevails whether one is rich or poor; where power would be exercised with competence, fairness and compassion; and where future generations could live in peace and security. These are all extraordinary gifts, but they came with an extraordinary price. So, Speaker, I believe Remembrance Day demands something more of us than remembrance alone. Here in this chamber, remembrance demands that we ask ourselves some difficult questions: Are we serving the people of Ontario with the same integrity, commitment and courage as those who have served us? Are we doing everything we can to keep faith with those who sacrificed so much for us? Are we protecting the democracy, the freedoms, the rule of law and the way of life that they gave everything to defend? I believe that is a question every one of us should carry with us, not just on Remembrance Day, but every day we have the privilege of serving in this House. Speaker, they gave up their tomorrows so that we could have ours, and we have a responsibility to make those tomorrows count to the best of our abilities. We cannot repay their sacrifices, but we can honour it through our actions, through the choices we make, the values we defend, the priorities we set, the way we serve our fellow Canadians. Democracy and freedom are not guaranteed. They must be protected, defended and renewed by every generation. Those of us who have the privilege of serving in this House have a particular responsibility to lead by example. Surely the least we can do is bring that same spirit of duty, integrity and selfless service to the responsibilities entrusted to us in the service of the people of Ontario. We must never forget their sacrifice. We must never forget why their sacrifice became necessary, and we must never forget that it is our responsibility, not only to remember, but to honour that legacy by leading today with courage, compassion and integrity. Lest we forget.
Mr. Mike Schreiner
Speaker, it is a deep honour to pay tribute to veterans who have sacrificed so much for all of us. On the 11th hour of the 11th day of the 11th month, we all gather to remember those who selflessly served, who paid the ultimate sacrifice. I encourage each and every one of us to live by the words of Guelph’s Lieutenant Colonel John McCrae in his famous poem that said, we must not break faith with those who fought and died for our freedom. I’m a proud member of our Royal Canadian Legion Branch 234, named after John McCrae, and this is the 100th anniversary of the Legion. I encourage all Ontarians to not only wear your poppy but to donate to the Legion to support the good work they do, because no veteran should be homeless, no veteran should struggle to access mental health services or go hungry. We owe it to them as our debt of gratitude. Lest we forget.
Ms. Bobbi Ann Brady
There is a quote by Winston Churchill, that the further backward you look, the further forward you can see. On Remembrance Day, we look backward to honour those who served in the Boer War, the First and Second World Wars, Korea, peacekeeping missions, the Gulf and Afghanistan. But we must never become so focused on remembering the soldier of yesterday that we fail to recognize the soldier who stands among us today. The uniform may have changed, the equipment may have changed and the nature of warfare may have changed, but the courage to serve and the willingness to put the safety of others before oneself have not. Today, Canadians continue to serve in a world where peace cannot be taken for granted. I believe we as policy-makers have a responsibility to protect the freedoms, our democratic institutions and principles that generations before us have secured. We honour their service not simply by remembering their past, but by accepting our responsibility for the future. Lest we forget.
Applause.
The Speaker (Hon. Donna Skelly)
Members, this morning, in the west public gallery, I am delighted to welcome Hamilton’s Redeemer University Concert Choir. Under the direction of conductor Andrea Van Pelt Pereira, the choir will now perform In Flanders Fields.
Singing of In Flanders Fields.
The Speaker (Hon. Donna Skelly)
Members and guests, please rise and join the choir in the singing of our national anthem.
Singing of the national anthem / Chant de l’hymne national.
Question Period
Government accountability
Ms. Peggy Sattler
My question is to the Premier. Speaker, yesterday, the Premier said that low-risk career colleges will be cleared by this government, then his minister contradicted him. Under that minister’s watch, close to a billion dollars of public money went to fraudulent institutions, a boondoggle that is upending people’s lives. I have heard from students who are training for the jobs we need, like PSWs, paramedics, dental assistants. They did everything right, but their dreams are shattered because this Premier left the door wide open for fraud. Can the Premier tell these students exactly when their OSAP funds will be released?
The Speaker (Hon. Donna Skelly)
I recognize the Minister of Colleges and Universities.
