Dispute boards piloted on road projects

Summary#

SR-169 is an enacted Louisiana Senate resolution directing the Department of Transportation and Development (DOTD) to run a dispute review board pilot for at least two fiscal years, starting July 1, 2026. It does not amend an existing Act; its stated goal is to test whether these boards can help address construction disputes while projects are underway.

  • DOTD must select at least five highway or transportation construction projects in each fiscal year of the pilot and set project-selection criteria.
  • For each selected project, DOTD must include board requirements in the project documents, including a contract mechanism identifying when a board will be used.
  • Each board must have at least three members: one chosen by DOTD, one by the contractor, and a chair chosen by those two. Additional members may be added or removed by mutual agreement.
  • Boards may review specified contract-performance disputes, such as disagreements about payment, extra work, delays, and site conditions. The resolution describes their recommendations as advisory and nonbinding.
  • DOTD must set procedures, appoint a program administrator, and report on progress by March 1, 2027, and results by June 30, 2028.

What it means for you#

  • DOTD: Must run the pilot, maintain a roster of qualified and independent candidates in consultation with industry representatives and other appropriate stakeholders, set procedures, and collect and report program data. It must designate an administrator to maintain the roster, standardize agreements and procedures, coordinate training, and evaluate performance.
  • Contractors on selected projects: Must take part in the board process required by that project’s documents. The process is not described as automatically extending legal or contract deadlines or waiving claim-preservation requirements or other rights.
  • Project parties: Boards may make written recommendations on disputes within their scope. The resolution directs DOTD to establish a process for parties to accept or reject recommendations in writing. It also directs DOTD to consider making board review a required step before formal claims, arbitration, or lawsuits—but does not require DOTD to do so.
  • Taxpayers and the public: The resolution does not directly change taxes, create a public benefit, or guarantee fewer disputes or delays. It requires reports on project types, disputes, costs, and any observed changes in claims or litigation.

Money#

No cost estimate is provided in the supplied material.

  • DOTD must provide staff and expertise for the pilot, including an administrator, but the resolution gives no staffing level or cost.
  • Board-member compensation must be covered by a standard agreement, but the resolution does not say who pays or how much.
  • DOTD must report anticipated costs in its interim report and program costs in its final report.

What is unclear#

  • The resolution does not define which projects are “appropriate” or set specific thresholds for project value, complexity, risk, or duration.
  • It does not specify how candidates qualify, how conflicts of interest are assessed, or how board-member compensation is set.
  • It leaves the details of board procedures to DOTD. No publicly available information in the supplied material describes the procedures DOTD will adopt.
  • The resolution does not say whether board review will become a required step before formal claims, arbitration, or litigation; it only directs DOTD to consider that option.
  • It does not specify how pilot costs will be funded or how costs will be divided between DOTD and contractors.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the pilot is that addressing disagreements during construction may help parties use current records, staff, and site information when considering a dispute.
  • A board with members chosen by both DOTD and the contractor, plus a mutually selected chair, could offer project-specific recommendations without replacing the parties’ contract rights.
  • Testing the process on multiple projects and reporting results could give the state evidence about costs, timeliness, and any observed change in claims or litigation.

Case against#

  • The resolution requires DOTD to run the pilot but leaves important choices—such as which projects qualify and how the process works—to the department.
  • Recommendations are nonbinding, and the resolution does not require board review before parties pursue formal claims, arbitration, or litigation. The process may therefore add work without resolving disputes.
  • The resolution does not set a budget or say who pays board members, so the cost to DOTD and contractors is uncertain.
  • Board review does not automatically extend legal or contract deadlines or preserve claims. Parties may need to protect those rights while the board process is underway.