Communities urged to shape coastal trails

Summary#

HCR-104 is a House concurrent resolution, not a bill that changes state or city law. It urges the Hawaii Department of Transportation and Honolulu’s Department of Transportation Services to work with North Shore community groups to advance coastal trails; its stated goal is to support safer travel by walking, biking, and other non-car modes. The House has passed it, but Senate concurrence is not shown in the available material.

  • If adopted by both chambers, it would ask the two agencies to work closely with North Shore community organizations and involve them in trail planning, design, construction, and maintenance.
  • It does not require the agencies to build trails, create a trail program, or meet a deadline. “Urged” is a request, not a binding duty.
  • It does not create a new right, ban, fee, or enforcement power, and it does not appropriate money.

What it means for you#

  • North Shore community organizations: The resolution asks the agencies to involve them in planning, design, construction, and maintenance. It does not specify which groups qualify or how involvement would work.
  • People who walk, bike, or travel along the North Shore: The resolution does not itself build or fund trails, or change current travel rules. Any trail improvements would depend on later agency action.
  • Residents, visitors, and taxpayers: The resolution makes no direct change to services, taxes, or fees.

Money#

No cost estimate is included; no publicly available information on the cost of any trail work.

  • The resolution does not authorize spending or say how trail work would be funded.

What is unclear#

  • Which community organizations would be involved, and how the agencies would choose or consult them.
  • Which routes or projects count as the “system of coastal trails,” and what “rapidly advance” would mean in practice.
  • What each agency would be responsible for, and whether either agency plans to take action.
  • Whether any trail work would receive funding, and what it would cost.

Case for#

  • The resolution states that some North Shore roads lack separated pathways and that unsafe shoulders discourage walking and biking. A possible argument for the request is that working with community groups could help agencies plan trail improvements around local knowledge.
  • The resolution points to existing trails, Honolulu’s Complete Streets program, the Oahu Vision Zero Action Plan, and the state’s draft Priority Multimodal Network. Coordinating with these efforts could support the resolution’s stated goal of safer travel choices.
  • The resolution identifies traffic congestion as a concern. Better walking and biking routes could be one part of addressing the area’s transportation needs, though the resolution does not promise that result.

Case against#

  • The resolution does not require construction, funding, deadlines, or specific agency steps. It may produce no trail improvements if the agencies do not act.
  • It does not define the trail system, set priorities, or explain how community organizations would take part. That leaves the request open to different interpretations.
  • The resolution gives no cost estimate or funding plan, so the public cannot assess the expense of any work that might follow.