Tax exemptions could end under new fund

Summary#

SCR 1624 proposes a constitutional amendment, not a new operating program under current law. It would amend Article 11 of the Kansas Constitution and add a “freedom from taxes” fund and a temporary Kansas citizens freedom review board. Its stated goal is to use revenue from ending tax exemptions, and investment earnings, to replace revenue from certain taxes over time. The current text of Article 11 was not supplied, so I cannot verify which existing rules the amendment would replace beyond the income-tax wording quoted in the bill.

  • The State Treasurer would administer the fund and its three parts for motor vehicle taxes and fees, specified property taxes, and state income and privilege taxes. The fund’s principal could not be spent or borrowed against; only investment earnings could be used.
  • The board would review existing state tax exemptions and decide which to approve or eliminate, in whole or in part. Its membership and appointment rules would be set by law.
  • Motor vehicle property taxes and state or local fees for registering or titling a vehicle would end only after the Treasurer finds the fund meets the bill’s funding test and the Legislature approves that finding by concurrent resolution.
  • The same kind of funding test and legislative approval would apply before ending state-mandated and state-imposed property taxes, and later state-imposed income and privilege taxes.
  • Exemptions the board approves would expire after five years; exemptions enacted later would also expire after five years unless renewed. The amendment is proposed for the November 2026 ballot, but first needs two-thirds approval in each legislative chamber and then voter approval.

What it means for you#

  • Vehicle owners: If the funding test is met and the Legislature approves, motor vehicle property taxes and state or local fees for registering or titling a vehicle would stop in the next tax year. The bill does not give a date for that to happen.
  • Property owners: The bill targets state-mandated and state-imposed property taxes. It does not clearly promise to end all property taxes, including every locally imposed property tax.
  • Income and privilege taxpayers: Those taxes would end only after a separate funding test and legislative approval. The bill does not set a date.
  • People and businesses using tax exemptions: An exemption the board eliminates could mean tax is due where it was not before. The Legislature could later restore an eliminated exemption, but a new or restored exemption would expire after five years unless renewed.
  • Local taxing subdivisions: The Legislature would have to provide by law for any distribution to local governments to replace revenue lost when the specified taxes end. The bill does not set the distribution method or amount.
  • General public: The board is a temporary constitutional body, not an independent agency with permanent status. It must submit a final report within one year after the law to carry out the amendment takes effect, then dissolve.

Money#

No publicly available information.

  • The bill does not provide a cost or revenue estimate.
  • Revenue identified as coming from eliminated or expired state tax exemptions would go into the fund. The principal would remain protected; only investment earnings could be spent for the specified tax replacements.
  • The Treasurer must contract with a money manager. The bill gives no estimate for that contract, board costs, staffing, or administration.
  • The bill relies on fund earnings for replacement payments and creates reserve funds, but does not show whether those earnings would be enough or when the funding tests would be met.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not define key terms such as “state-mandated” or “state-imposed” property taxes, or explain how the funding tests would be calculated in practice.
  • It leaves the board’s membership, qualifications, and appointment process to a later law. It does not set out procedures for its exemption decisions, public input, or appeals.
  • It does not identify which exemptions would be eliminated, or estimate how much revenue their elimination would raise.
  • It does not explain how replacement money would be divided among local governments.
  • The ballot statement says the amendment would reduce home property taxes, but the operative text specifies state-mandated and state-imposed property taxes; it does not say that all home property taxes would end.
  • The bill is at the introduced stage. It would not amend the Constitution unless it passes both legislative chambers by two-thirds and voters approve it.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to connect the removal of tax exemptions with funding for specified tax reductions, rather than end those taxes immediately without a replacement source.
  • A possible argument for the fund is that protecting its principal and limiting spending to tax replacement could preserve resources for future years.
  • Regular review and five-year expiry rules could give lawmakers chances to reconsider exemptions instead of leaving them in place indefinitely.
  • The staged funding tests and legislative votes could provide checks before each tax category is ended.

Case against#

  • One concern is that eliminating exemptions could raise taxes for people or businesses that rely on them, while the bill does not say which exemptions the board would remove.
  • It is unclear whether investment earnings would be sufficient to replace the specified tax revenue. The bill gives no forecast or fallback if the funding tests are not reached.
  • The fund’s narrow spending rules could limit how the state responds to other budget needs; the bill does not estimate the effect on public services.
  • The board would make decisions affecting tax exemptions, but the amendment leaves its composition and decision process to later laws.