The committee met at 1459 in room 151, following a closed session.
Legislative Assembly of Ontario · Committee
Monday, November 3, 2025
Standing Committee on Public Accounts
The official transcript of the meeting, from Hansard, by heading. Ministers, officials and witnesses appear as the transcript names them; committees have no live transcript, so the record appears once the Assembly publishes it.
Ministry of Infrastructure; Ministry of Tourism, Culture and Gaming; Infrastructure Ontario; Metrolinx
Consideration of the Performance Audit: Ontario Place Redevelopment.
The Chair (Mr. Tom Rakocevic)
I would like to call this meeting of the Standing Committee on Public Accounts to order. We are here to begin consideration of the 2024 Performance Audit: Ontario Place Redevelopment. Joining us today are officials from the Ministry of Infrastructure; Ministry of Tourism, Culture and Gaming; Infrastructure Ontario; and Metrolinx. You will have 20 minutes collectively for an opening presentation to the committee. We will then move into the question-and-answer portion of the meeting, where we will rotate back and forth between the government, official opposition and the third party caucuses in 20-minute intervals. Before you begin, the Clerk will administer the oath of witness or affirmation. The way we’re going to be doing it is just the people at the lead table. If you have to reach out to somebody behind you, at that point they will have to either affirm or swear an oath as well. During the question-and-answer rotations, I will pause the clock so as not to lose member time when that transition occurs.
The Clerk of the Committee (Ms. Thushitha Kobikrishna)
I’ll just administer the oath and then we can go ahead. I’ll begin with Nancy Kennedy. Do you solemnly affirm that the evidence you shall give to this committee touching the subject of the present inquiry shall be the truth, the whole truth and nothing but the truth?
The Clerk of the Committee (Ms. Thushitha Kobikrishna)
Ali Veshkini, do you solemnly affirm that the evidence you shall give to this committee touching the subject of the present inquiry shall be the truth, the whole truth and nothing but the truth?
The Clerk of the Committee (Ms. Thushitha Kobikrishna)
Thank you. Michael Robertson, do you solemnly affirm that the evidence you shall give to this committee touching the subject of the present inquiry shall be the truth, the whole truth and nothing but the truth?
The Clerk of the Committee (Ms. Thushitha Kobikrishna)
Thank you. Angela Clayton, do you solemnly affirm that the evidence you shall give to this committee touching the subject of the present inquiry shall be the truth, the whole truth and nothing but the truth?
The Chair (Mr. Tom Rakocevic)
You may begin, but I remind you: On the first time that you are speaking, if you may, give your name and title for Hansard. Thank you very much. Please begin.
Ms. Nancy Kennedy
Good afternoon. My name is Nancy Kennedy, and I’m Ontario’s Deputy Minister of Tourism, Culture and Gaming. Chair and members of the committee, it is a privilege to be here to speak with you today. I’m joined today by Deputy Minister Ali Veshkini from the Ministry of Infrastructure; Angela Clayton, chief executive officer of Infrastructure Ontario; and Michael Robertson, assistant deputy minister of the Ontario Place Redevelopment Secretariat. I also want to thank Michael Lindsay, who is present today in his capacity as the former CEO of IO. To start and for context, I want to take you on a quick journey that begins with Ontario Place as many of us remember it. It was once a vibrant hub for families, friends, concertgoers and tourists to gather. For years, Ontario Place stood as a symbol of what was possible; a place where innovation, recreation and culture converged on Toronto’s waterfront. But as time passed, while some of the areas of the site remained open, declining visitors and revenues led to its closure in 2012. The site became derelict, its potential untapped, its legacy at risk of fading away. The government saw not just what Ontario Place was but what it could be and moved forward to transform Ontario Place from a neglected relic into a world-class waterfront tourism destination, welcoming millions of visitors from across Ontario, Canada and the world, becoming a hub for unique visitor experiences and community connections. Ontario Place offers more than a stretch of shoreline, more than a scenic backdrop. We have a bold vision. We see a living, breathing and evolving destination that has the potential to contribute significantly to Toronto’s waterfront and Ontario. That is why we are transforming the site into a modern, year-round attraction that will restore Ontario Place as a vibrant hub for families, students and tourists, while also driving economic growth for the province as a whole. This is more than a rebuild; it’s a reinvestment and a reimagination for Ontario’s future. We are giving a new life to a place that means so much to so many, ensuring it continues to enrich the province’s economy, culture and communities for generations to come. People across the province deserve modern amenities and attractions, and the government is confident that the reimagined Ontario Place will both provide for Ontarians everywhere and showcase to millions of visitors everything our province has to offer. The new public park at Ontario Place will preserve key heritage and recreational features of the site, connecting to all the new attractions while offering free public access to the waterfront for residents and tourists alike to explore year-round. I am grateful for this opportunity to highlight the steps we have taken to transform Ontario Place. We know Ontario Place has a special