Wildlife records privacy rules expanded

Summary#

LD-2236, “An Act Regarding Public Records Maintained by the Department of Inland Fisheries and Wildlife,” is enacted law. It repeals and replaces a section of Maine’s Title 12 and adds rules for license and permit records and snowmobile and ATV accident records. The text says accident reports are for statistical analysis and accident prevention; it gives no broader stated goal.

  • Personally identifiable information in department-held records is confidential, with exceptions for specified purposes and recipients.
  • The Department of Inland Fisheries and Wildlife may share non-identifying data and records. It may also release names and mailing addresses from licenses, permits and registrations.
  • Personally identifiable information must remain confidential until the relevant records have existed for 100 years.
  • The Bureau of Warden Service may release non-identifying accident data. It may release a snowmobile or ATV registration number to someone who signs an affidavit promising not to use it to identify or contact anyone, or share it.
  • Accident reports generally cannot be used as evidence in a civil or criminal trial arising from the accident, except to prove compliance with the reporting rules. The Game Warden Colonel may disclose specified details and provide an investigating officer’s report on written request.
  • The law makes certain knowing conduct a Class E crime, including specified failures to respond to an officer’s request after a reportable accident and misuse or sharing of a registration number obtained under the law.

What it means for you#

  • People with department records: The law limits disclosure of information it defines as personally identifiable. But names and mailing addresses in licenses, permits and registrations may be publicly disseminated. For commercial records, telephone numbers, email addresses and physical addresses are not treated as personally identifiable information under this section; that does not establish whether other laws protect them.
  • People requesting records or data: The department and the Bureau may charge reasonable fees. They are not subject to the usual fee limits in Maine’s public-records law for furnishing copies.
  • People involved in a snowmobile or ATV accident: The Game Warden Colonel may disclose the date, time and place, names and addresses of operators, owners, injured people and witnesses, and the investigating officer. A person who knowingly fails to give a correct name and address when asked, or fails to produce or return the vehicle when asked, commits a Class E crime.
  • General public: The Department and Bureau may share non-identifying data, but the law does not require them to release every record or dataset.

Money#

No cost estimate is provided in the available material.

  • The Department and Bureau may charge reasonable fees for records and data. The law gives no fee amounts or method for deciding what is reasonable.
  • The law requires no stated appropriation or staffing increase.

What is unclear#

  • The prior text of repealed section 10110 and the existing laws on accident reports were not supplied. The available material therefore does not show how much of the enacted wording changes current rules.
  • The law does not set out request procedures, response times, review or appeal rights, or how fee amounts will be set.
  • It does not explain how the 100-year confidentiality period applies to records already held.
  • “Commercial record” and “noncommercial record” are defined, but the law does not explain how borderline records should be classified.
  • The material does not give an effective date.

Case for#

  • The law could protect people’s identifying information while still allowing the Department and Bureau to share data that does not identify them.
  • The affidavit condition for sharing vehicle registration numbers sets a limit on how recipients may use or pass on those numbers.
  • Keeping accident reports mainly for analysis and prevention, while limiting their use in accident-related trials, could support those stated purposes.
  • The Game Warden Colonel’s authority to disclose specified accident details preserves some access to information about an accident.

Case against#

  • The law permits release of names and mailing addresses from licenses, permits and registrations, despite its broad confidentiality rule for personally identifiable information.
  • It allows fees without stating amounts or a fee-setting process, and exempts copy costs from the usual public-records fee limits.
  • The law makes some conduct a crime but does not explain the penalty amount in the supplied text.
  • The law does not describe how the Department or Bureau will handle requests, resolve disputes, or oversee use of information released under an affidavit.