Tax exemptions phased out to fund replacement payments

Summary#

HCR 5034 proposes a constitutional amendment; it does not create a working program unless the Legislature approves it and Kansas voters approve it. The amendment would create a protected Freedom from Taxes Fund and a temporary review board, with the goal of using interest from the fund to phase out certain taxes. The supplied status lists the resolution as introduced; it does not establish that it became law or was approved by voters.

  • The Kansas Citizens Freedom Review Board must review existing state tax exemptions and approve or eliminate each one, in whole or in part. The Legislature would set the board’s composition and appointment rules.
  • Money identified as collected because state tax exemptions end would go into the fund. The fund’s principal could not be spent or borrowed; only interest earnings could be used for the tax-replacement payments described in the amendment.
  • The state treasurer would administer the fund and arrange for a money manager. The amendment sets investment and reserve rules.
  • After the fund reaches specified interest-income thresholds, the treasurer would present a determination to the Legislature. A concurrent resolution is also required before each category of tax is eliminated.
  • In stages, the amendment would eliminate motor-vehicle property taxes and state or local fees for registering or titling motor vehicles; state-mandated and state-imposed property taxes; and state-imposed income and privilege taxes. It does not say that all locally imposed property taxes would end.
  • The amendment would limit tax exemptions to five years unless the Legislature enacts them again. It excludes federal exemptions and certain existing exemptions where ending them would cause multiple sales-tax layers on an item.

What it means for you#

  • Motor-vehicle owners: If the fund reaches the required threshold and the Legislature approves the treasurer’s determination, property taxes and state or local registration and title fees on motor vehicles would end in the next tax year. The amendment does not set a date for reaching that threshold.
  • Property owners: Only state-mandated and state-imposed property taxes are named for elimination. The text does not promise to eliminate all property taxes or specify the effect on each property owner’s bill.
  • Income taxpayers and financial institutions: State income and privilege taxes would be eliminated only after the fund reaches its threshold and the Legislature approves the treasurer’s determination. The amendment does not set a phase-out date.
  • People and businesses using state tax exemptions: The board could approve or eliminate exemptions, in whole or in part. An exemption it approves would expire five years after the board’s final report unless the Legislature renews it. An exemption it eliminates could be enacted again by the Legislature.
  • Local taxing subdivisions: The state would transfer money to the state general fund to replace specified lost tax revenue. The Legislature must provide by law for any distribution to local taxing subdivisions for the motor-vehicle and property-tax changes; the text does not give a distribution formula.
  • Kansas residents generally: The amendment does not guarantee that essential services would continue without cuts. That assurance appears in the proposed ballot statement, not as a requirement in the amendment text.

Money#

The amendment authorizes a tax-replacement fund and requires state treasurer and board functions, but the available material gives no cost estimate.

  • The fund would receive money identified as collected because state tax exemptions are eliminated or expire, and interest earnings.
  • The fund’s principal must remain intact. Interest would support replacement payments, with portions retained in the funds and reserve accounts under the amendment’s rules.
  • The text does not estimate exemption-related revenue, investment returns, staffing or management costs, or the amount and timing of tax revenue that would be replaced.

What is unclear#

  • The text refers in some places to sales and compensating-use-tax exemptions, and elsewhere to state tax exemptions more broadly. It is unclear which exemptions the board would review and which exemption-related receipts would fund the tax replacements.
  • The amendment does not set review criteria, hearing or appeal procedures, or rules for how the board would reach its decisions.
  • The Legislature would set the board’s composition and appointment rules, but those details are not in the resolution.
  • The thresholds depend on projected interest earnings, but the text gives no dollar estimates or timeline for reaching them.
  • The text does not explain how local taxing subdivisions would receive replacement money, or how the state would handle any gap between lost revenue and available interest.
  • The resolution says it would go to voters after legislative approval, but the supplied material does not establish whether that approval or a vote occurred.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the amendment is that it would use revenue from ending tax exemptions to build a dedicated fund, rather than relying only on annual budget decisions, to replace specified taxes over time.
  • Keeping the fund’s principal intact and setting reserve rules could help preserve a continuing source of interest income for tax-replacement payments.
  • The Legislature could restore exemptions the board eliminates, and exemptions would face periodic renewal rather than continuing indefinitely without new action.

Case against#

  • One concern is that ending exemptions could increase taxes for people or businesses that currently benefit from them, while the amendment does not show which exemptions would be removed or the resulting costs.
  • It is unclear how quickly the fund could earn enough interest to replace the named taxes. The amendment provides no estimates or deadline, and the principal could not be used to speed up payments.
  • The amendment gives the board broad power over exemptions without stating its decision criteria or review and appeal process.
  • The limits on property-tax elimination are important: the text names state-mandated and state-imposed taxes, not every local property tax. The ballot statement’s claim about lowering home property taxes is not a guaranteed result in the amendment.