place in the hearts of people across the province. We understand and respect its importance as a waterfront public destination for communities across the city of Toronto, the greater Toronto area and the province. The government made sure commitments for Ontario Place’s redevelopment were included in the terms of the new deal with the city of Toronto, ensuring continued collaboration and engagement with municipal partners as we move forward with this project. After two years of Indigenous, public and stakeholder engagement, the government unveiled the final designs for Ontario Place’s public realm earlier this summer. We understand that Ontarians do not want a casino or condos on the site, and we have listened. Between 2021 and 2024, more than 9,300 people provided their input directly to the government on the future of Ontario Place along with feedback received from Indigenous communities, the city of Toronto and key stakeholders. Feedback received was considered as part of early planning and development of the site including the design of the future park land and public spaces. I’d like to take a few minutes to describe what you can expect of Ontario Place in the area we call the public realm, which people will be able to access free of charge. Ontario Place’s beloved parkland and shoreline have been reimagined to include more than 50 acres of free public space with brand-new modernized amenities, family areas, event spaces, picnic spaces, art fixtures and more. Upon first approach to the park, visitors will come across the mainland district, the front doors of the renewed Ontario Place. Incorporating public plazas, promenades and marquee gateways, this area will also allow for connectivity with travel and transit options, reaching streamlined access to waterfront trails, parking and rideshare drop-off locations. At the heart of the park, the forum will provide ample space for concerts, outdoor markets, festivals and community events of all sizes. The forum’s centrepiece will be a full one-acre splash fountain in the shape of Ontario’s iconic trillium—the largest fountain of its kind in the province. To the south, the new water’s edge district will feature a brand-new terraced shoreline incorporating an extended William G. Davis Trail. This innovative design will not only provide an exciting visitor destination for relaxation, picnics and sunsets, but it will also ensure long-term sustainability with its focus on erosion protection and flood mitigation. Brigantine Cove will be transformed into an urban beach, featuring boardwalks and playgrounds, including a multi-level interactive tree house and a turtle-shaped play structure paying homage to the location’s First Nations heritage. The new family-friendly cove will provide a year-round destination for cultural events, Indigenous storytelling and children’s play while also incorporating expanded amenities such as changing areas and washrooms. The Ontario Place Marina will become a vibrant hub of open-air pavilions, boardwalks and expanded spaces for future programming and amenities. Featuring stunning views of Toronto’s skyline, modernized facilities and moorings will accommodate enhanced boat traffic for visitors travelling by water. This integration of land and water is a crucial aspect of the government’s vision for Ontario Place. We are expanding possibilities for exploration with new canoe and kayak launch sites to allow visitors to enjoy Lake Ontario and explore the park from the water itself. Finally, an Indigenous cultural pavilion will provide up to 3,400 square feet of public space on the east island, offering a dedicated area for community gatherings, workshops and learning programs. The final design of the parkland and public spaces at Ontario Place reflects more than two years of public stakeholder and Indigenous engagement. We’re proud of the work, the partnerships and the conversations that have gone into planning and designing the public realm and are excited to see it take shape. As you know, Ontario Place will also become the new home of the Ontario Science Centre. The new OSC has always been an element of the government’s bold vision for Ontario Place. The new state-of-the-art facility will be designed and built to modern standards, ensuring an accessible and welcoming environment for all visitors and staff while also inspiring the next generation of innovators. It will provide fresh opportunities for the OSC to offer expanded programming and exhibits, sparking curiosity and innovation in a new generation of visitors. Serving as a vibrant hub of dynamic partnerships focused on science education and engagement, the new Ontario Science Centre will continue its mission of inspiring and engaging teachers and students with learning-centric approaches, directly and measurably contributing to Ontario’s STEM pipeline. It will drive awareness, engagement and participation in science and innovation in everyone we serve, helping to build science capital in our society and supporting strong citizenship. It will broaden the centre’s reach as a beloved and trusted source of family-focused fun and interactive in-person and virtual scientific experiences, serving as a premier destination in the province’s cultural tourism landscape and contributing to a strong Ontario economy. The OSC’s brand new custom-built facility will be located on the mainland of Ontario Place. During the transition period, the OSC currently has two temporary satellite locations continuing to serve visitors, offering programming and exhibitions—one at Harbourfront Centre’s downtown Toronto location and another at Cadillac Fairview Sherway Gardens in Etobicoke—along with many pop-ups and other events. Ontario Place will also feature