Barnett compensation from DCF

Summary#

The Relief of Michael Barnett by the Department of Children and Families is a proposed Florida law for a specific claim, not a bill changing the general rules for child protection. It would appropriate $296,400 from the General Revenue Fund and direct payment to Michael Barnett and R.B.; its stated purpose is to compensate them for injuries and damages linked to the department’s negligence. It does not amend an existing Act.

  • The bill declares the facts in its preamble true, including its account that the department failed to act on warning signs before the 2010 shootings.
  • It directs the Chief Financial Officer to issue a warrant for $296,400 to Barnett and R.B.
  • The bill says payments under Florida law and this act are intended to be the sole compensation for present and future claims arising from the events.
  • Attorney fees related to the claim may not exceed 25% of the amount awarded under the act.
  • The bill is introduced and is not law. Passage is uncertain.

What it means for you#

  • Michael Barnett and R.B.: If enacted, they would receive the $296,400 payment. The bill does not say how the amount would be divided between them.
  • Florida taxpayers: The money would come from the General Revenue Fund, through the Department of Children and Families.
  • People using child-protection services: The bill does not create a new service or change general department duties, investigations, or procedures.

Money#

The bill would authorize a $296,400 public payment, but the available material gives no estimate of other costs.

  • It directs the Chief Financial Officer to pay the amount from funds of the Department of Children and Families in the State Treasury.
  • The bill’s preamble says Barnett and R.B. agreed to accept $160,000, including attorney fees and costs, and that a consent judgment was entered for $296,400. The bill does not explain how those amounts relate to the new payment.
  • Attorney fees related to the claim are capped at 25% of the $296,400 award. The bill does not state a separate cap on costs.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not explain whether, or how, the $160,000 described in its preamble has been paid or is accounted for in the $296,400 payment.
  • It does not specify how the payment would be divided between Barnett and R.B.
  • It refers to payments under Florida law but does not explain how those payments interact with the award. The text of that law was not supplied, so the interaction cannot be checked here.
  • The bill would take effect when it becomes law, but it does not give a payment deadline.

Case for#

  • The bill’s account describes repeated warnings of domestic violence and says the department closed its investigation without finding the children at significant risk. It also says a regional director acknowledged the department should have done more.
  • The bill describes a consent judgment for $296,400. A possible argument for the payment is that it provides compensation for a specific claim the state has agreed to settle.
  • The fee limit and the statement that the payments are the sole compensation for the claims put limits on the payment and related claims.

Case against#

  • One concern is that the bill commits $296,400 in public funds without explaining the relationship between that amount and the $160,000 settlement described in its preamble.
  • The bill provides compensation but does not require changes to department investigations, reviews, or oversight.
  • It does not explain how the award would be divided between the two recipients, or give a deadline for payment.