Environmental appeals clarified for licensing decisions

Summary#

LD 2210, “An Act to Clarify Board of Environmental Protection Procedures Regarding Appeals of Licensing or Permitting Decisions of the Commissioner of Environmental Protection,” is an enacted law amending Maine’s environmental statutes. Its stated goal is to clarify how the Board of Environmental Protection handles appeals of the commissioner’s licensing and permitting decisions.

  • A person aggrieved by a final license or permit decision must appeal within 30 days and identify the licensing or permitting standard they say was not met.
  • The amended text sets out who receives notice and who may offer supplemental evidence (evidence added to the record on appeal), and when.
  • The board may affirm, change, reverse, or send a decision back to the commissioner. It is not bound by the commissioner’s findings of fact or conclusions of law.
  • If the board changes or reverses a decision, the licensee or permittee must make project changes needed to comply. These may include deconstruction and site restoration.
  • The bill changes an existing appeal statute; the prior version was not supplied, so the exact differences from the law before LD 2210 cannot be verified.

What it means for you#

  • People appealing a permit decision: You must file within 30 days, identify the standard you believe was not met, and include information required by board rules. Any supplemental evidence you propose must be filed with the appeal.
  • People who commented on an application: The text defines an “interested person” as someone who submitted written comments on that application. Board staff must notify these people, the appellant, certain licensees or permittees, and others who asked to be notified.
  • Licensees, permittees, and certain interested parties: Within 30 days after notice of the appeal, they may submit proposed supplemental evidence addressing the appeal’s issues. The board chair may admit evidence only if it is relevant and material and the submitter meets a diligence or newly discovered evidence test.
  • Licensees or permittees affected by a board decision: If the board changes or reverses the commissioner’s decision, you must make changes needed to comply. The department may take enforcement action and impose penalties if you do not do so satisfactorily.
  • Other members of the public: The text does not create a new general right to appeal for everyone. It also does not itself issue or change a permit.

Money#

No cost estimate or appropriation is included in the supplied material. No publicly available information.

  • Department staff must submit evidence and analysis responding to issues raised in an appeal and to supplemental evidence admitted by the board. The material does not state the staffing or cost involved.
  • The text allows project changes that could include deconstruction and site restoration, but does not estimate those costs.

What is unclear#

  • The prior version of the amended statute was not supplied, so it is unclear which procedures are new and which were already law.
  • The text refers to information required by board rules, but those rules were not supplied.
  • The board may hold a hearing at its discretion; the text does not set criteria for when it will do so or give a deadline for deciding an appeal.
  • The supplied material does not state when the law takes effect.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the law is that clear filing, notice, and evidence rules can help people understand how to bring or respond to an appeal.
  • Requiring proposed evidence with the appeal, while allowing evidence that meets a diligence test, may help keep appeals focused on relevant material.
  • The board can review the record and change a decision when it concludes the decision should not stand.

Case against#

  • The 30-day filing deadline and requirement to include proposed supplemental evidence with the appeal may make it harder to present evidence that takes longer to gather.
  • The board chair decides whether proposed supplemental evidence meets the admission test, and the text does not give more detail about how that discretion will be applied.
  • A board decision changing or reversing a permit may require substantial project changes, potentially including deconstruction and site restoration. The text gives no estimate of those costs.