Live Nation’s revitalized amphitheatre, transforming the iconic seasonal venue into a year-round destination to continue delivering world-class concerts and performances from a leader in the live entertainment industry. The amphitheatre has been a long-time staple of a Toronto summer, operating on the site since 1994 and creating musical memories that last a lifetime. With this transformation, the expanded venue will be able to build on that legacy, thrilling concertgoers every month of the year, becoming a key destination in the city and part of the province’s dynamic music tourism sector. Finally, the west island will feature Therme Canada’s water park and wellness destination, a new landmark along Toronto’s waterfront. The family-friendly facility embodies a commitment to wellness, well-being and connection with social saunas, wade pools and thermal bathing—
Ms. Nancy Kennedy
—all set amongst a vibrant botanical garden and inspired by spa traditions from around the world. Therme’s facility will sit alongside 16 acres of public park and beach areas, offering year-round free public access to the iconic waterfront, and new immersive spaces representing a commitment to ecological stewardship and community connection. The new Ontario Place will be served not only by transit connections but also by a new provincially owned parking structure with up to 3,500 spots, designed to enhance connectivity across the waterfront and support access to the site’s many attractions. This parking will be built for long-term sustainability, serving the needs of all Ontario Place users, from beach-goers and trail-walkers to concert attendees, marina users and Ontario Science Centre visitors. It reflects the province’s commitment to ensuring the revitalized Ontario Place has the infrastructure needed to handle not only the demands of today but the needs of tomorrow. Beyond transportation and financial sustainability, our redevelopment efforts are also focused on protecting and enhancing the natural environment. The government has already taken significant steps in ensuring the site is development-ready, and this has gone far beyond basic infrastructure. Site preparation work has paid close attention to ecological stewardship. Soil remediation, heritage preservation and environmental investigations underpin our dedication to the natural environment of this crucial area. Redevelopment work will reinforce the island’s shoreline, creating a flood-resistant landscape that preserves the waterfront destination for future generations. The water’s edge will be supported by open spaces, connected by a network of multi-use trails. The landscape strategy prioritizes plants and trees that are indigenous to southern Ontario, creating a dense and diverse habitat that showcases our province’s natural history and beauty. In addition to these environmental enhancements, the redevelopment of Ontario Place will deliver significant economic benefits to the province. During the site’s construction, early estimates anticipate the project will create more than 4,700 jobs, add $420 million to Ontario’s GDP, generate $68 million in provincial tax revenue and attract $500 million in private investment. Once complete, we expect Ontario Place to attract up to six million visitors a year and support more than 2,000 jobs. This economic activity will boost Toronto, the GTA and the surrounding region, but most importantly it will deliver upon the promise of Ontario Place, creating a destination that not only drives prosperity but truly belongs to and serves all Ontarians now and for generations to come. I would like to focus next on the important work we are engaged in with First Nations and Indigenous partners. I touched on this a bit earlier in my remarks, but I think it merits highlighting in more detail. It’s a great example of the kind of truly meaningful consultation we are all aspiring to. The Ontario Place Redevelopment Secretariat, led by my colleague Michael, has always recognized that its duty to consult is a vital component of our work. Ontario, as the crown, has a legal obligation to consult with First Nations people on decisions or actions that may adversely impact asserted or established treaty rights. The redevelopment of Ontario Place includes activities related to in- or above-water work, which have been legally assessed as presenting a medium-to-high risk due to potential impacts to fishing rights and title to water. Accordingly, we have sought consultation with the Mississaugas of the Credit; the Six Nations of the Grand River, as represented by elected council; the Haudenosaunee Confederacy Chiefs Council; and Alderville, Curve Lake, Hiawatha, Mississaugas of Scugog Island and Kawartha Nishnawbe First Nations. We ensured this consultation happened early, often and transparently, and we remain committed to continuing this consultation as the project moves forward. We have maintained a tailored nation-to-nation approach to consultation, respecting each nation’s concerns and asserted treaty rights. Consultation has been structured across multiple project streams and activities to ensure it is meaningful and comprehensive. Since 2019, the Ontario Place Redevelopment Secretariat has developed productive relationships with First Nations and Indigenous organizations and consulted on more than 20 project streams related to the redevelopment. Over a dozen consultations have already been completed, with a dozen more planned or under way as we continue to work with our First Nations partners on how we’re preparing the lands and Ontario Place for redevelopment. In addition to consultation, we have also engaged Indigenous communities and urban Indigenous organizations on design elements for the public