Skill based contests exempt from gambling

Summary#

SB 516 would amend Kansas’s unlawful-gambling statutes, K.S.A. 21-6403 and 21-6404. Its stated goal, as described by its title, is to exempt certain devices and contests from the crime of unlawful gambling. The current versions of those statutes were not supplied, so it is not possible to verify which provisions are new and which restate current law.

  • The bill defines “amusement machines” and allows them to award certain prizes, subject to limits including a $25 wholesale-value cap per play and restrictions on vouchers and redemption.
  • It defines esports competitions and skill-based contests, and excludes them from the definition of a bet if they meet the bill’s conditions.
  • It adds a category of gambling device covering some paid games with outcomes based on skill that can award money or other things of value. It also lists exemptions, including amusement machines and devices used by esports competitors.
  • The crime of gambling remains making a bet, playing or offering a game or contest using a gambling device, or entering or remaining in a gambling place with the stated intent. The bill states that gambling is a class B nonperson misdemeanor.
  • The bill is introduced and has been referred to a Senate committee; it is not law. It would take effect after publication in the statute book if enacted.

What it means for you#

  • Operators of amusement machines: A machine would fit the bill’s definition only if it meets the listed conditions, including having no material element of chance. Certain noncash merchandise prizes or vouchers could be offered, subject to the bill’s value, redemption, and on-site distribution limits. The bill does not by itself authorize a machine that fails those conditions.
  • Esports organizers and competitors: A competition would have to meet the bill’s requirements, including direct competition in the same video game, at the same time and location in view of spectators, with results based solely on player skill. Entry fees must be collected from all participants before the competition, and prize value must be set in advance. Traditional casino games such as poker and roulette are excluded from the definition.
  • People running or entering other contests: A “skill-based contest” must be a live, in-person competition among people or teams, decided by skill, and must not use a gambling device. The bill does not set out an application or approval process for contests.
  • Other gambling businesses and the public: The bill does not say that all skill-based games or contests are exempt. A qualifying paid device that can award money or something of value may still meet the bill’s definition of a gambling device. The bill does not directly change taxes, benefits, or general gambling licensing rules.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill does not appropriate money or provide a cost estimate for enforcement or staffing.
  • It permits entry fees for qualifying esports competitions, subject to the conditions above. It does not set fees charged by government.
  • It allows some amusement-machine prizes, but limits their value and restricts how vouchers and prizes can be redeemed.

What is unclear#

  • Because the current versions of the amended statutes were not supplied, the available material does not show how much of the wording changes current law.
  • The bill does not define “material element of chance,” which matters for deciding whether a machine qualifies as an amusement machine.
  • It does not explain how authorities would determine whether a device or contest meets the definitions, or provide review, appeal, or reporting procedures.
  • The bill does not explain how these definitions interact with other state or local rules.
  • The bill’s passage is uncertain; its stated start date applies only if it becomes law.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to distinguish some entertainment machines and skill-based competitions from gambling under these criminal statutes.
  • Clear conditions for qualifying contests—such as setting prizes in advance and requiring results based solely on skill in esports—could make the exemption more specific.
  • The amusement-machine limits could allow modest merchandise prizes while restricting cash-like redemption and higher-value awards.

Case against#

  • The bill draws distinctions using terms such as “material element of chance” and “skill” without explaining how borderline cases should be decided.
  • A paid device can fall within the gambling-device definition if its outcomes involve any element of skill and it can award money or something of value. That may make the boundary between exempt entertainment and criminal gambling difficult to apply.
  • The bill does not provide procedures for getting a ruling in advance, so operators may have to assess the definitions without guidance in the bill.
  • The available material gives no cost estimate for enforcing the rules or handling disputes about whether a device or contest qualifies.