Hon. Nolan Quinn
Thank you to the member opposite for the question. As the Premier and I have repeatedly stated, we’re working as quickly as possible to ensure that we can restore the integrity of the OSAP system under the private institutions. But we need to ensure that we’re driving home the seriousness of these allegations of fraud towards the taxpayers of Ontario, Speaker. We take this very seriously. That’s why we brought it forward to the Ontario Provincial Police and also notified the Auditor General of the serious nature of these allegations. I need to ensure that I have confidence back in the OSAP system, and that is why we brought forward KPMG, the forensic auditors, the experts when it comes to this topic, to ensure that we have confidence in the OSAP system before we release another Ontario taxpayer dollar. One taxpayer dollar going towards fraud is one taxpayer dollar too many, and that’s why we take every single tip seriously, and we investigate every single tip very thoroughly.
Ms. Peggy Sattler
Students need answers. They need a timeline. They did what the Premier told them to do: They saved money, they enrolled in a program that promised them a good job, they went to school for an in-demand career so they could build a good life. But now they are not only being punished by this government, they are being blamed. Yesterday, the Premier said students were abusing OSAP when he knows that it was fraudulent career colleges, many run by PC Party donors who, were abusing the system. When will the Premier stop blaming students and start admitting that his government failed?
Hon. Nolan Quinn
Speaker, as I’ve said many times in this House, I understand the impact on the good students, even the students from Redeemer who were just speaking. I am just as frustrated as they are that the Ontario taxpayer has been defrauded. I am extremely frustrated that bad actors and wrongdoers have taken advantage of the Ontario taxpayer and unfortunately utilized OSAP dollars not for their intended use; they used it for fraudulent purposes. But these are very, very serious allegations. We take every single allegation very seriously. We investigate every single tip that we receive in the ministry, and that’s how we got to this point. That’s why we understood we needed to bring in KPMG, because it was more widespread than we initially thought. We’ve done over 3,200 OSAP investigations just since 2020, and we’ll continue taking every single tip seriously and we’ll investigate every single tip of wrongdoing across the system.
Ms. Peggy Sattler
Private institutions like Redeemer and others are not the bad actors. They should not be blamed. Career Colleges Ontario flagged the bad actors. The minister knew who the bad actors were, but instead of doing his job and immediately inspecting the flagged colleges, this minister waited, allowing hundreds of millions more dollars to flow out of public coffers. After it was too late, he cut off every single student in Ontario instead of going after the bad actors. When will the Premier fire his Minister of Colleges and Universities?
Hon. Nolan Quinn
I will repeat myself numerous times to ensure that the time frame is correct. In late 2024, we realized that there was an increased amount of OSAP applications at private institutions. In January 2025, Career Colleges Ontario, a third-party agency, brought forward the same concerns that we had in my ministry. We recognized those concerns, and in May 2025, the federal government completed their own investigation, gave the results of those investigations to my ministry officials, after which we started doing enhanced and targeted inspections to the sector, Speaker. In July 2025, we brought forward those inspections to the institutions and then, this spring, we removed eligibility from those six institutions. So after two years of individual inspections and investigations into institutions, once we realized how widespread this was, we knew we needed to act very quickly, and we needed to bring in KPMG to ensure that we bring back confidence into the private OSAP system at private institutions. But again, we needed to bring in the OPP. This is a very serious matter, and we will not apologize for bringing in the Ontario Provincial Police. This is something that needed to be done because it was widespread right across the sector. Wrongdoers have defrauded the Ontario taxpayer, and we’re going to ensure that we have confidence back in the OSAP system.
Health care funding
MPP Robin Lennox
For weeks now, the Minister of Health has been using health experts as a shield for denying life-saving cancer treatments to Sabrina Apitz-Grossman, Alex Shved and others trying to access treatment. Today we learned, through a freedom-of-information request, that coverage for Sabrina’s treatment was recommended by health experts, and it was in fact this ministry who denied approval. Speaker, this is outrageous. Alex took this Conservative government to court and won. Sabrina had to submit an FOI. Why is this Premier making cancer patients spend their time fighting this government in court instead of giving them the cancer treatment they need to live?