realm, working closely with design firm LANDinc to ensure the reimagined Ontario Place honours Indigenous peoples and perspectives, educates visitors on the site’s rich heritage and serves as a welcoming and educational environment for current and future generations. As part of this work, more than 60 engagement sessions with Indigenous communities and organizations were held to inform Indigenous place-keeping initiatives. For example, this past September, Minister Cho and I met with Chief Claire Sault of the Mississaugas of the Credit to share the final designs of the Indigenous place-keeping initiatives and the strong engagement that has fed into those designs. Meaningful opportunities for First Nations to participate are vital to constructive dialogue and have included economic reconciliation. Through Infrastructure Ontario’s Indigenous engagement and participation program, nearly $5.5 million in contracts have been awarded to Indigenous-owned businesses on the Ontario Place site servicing work. We will continue to value our relationships and work with First Nations throughout this project to ensure Ontario Place is also an Indigenous place for communities and Indigenous people to gather. I want to thank you for allowing me the time to present on behalf of the Ministry of Tourism, Culture and Gaming, and I also want to thank the Auditor General for her recommendations and report. I am proud of the work our ministry does in serving the hundreds of thousands of Ontarians who work in the tourism sector and our millions of annual visitors. The sector supports more than 320,000 jobs and nearly 93,000 businesses, contributing more than $32 billion to the Ontario economy. Ontario Place represents a unique opportunity to grow this impact even further. Waterfront destinations and experiences provide an outsized impact on our economy, culture and shared heritage. We have internationally recognized tourism destinations in Ontario, like Niagara Falls and Wasaga Beach, and we are looking forward to creating an Ontario Place worthy of the same distinction. The government will continue in its work and its bold new vision with diligence and transparency.
Ms. Nancy Kennedy
We have confidence in our strategy, and we are excited for the path forward as we are building on our momentum, showcasing the very best our province has to offer and demonstrating to the world Ontario is the global destination we know it to be.
The Chair (Mr. Tom Rakocevic)
Thank you very much. This week’s rotations begin with the third party, the official opposition and then government members. Just to let members know, I will be giving you a roughly 10-minute warning and a two-minute warning to help you with your timing for your questions. We will now begin with the third party. MPP Fairclough, you have the floor.
Ms. Lee Fairclough
Thank you for those introductory comments for the discussion today. I’m going to start with—we have seen the reporting on the financial viability of the Therme Group, including the European auditor’s concern that financing issues make its future a significant uncertainty. And it’s clear that that was probably known during the selection process. So, can you just maybe tell us why Therme was chosen when there were issues with their financial viability?
Ms. Nancy Kennedy
Thank you for the question. At the time of the selection process, there was rigorous financial due diligence that was done on all of the proposals. I’d like to turn it over to my colleague from Infrastructure Ontario to talk a bit about the process at the time and to answer questions that you might have about that particular process.
Ms. Angela Clayton
Thank you for the question. Two things I would offer: Consistent with best practices, the call for development required participants not only to provide their experience on similar projects but also to identify all of their team members. Our review focused on both the qualitative strength of the member’s team that they put forward as well as the formal ownership. Prior to entering into the lease agreement with Therme, we did our due diligence to ensure that the key members of the team had a proven track record in delivering successful projects in line with what they had proposed at Ontario Place. Additionally, a financial review was undertaken. As part of this review, an analysis of the audited financial statements demonstrated that Therme met the financial net worth test that was required. This test was informed by advice by IO’s independent third-party real estate and financial adviser, E&Y, on an appropriate test of financial substance to enter into a deal of this structure. The lease includes a provision, and is ongoing, that Therme has to maintain a net worth of at least $100 million or would be in default of a term of the lease agreement. This is in section 16.8 of the publicly available lease.
Ms. Lee Fairclough
I want to maybe turn my questioning then to how we arrived at Therme in the first place in the selection process. Because it’s my understanding they didn’t necessarily have the strongest proposal in that process and there were some concerns at that time with the financial viability. In the selection process itself, we see that there was a single process that was used. Now you’re saying that there will be a realty development solicitation policy that will be used for a staged approach going forward for these types of procurements. Can you talk a little bit about why you chose to go that route? Why not use things like RFQs, RFPs? There’s a table—I think it was figure 5—that showed what had been done at other big waterfront projects. I think for me, I’m just really trying to understand why this process was selected for this particular decision.
