One-time $28M relief to L.P.'s trust

Summary#

S-16, “Relief of L.P. by the Department of Children and Families,” would create a one-time law for this claim; it does not amend a general law. Its stated goal is to compensate L.P. for injuries and damages the bill attributes to negligence by Department of Children and Families (DCF) employees and caseworkers.

  • The bill declares the facts in its preamble true. The preamble says a jury found DCF negligent and awarded L.P. $28 million, and that an appeal affirmed the judgment.
  • It appropriates $28 million from Florida’s General Revenue Fund to DCF for L.P.’s relief.
  • It directs the state Chief Financial Officer to issue a $28 million warrant payable to a special needs trust for L.P.’s exclusive use and benefit.
  • The $28 million award, together with the $200,000 the bill says DCF has already paid under state law, is intended to be the sole compensation for all present and future claims arising from these events.
  • Attorney fees, lobbying fees, and similar expenses tied to the claim may not exceed 25% of the $28 million award.

What it means for you#

  • L.P.: If the bill becomes law, the trust would receive the $28 million payment for L.P.’s benefit. The bill would make that payment, together with the prior $200,000 payment, the sole compensation for the covered claims.
  • DCF and the Chief Financial Officer: DCF would receive the appropriation, and the Chief Financial Officer must issue the warrant to the trust.
  • Taxpayers: The bill would direct $28 million in public funds to this individual claim. It does not change DCF’s general duties or create a new compensation program for other people.
  • General public: The bill is filed and introduced, not yet law. Its payment would begin only if it becomes law.

Money#

The bill appropriates $28 million from the General Revenue Fund; no estimate of other costs is provided.

  • The bill says DCF has already paid $200,000 under existing law. That amount is separate from the $28 million appropriation.
  • Combined attorney, lobbying, and similar fees related to the claim may not exceed 25% of the award—$7 million.
  • The bill does not state how much of the fee limit would be used or whether there would be additional costs to administer the trust.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not explain who would create or administer the special needs trust, or what rules would govern its payments.
  • It does not set out how the $28 million would be distributed or managed for L.P.
  • The bill describes the prior $200,000 payment as made under a statutory limit, but the current text of that law was not supplied, so that limit could not be checked here.
  • The bill does not explain how the fee cap would be monitored or enforced.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to provide compensation for severe injuries and continuing needs that the preamble says resulted from DCF employees’ negligence.
  • A payment to a trust for L.P.’s exclusive benefit could direct the money toward her needs.
  • The bill describes a jury award and an affirmed judgment, while also stating that the amount previously paid under existing law was $200,000.
  • A single payment and a defined fee limit make the amount of this relief and the maximum fees clear.

Case against#

  • One concern is the size of the payment: the bill would direct $28 million in General Revenue to one claim.
  • The bill makes the award, along with the prior payment, the sole compensation for present and future claims arising from these events. It does not provide additional compensation under this bill if future needs exceed the award.
  • The bill does not explain how the trust will be overseen or how decisions about using its funds will be made.