Summary#
The bill is titled Relief of H.H. by the Department of Children and Families. It would make a one-time payment from Florida’s General Revenue Fund to compensate H.H. for injuries the bill says resulted from the Department of Children and Families’ negligence; it does not amend the child-welfare law. Its stated goal is to provide compensation for H.H.’s injuries and damages.
- The bill would appropriate $14,926,639.56 to the department and direct the Chief Financial Officer to pay that amount to an irrevocable trust for H.H.’s exclusive use and benefit.
- The bill says the state intends to waive and pay government liens, including Medicaid liens, related to H.H.’s treatment and care.
- The bill intends the previous payment of $200,000 and this award to be the sole compensation for all present and future claims arising from the events described.
- Attorney fees for the claim could not exceed 25% of the amount awarded under this bill.
- The bill is filed and introduced, not law. It would take effect if it becomes law.
What it means for you#
- H.H. and her trust: The trust would receive the bill’s specified payment if the bill becomes law. The bill’s preamble describes H.H.’s injuries and ongoing care needs; the payment is intended as compensation for claims arising from the events it describes.
- H.H.’s attorneys: Their fees for the claim would be capped at 25% of the amount awarded under this bill. The bill does not set a separate cap for other costs.
- Taxpayers: The appropriation would use state General Revenue Fund money.
- The Department of Children and Families: It would receive the appropriation and the payment would be made from department funds in the State Treasury. The bill does not change the department’s ongoing child-protection duties or create a new service.
Money#
The bill specifies a state appropriation of $14,926,639.56; no broader cost estimate is provided.
- The bill’s preamble says $200,000 was already paid under the existing sovereign-immunity limit, and that the specified amount is the unpaid balance and awarded costs. The $200,000 is not part of the new appropriation.
- The bill also says the state is to waive and pay related government liens, including Medicaid liens, but gives no amount for them.
- The bill refers to interest in describing the unpaid amount, but the appropriation itself specifies a fixed sum and does not state an additional interest amount.
- No publicly available information in the supplied material estimates the cost of paying the liens or administering the trust.
What is unclear#
- The bill does not set out the trust’s terms, who would manage it, or when the payment would be made.
- It says the state intends liens to be waived and paid, but does not explain how that would happen or how much the liens are.
- The bill does not explain how its “sole compensation” provision would be carried out for present and future claims.
- No publicly available information in the supplied material gives a fiscal estimate beyond the specified appropriation or explains whether the bill has enough support to pass.
Case for#
- The bill appears intended to address a jury award that exceeded the amount the department had paid under the sovereign-immunity limit described in the bill.
- The bill’s preamble says the jury found that the department’s failure to complete a thorough investigation was a cause of H.H.’s catastrophic injuries. A one-time payment could provide compensation without changing the child-protection system’s rules.
- Paying the award into an irrevocable trust for H.H.’s exclusive benefit could direct the money toward her needs.
- The attorney-fee cap could limit how much of the award goes to legal fees.
Case against#
- The payment would use public funds, while the bill gives no estimate for the additional cost of paying government liens.
- The bill does not explain the trust’s management or how the money would be used over H.H.’s lifetime.
- The bill intends the award to be the sole compensation for all present and future claims tied to the events described. That could limit later compensation, even though the bill describes continuing care needs.
- The bill provides relief for one person but does not change investigation rules or create new protections for other children.