Ms. Nancy Kennedy
At the time, I think with the process, it was designed to ensure flexibility, and it took under consideration best practices for different sorts of procurement practices. I’ll turn it to Angela to provide a bit more detail about that. But flexibility was the key objective.
Ms. Angela Clayton
Just to echo that, the process we designed was meant to be flexible but also infused with some of the best practices from our formal procurements—as you mentioned, our RFQ, RFP process—but allow for the comparison of very different types of submissions. We agree with the Auditor General’s findings that the outcome of the call-for-development process would not have been materially different if these procedures had not been followed, but we also are implementing the recommendations that they have put forward. Once all the assessments were complete—and that was a summary of the 34 submissions that we received and evaluated, including a review of how each submission performed against the primary assessment of criteria that were prescribed as part of the process—ultimately, we made the recommendation, and government made the decision in terms of moving forward with Therme. With regard to the recommendation for a realty development solicitation policy, we did accept and adopt that recommendation from the Auditor General. In 2024, we brought a policy forward to our board which was approved, and this policy imposes a best practice for competitive solicitations and is being applied to all future solicitations.
Ms. Lee Fairclough
I do want to ask a little bit about the process you did use in this case with Triple Five. As I understand from the reports, they were the only proponent that was offered more time, and also interacted with a senior member of the organization managing the process—to provide advice on what additional information was needed. What I’m accustomed to in these kinds of processes is that anybody involved in the competitive process is aware of what is being offered to other proponents. So I really want to dig in on this point, because it seems that the initial submission wasn’t sufficient, and I’m just trying to understand how we arrived at a decision to allow for more time and allow for that interaction directly with a senior member—when others submitting were not.
Ms. Angela Clayton
I would say that during the call-for-development process, actually, multiple participants requested additional time to complete their submissions. This is a common occurrence in such processes—where extensions are requested. As the call-for-development process required participants to prepare comprehensive concepts, an extension of three weeks was granted to all participants, not just Triple Five. Most participants who submitted responses to the call for development did use this three-week extension and submitted their proposals after September 3. The timeline extension was granted in the interests of maximizing participation, following the multiple requests from a number of the different bidders. With regard to Triple Five, I would say Triple Five is a well-known developer with world-class projects across Canada and beyond. They have a strong and demonstrated track record delivering projects that aligned well with the criteria for the call for development process. Within the criteria communicated between government and the call-for-development participants, they were permitted to communicate through a designated email address, and that was specified in the documents. In fact, at least 18 of the participants used that form of communication to go back and forth. To complete a comprehensive review of the submissions, government may need to complete additional due diligence on submissions, so it’s not uncommon for us to ask for clarification after a submission is received. The government may choose to contact participants as part of this due diligence or undertake its own due diligence as part of the submission.
Ms. Lee Fairclough
Maybe I’ve got my facts incorrect. I thought you said that all were given three weeks—everybody that would submit, three weeks additional. But this particular proponent was actually given longer than three weeks to resubmit information. Is that accurate?
Ms. Angela Clayton
All of the submissions were submitted by the deadline. There was a clarification that was requested from Triple Five after that submission, that allowed them to provide addition information.
Ms. Lee Fairclough
And all the other proponents were made aware that that was happening for that organization?
Ms. Angela Clayton
I’m not able to speak to what the proponents were made aware of at that time. I’m happy to call on one of my colleagues to answer that question.
Ms. Lee Fairclough
It’s okay. We can keep moving on. I do just want to talk a little bit more about the call for development document, because it noted that there would be “no communication with government staff or appointed officials … permitted during the call for the development process.” How will this realty development solicitation process ensure similar guidelines are used in the future?
Ms. Angela Clayton
I will at this point ask my colleague Heather Grey-Wolf to join us. She’s our chief investment officer with Infrastructure Ontario.
The Clerk of the Committee (Ms. Thushitha Kobikrishna)
Very quickly, I’m just going to have you affirm. Heather Grey-Wolf, do you solemnly affirm that the evidence you shall give to this committee touching the subject of the present inquiry shall be the truth, the whole truth and nothing but the truth?
