Summary#
“Relief of Maury Hernandez by the Department of Corrections” is a bill for a one-time payment to a former Broward County sheriff’s deputy. It does not amend general probation laws; it would appropriate $5 million from the General Revenue Fund to the Department of Corrections (DOC) for Hernandez, with payment by the Chief Financial Officer. Its stated goal is to compensate him for injuries and damages the bill links to DOC’s failure to enforce probation rules.
- The bill declares the facts in its preamble true and says Hernandez should receive legislative relief.
- The Chief Financial Officer must issue Hernandez a $5 million payment from DOC funds in the State Treasury if the bill becomes law.
- The bill states the Legislature intends for state liens related to his treatment and care to be waived.
- The award is intended to be the sole compensation for present and future claims arising from the events described. Attorney fees for the claim cannot exceed 25% of the award.
- The bill does not change probation rules or create a general compensation program. It is filed and introduced, so it is not law yet.
What it means for you#
- Maury Hernandez: If the bill becomes law, he would receive the $5 million award, subject to the attorney-fee limit and the bill’s statement that the award is sole compensation for claims arising from these events.
- Department of Corrections and Chief Financial Officer: DOC would receive the appropriation, and the Chief Financial Officer must issue the payment from State Treasury funds.
- State lien holders: The bill expresses legislative intent that state liens arising from Hernandez’s treatment and care be waived. It does not identify the liens or set out how the waiver would be carried out.
- Taxpayers: The bill would use $5 million in public funds. It would not directly change taxes, probation supervision, or services for the public.
Money#
The bill requires a $5 million appropriation from the General Revenue Fund; no estimate of other costs is provided.
- Attorney fees related to the claim are capped at 25% of the award, or $1.25 million. The bill does not say what fee will actually be charged or how much Hernandez would receive after fees.
- The preamble estimates Hernandez’s economic damages at about $6.73 million, including future care and lost earnings. The $5 million award is less than that estimate.
- The bill calls for state liens related to his care to be waived, but gives no amount for those liens or estimate of the effect.
- No publicly available information on other costs.
What is unclear#
- The bill is at the introduced stage; whether it will pass is uncertain.
- It does not specify how the intended waiver of state liens would be implemented or identify which state liens are covered.
- The preamble says a workers’ compensation insurer has a lien, but the bill’s waiver language refers to liens held by the state. It does not say what happens to the insurer’s lien.
- The bill does not explain how the $5 million award relates to non-economic damages, such as pain and suffering, beyond saying it is intended as sole compensation for the claims described.
- The preamble says a court dismissed Hernandez’s lawsuit because DOC owed him no specific legal duty. The bill does not set out a new process for deciding or reviewing similar claims.
Case for#
- The bill’s preamble says probation officers did not report repeated violations, including illegal firearm possession, and cites findings that reporting them could have led to Maldonado being jailed before the shooting.
- It describes severe, permanent injuries and says Hernandez has no legal or administrative remedy after his lawsuit was dismissed.
- A possible argument for a legislative payment is that it provides compensation in an individual case where the bill says the ordinary court process did not provide a remedy.
Case against#
- The bill would pay $5 million from public funds even though the preamble estimates economic damages alone at about $6.73 million; the bill does not explain how that amount was set.
- The Legislature declares the preamble’s facts true, but the bill does not establish a separate fact-finding or review process before payment.
- The bill’s lien language states an intent to waive state liens but does not clearly explain how that would work or address the insurer’s lien.