Electronic deer registration would be allowed

Summary#

LD 2217, “An Act Related to the Electronic Tagging of Deer,” would amend Maine’s fish and wildlife laws; it would not create a separate program or agency. It would require the Department of Inland Fisheries and Wildlife to allow electronic deer registration starting in 2027, with rules set by the commissioner. The stated goal is to enable electronic registration, but the bill failed and did not become law.

  • The department would have to allow electronic registration of deer. The bill does not say electronic registration would be the only option.
  • The commissioner’s rules could create exceptions to, or electronic ways to meet, requirements in the chapter for people registering deer under those rules.
  • The bill adjusts several deer-registration requirements—including presenting the animal at a registration station, time limits, and what must be presented—to allow for exceptions under the new rules.
  • The text still requires a securely attached, plainly visible tag before a deer is presented for registration, but allows the new rules to address compliance with chapter requirements.
  • The bill’s summary says it removes seal fees, but the supplied operative text still says agents collect fees. The materials do not clearly reconcile that difference.

What it means for you#

  • Deer hunters: If the bill had become law, you would have had an electronic registration option beginning in 2027. The bill does not explain how to register electronically or whether you would still need a physical tag.
  • Registration agents: The bill does not clearly establish whether their duties or fee collections would change; its summary and operative text appear to conflict.
  • Department and commissioner: The department would have to allow electronic registration, and the commissioner would have to adopt implementation rules.
  • Other hunters and the public: The bill’s stated electronic-registration change concerns deer. It does not directly change the registration rules for bear, moose, or wild turkey in the new provision.
  • Everyone: Because the bill failed, it made no changes to current law.

Money#

No publicly available information on the bill’s implementation costs.

  • The department would have to allow electronic deer registration and the commissioner would have to make rules, but no staffing or cost estimate is provided.
  • The bill summary says seal fees would be removed. However, the supplied bill text says agents collect $5 for bear, deer, and moose registrations and retain $2, and collect and retain $2 for wild turkey registrations. The materials do not show whether those fee rules would change.

What is unclear#

  • The supplied materials do not include the full current law, so it is not possible to verify exactly which existing requirements the bill would change.
  • The bill does not set out the electronic registration process, required information, deadlines, or any appeal or review process.
  • It does not say whether electronic registration would replace physical tags, or how hunters would meet the visible-tag requirement.
  • The bill gives the commissioner room to make exceptions to requirements, but does not specify which requirements would be excepted.
  • The summary’s claim about removing seal fees conflicts with the operative text on fee collection.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to give deer hunters an electronic way to register their deer.
  • A possible argument for the bill is that electronic registration could allow some registration requirements to be met electronically, if the commissioner’s rules provide for that.
  • Requiring the department to allow electronic registration by 2027 would set a start date for the option.

Case against#

  • The bill leaves many practical details to rules that are not included in the text, so hunters would not know from the bill what the electronic process would require.
  • The commissioner could make exceptions to requirements across the chapter, but the bill does not specify the limits or conditions for those exceptions.
  • It is unclear whether hunters would still need a physical tag, and how electronic registration would fit with the other requirements for presenting and keeping a deer.
  • The conflict over seal fees makes the bill’s effect on hunters and registration agents uncertain.

Votes

2 recorded votes on this bill, newest first.

  1. Division No. 1679509

    Defeated35 members voted

    Recede And Concur RC #916

    AGAINST · 23FOR · 12

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    23Against

    • Republican15
    • Democratic8

    12For

    • Democratic12
  2. Division No. 1677625

    Defeated30 members voted

    Accept Majority Ought To Pass As Amended Report RC #899

    AGAINST · 26FOR · 4

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    26Against

    • Republican14
    • Democratic12

    4For

    • Democratic4

    5 members were paired and sat out the vote.