Ms. Lee Fairclough
Sure. The call for development document noted that “no communication with government staff or appointed officials is permitted during the call for development process.” I just wondered, your new process, the realty development solicitation policy, how will it ensure similar guidelines are followed in future solicitations? It’s part of our role to give recommendations around process, so I’m just curious about how this will ensure this in the future.
Ms. Heather Grey-Wolf
Thanks, and I appreciate the question. I’d like to thank the Auditor General of Ontario for their review of the call for development process. As an organization, Infrastructure Ontario is an implementing agency of the government and committed to continuous improvement in our processes and procedures, with the goal of delivering the best value for taxpayers. As a result of the audit process, our board of directors approved the realty development solicitation process in 2024. Through that process, we started to implement a lot of the recommendations that came forward through the audit, including a prohibition of any contact outside the formal channels outlined in the solicitation processes with Infrastructure Ontario staff.
Ms. Lee Fairclough
Great. Thank you. I’m going to just switch gears a little bit and just talk about the presentation of the information to Treasury Board. I guess my very first question is, why was Triple Five brought forward as the master developer when they ultimately scored the lowest score? I think that that was the recommended proponent that was brought forward to Treasury Board, so can you explain what happened to get to that decision to present them?
Ms. Lee Fairclough
They were presented as the preferred option, but my understanding from the report is that they were actually one of the lowest scores. So how is it that they came to be presented to the Treasury Board? I want to talk a little bit about that process itself.
Ms. Angela Clayton
Okay. At this point—apologies—I am going to call on another one of my colleagues, Michael Lindsay, to join us, if I may
The Clerk of the Committee (Ms. Thushitha Kobikrishna)
Michael Lindsay, do you solemnly affirm that the evidence you shall give to this committee touching the subject of the present inquiry shall be the truth, the whole truth and nothing but the truth?
Mr. Michael Lindsay
I do. The answer to your question is that when we made recommendations to Treasury Board, we never recommended, as Infrastructure Ontario, the wisdom of a single party doing a comprehensive development of the entire island. We always suggested that the right path was a multi-partner approach, which was what led us to the shortlist that then government endorsed. The document in question says that if the government did not accept that recommendation or couldn’t come to terms with the parties that we were recommending shortlisting for a multi-partner site, there were viable single-party partners that you could go back to and have a conversation with about an integrated development for the island. Triple Five was one of five parties that we ultimately listed in that respect.
Ms. Lee Fairclough
I see. When the information was presented to them, it was won because it was done in this sort of piecemeal way, and they were just a different kind of proponent than the other four? Just so I’m clear.
Mr. Michael Lindsay
Because it wasn’t the recommendation of Infrastructure Ontario to have a single partner for the entirety of the island, we were pointing at five of the proponents that had come forward, as my colleague Angela has said, that we knew had a track record of development elsewhere in the world, that could be partners the government would go back to, to have a conversation with if for whatever reason they did not want to do a multi-partner site, or if for whatever reason they couldn’t come to terms with any of the shortlisted parties that we were recommending. So it all portended more conversation, more elucidation of any one of those five parties, if ultimately that would have been the government’s direction.
Ms. Lee Fairclough
Maybe this is a good time to ask then about the criteria that they were all assessed on, because there were some comments about whether those criteria were clear from the beginning. Were all of those that submitted aware that there was this preference, that they would only be considered if the government then directed to go to a single?
Mr. Michael Lindsay
Part of the reason we used a call-for-development real-estate-solicitation approach was precisely because we wanted to get a bunch of different types of proposals for Ontario Place. We were creating, by design, something that would allow us to compare oranges to apples, a little bit, in respect to ranking. It’s worth noting that other real estate proposals that have happened, whether Quayside or the city of Hamilton with Pier 8, have had similar language in their actual documents that specifies—the giveaway phrase is, “This is not a contract A/contract B procurement,” giving flexibility to evaluators. Everybody knew what the government’s four objectives were, publicly stated at the start of this call-for-development process, and we made them aware of the evaluation criteria. We did not draw a distinction in the evaluation for anybody at the time who received information as between a preference for a multi-partner or single-integrated-partner site. That came after our recommendation.
Ms. Lee Fairclough
Oh, it came after the recommendation. So it wasn’t clear up front when people were putting the bid in that that it might carry more weight to be a single versus multi.
Mr. Michael Lindsay
It was very clear to everybody that we were trying to get a wide set of development proposals for Ontario Place and that we had four criteria that every proposal was being evaluated against consistently.
