Study federal housing allowances impact on rents

Summary#

SCR-157 is a Senate concurrent resolution, not a bill that changes state law. It asks the Department of Business, Economic Development, and Tourism (DBEDT), working with the University of Hawaiʻi Economic Research Organization (UHERO) and other appropriate stakeholders, to study federal housing allowances and Hawaiʻi’s rental market. Its stated goal is to give lawmakers a more balanced picture of possible effects and economic benefits.

  • The requested study would examine how allowance rates relate to rents by island and county, whether rents cluster near allowance levels, and how allowances may affect landlord pricing.
  • It would compare rent growth in areas with many military households to comparable areas with fewer, and examine possible displacement of local working families.
  • It would consider policy options to address possible market distortions while respecting federal authority and state-federal relations.
  • It would also assess economic benefits, including payments to landlords, property-tax revenues, and related activity, and quantify the overall economic impact.
  • DBEDT is asked to report findings and recommendations to the Legislature at least 20 days before the 2027 regular session. The resolution is introduced and referred to committees; passage is uncertain.

What it means for you#

  • Renters, landlords, and the public: The resolution would not change rents, housing allowances, landlord rules, or eligibility for housing assistance. It requests a study; it does not require anyone to apply, provide information, or take part.
  • DBEDT and UHERO: DBEDT is asked to conduct the study with UHERO and other appropriate stakeholders. The text does not specify how the work or stakeholder involvement would be organized.
  • Lawmakers: They would receive the requested report before the 2027 regular session if the resolution is adopted and the study is completed.

Money#

No cost estimate is provided in the available material.

  • The resolution requests staff and research work but does not state a budget, funding source, or staffing level.
  • It asks the study to estimate the economic impact of federal housing expenditures, including benefits such as landlord income, property-tax revenues, and related economic activity. That estimate is not itself a state appropriation or payment.

What is unclear#

  • The resolution does not set out the study’s methods, data sources, or how it would separate the effect of housing allowances from other influences on rents.
  • It does not define “distortion effects” or specify how the study should measure displacement.
  • It does not say what funding or staff DBEDT and UHERO would use, or how other stakeholders would be selected or involved.
  • It asks for policy options but does not say what authority the state could use to carry them out.
  • The resolution’s statements about housing costs and military households provide its rationale; the requested study would examine the claimed effects, which the text does not establish as proven.

Case for#

  • The resolution appears intended to fill a stated research gap: examining whether federal housing allowances affect rents, landlord pricing, or housing access for non-military residents.
  • Looking at different islands, counties, and areas near military installations could show whether effects vary across local markets.
  • Including economic benefits as well as possible costs could give lawmakers a fuller picture before considering policy options.

Case against#

  • A study alone would not change housing affordability or provide immediate help to renters.
  • The resolution does not specify methods for distinguishing the effect of allowances from other causes of rent changes, so the results may not answer the key question clearly.
  • It asks for a wide-ranging study but provides no cost, staffing plan, or data-access plan.
  • The study may identify possible policy options without resolving what the state can do, given the resolution’s instruction to respect federal authority.