Study universal basic income feasibility

Summary#

HCR-184 is a concurrent resolution, not a law that creates a benefit or amends an Act. It requests the Legislative Reference Bureau (LRB), consulting with the Department of Business, Economic Development, and Tourism, the Department of Human Services, and the University of Hawaiʻi Economic Research Organization, to study whether Hawaiʻi could establish a guaranteed universal basic income program for working families. Its stated goal is to explore ways to support families’ economic security.

  • The LRB is requested to study possible program structures and eligibility rules, costs and funding sources, and possible effects on poverty, economic stability, and workforce participation.
  • The study is also requested to examine lessons from other guaranteed-income pilots and whether Hawaiʻi could run a pilot.
  • The LRB is requested to send findings, recommendations, and any proposed legislation to the Legislature at least 20 days before the 2027 Regular Session.
  • The measure does not establish a basic-income program, authorize payments, or require a pilot. The committee recommended that it be deferred; it has not been adopted.

What it means for you#

  • Working families: This resolution would not give you money or change your eligibility for existing benefits. It requests a study of possible eligibility rules and program options.
  • LRB and the named agencies and research organization: The resolution requests that the LRB conduct the study in consultation with the three named bodies. It does not set out how that consultation must work or require any of them to create a program.
  • Taxpayers: The resolution itself does not set a tax, fee, or payment. It requests an estimate of possible program costs and funding sources.

Money#

No cost information is in the supplied material; no publicly available information about the cost of the requested study is provided.

  • The study is requested to estimate the cost of possible programs and identify possible funding sources.
  • The resolution does not provide a study budget, appropriate money, or authorize basic-income payments.

What is unclear#

  • “Working families” and “guaranteed universal basic income” are not defined. The study is asked to consider eligibility and program structures.
  • The resolution does not specify the study’s methods, whether there would be public input, or how the agencies and research organization would take part.
  • It does not set a budget or identify staff for the study.
  • It is unclear whether the report would lead to proposed legislation or a pilot; the resolution only requests recommendations and says the report may include proposed legislation.

Case for#

  • The resolution describes working families facing high living costs and financial insecurity, and asks for analysis rather than starting a program without first assessing it.
  • A study could put possible eligibility rules, costs, funding sources, and effects in one report for lawmakers to consider.
  • Reviewing other pilots and the feasibility of a Hawaiʻi pilot could help lawmakers assess whether the idea fits Hawaiʻi’s conditions.

Case against#

  • A study would not provide immediate financial help to families facing high costs.
  • The resolution does not provide study funding or specify the methods and evidence the LRB should use, which may leave the scope and cost unclear.
  • “Universal” may suggest broad coverage, while the study is specifically about “working families”; the resolution does not explain how those terms would fit together.