Ms. Lee Fairclough
Okay. Let me just look here for my next question. I do want to come back then to the Treasury Board submission process because that was the next part of this. The response around what was presented to Treasury Board was more training—more training about what should be taken forward to inform those decisions. I guess I just needed to ask, aren’t most of our MOI staff that completed some of the Treasury Board submissions for Ontario Place—wouldn’t they already have been trained in that process? Do we think it was a training issue for what was being presented to the government to make those decisions?
Mr. Ali Veshkini
Ali Veshkini, Deputy Minister of Infrastructure. Training is one component of it, absolutely. We accept and thank the Auditor General for her recommendations. There are a few things in her recommendations beyond just training. The first was with respect to working with our partners, whether it be Infrastructure Ontario or other agencies, to have some more fulsome, when available, business cases. However, this was done in stages, as Michael Lindsay has alluded to, and we wanted a wide spectrum—but as much as possible, having more information, maybe having less of a spectrum in the future. So we took that recommendation and accepted it as well. The second was really looking at the process and the criteria, which Angela Clayton just spoke about. That’s kind of the second component. The third component is obviously training as well, because this was new in terms of how to do the call for development. So it’s not that the staff don’t understand in terms of the Treasury Board process, but when you’re doing things that are novel, not routine-based Treasury Board submissions, making sure we’re training with respect to the criteria, the process, how to look at things, the due diligence and also the intake of information as well. It’s not that they didn’t, it’s more that this was just new, so we wanted to make sure in the future, whether it was MOI or if we can help any other ministry—to ensure that that’s robust moving in the future. But we accepted all the recommendations of the Auditor General.
Ms. Lee Fairclough
And it will include the kind of cost-benefit information for—yes. Thank you.
Ms. Nancy Kennedy
If I can just add to Ali’s remarks, Deputy Veshkini’s remarks, we work very closely with his ministry on constructing business cases. It’s something that, with our own staff at tourism, culture and gaming, we’ve made an effort to be much stronger at, at the ministry level. While Infrastructure Ontario might inherently have that skill set within their staff, it’s something that we’re deepening within the ministry. I feel at this point that our business case and our economic analysis is much stronger than it would have been at that particular time. We put real emphasis at the ministry, and it’s a priority for me in particular.
Ms. Lee Fairclough
Oh, two minutes. Okay. I did want to ask a question about the provisions in the agreement with Therme, particularly in the event that their facility is no longer commercially viable through low attendance once open, lower-than-expected profits or losses, or, prior to opening, the company or the facility deeming that it’s no longer viable. If the agreement is cancelled, what happens with Therme? Can they walk away? Will Therme assign that lease to another entity? And what are our protections for the government in that circumstance, given that people have a lot of concerns around the financial viability of this organization?
Ms. Nancy Kennedy
I’ll turn it over to Infrastructure Ontario, but there are penalties in the lease if there is transgression. I’ll let them go through what those are.
Ms. Lee Fairclough
Yes. Maybe when we do, can you highlight what the risk is for the province and the government in those situations?
Ms. Heather Grey-Wolf
Absolutely. As we went through the lengthy lease negotiation process with Therme, Infrastructure Ontario had, first and foremost, protecting the interests of the government as a key outcome of the negotiation, delivering value for the taxpayer. One of the considerations was what to do in the event if Therme should decide to cease operations and what the conclusion would be. I don’t have the provisions at my fingertips today, but there are—
The Chair (Mr. Tom Rakocevic)
We’re out of time. We now move to the official opposition. Who will be beginning? MPP Glover, you have the floor.
Mr. Chris Glover
Actually, I’ll ask a question about that. In the terms of the lease, it says that if Therme ceases operations or declares bankruptcy, they could sell the property to a third party for 50% and keep the money, and then the Ontario government would have to sue them. Is that not accurate? We would have to sue Therme for—
Ms. Heather Grey-Wolf
Therme, as part of the lease provision and their vision at Ontario Place, is making a significant capital investment in the lands at Ontario Place. Were they to choose to cease operations, they’re able to, under the terms of the lease and with the co-operation of government, seek a partner to take over this facility. So we would have a water park facility at Ontario Place, and they would be looking for an operator to take over that facility so that all of Ontario could enjoy the continued operation of such a facility at Ontario Place, which aligns with the government vision to activate the area.
Mr. Chris Glover
Okay. If they go bankrupt, according to the terms of the lease, and they cease operations, the Ontario government—so, us—would be responsible for 50% of the value of the lease. Now, 50% of the value of the lease: Is that on a fair market value of a 95-year lease on public parkland, or is that based on the assessment of—say they built half the spa; we’re responsible for giving them 50% of the cost of half the spa that they built, which would be 25%. What does 50% of the value of the lease mean?
Ms. Heather Grey-Wolf
It would be the value of both the facility, which we could then take control of and lease out to another party, as well as the business.
Mr. Chris Glover
Okay. But if they build half a spa and they go bankrupt—they don’t have the money to complete the spa—then we have to pay them for 25% of the cost of the spa. So, we have to pay them for half of what they built. But if it’s not a viable business operation, then we are paying them for something that’s of no use to the people of Ontario. Is that not a substantial risk for the people of Ontario?
Ms. Heather Grey-Wolf
In our opinion, it is a viable business, and that was part of the evaluation process, as well as—Therme invests $500 million on the site. Those assets in that situation that you’re outlining become assets of the province. So they will be making significant improvements at Ontario Place to our benefit.
Mr. Chris Glover
The Auditor General has said there is no actual requirement in this lease with Therme for them to invest any specific amount into the project. There is with the contract with Live Nation but not with Therme. Is that accurate?
Mr. Chris Glover
Okay. I’ve got a couple of quick questions. Let me just ask these ones. Would one of you be able to provide this committee with copies of the emails mentioned on page 77 of the Auditor General’s report, one in which a senior IO adviser pointed out that Therme group “had low liquidity and it was not cash flow positive,” and the other email from IO that Therme had met the $100-million financial test to be eligible for the lease of Ontario Place? Are you able to provide those emails to the committee? I mean, not today, but—
Mr. Chris Glover
Right. Can you provide them to us at the committee? The Auditor General, under the terms of her work, is not able to release them to us. Can you release them to us?
Ms. Heather Grey-Wolf
I’m not able to answer that question, but I might ask my legal counsel.
Mr. Chris Glover
You’ll take the request and report back to the committee. Is that correct?
Mr. Chris Glover
Okay. Thank you. Let’s see. Was Infrastructure Ontario aware that Therme’s claim of having $100 million to meet the financial test was based on projected revenues from an unbuilt spa in Germany? It’s a yes-or-no question.
Mr. Chris Glover
Was Infrastructure Ontario aware that Therme’s claim of having $100 million to meet the financial requirements for this project—that that $100 million was based on projected revenues from an unbuilt spa in Germany?
Ms. Angela Clayton
The $100 million was based on audited financial statements. That was what the basis of the assessment was.
Mr. Chris Glover
Right. Okay. Were you aware that those audited financial statements were based on projected revenues from an unbuilt spa in Germany?
Ms. Angela Clayton
It would have been based on the team that the Therme Group included in their submission, which included a number of different members. We would have looked at the composition of the team and the audited financial statements, and that would have been the basis for the evaluation.
Mr. Chris Glover
I’m still not clear. Were you aware that the $100 million is actually from projected revenues from an unbuilt spa?
Ms. Angela Clayton
If that’s what was included in their audited financial statements, that would have been the basis of our evaluation.
Ms. Nancy Kennedy
We used the audited financial statements, so that’s the basis of the evaluation.
Mr. Chris Glover
Okay. And then the other thing that Therme did is they said that they owned and were operating six spas in Europe when they actually only owned one. There’s this proof of concept. IO approved them as saying they have a proof of concept, they will be able to run this thing based on the six spas they’re running in Europe. Was IO aware that they actually only owned and operated one of those six spas?
Ms. Angela Clayton
Again, the team that Therme put forward in their response included several members, and these individuals had extensive experience in construction and operation of the spas across Europe, which included similar projects.
Mr. Chris Glover
But they don’t actually own or operate those, so whoever’s on the team didn’t actually own and operate five of the spas that they’re claiming credit for.
Ms. Heather Grey-Wolf
I would suggest that that’s not the case. The call for development process allowed for a range of partnering approaches, giving the teams opportunity to include a required diversity of expertise and experience. The Therme Group proposal included members of Therme Group as well as Therme Wund and allied heat exchange, in addition to several other Canadian and international firms. These team members collectively had the experience in delivering and operating the example projects provided by the proposal, including ownership of the spas outlined in the proposal.
Mr. Chris Glover
But they were not the same company. The contract that IO signed is with Therme Canada and these other entities were not part of that, so they have no legal obligation to the people of Ontario. Why would IO include them as a proof of concept if they don’t have a legal obligation or a legal connection to Therme Canada?