DNA records access narrowed

Summary#

LD 2219, “An Act to Implement the Recommendations of the Right To Know Advisory Committee Concerning Certain Existing Public Records Exceptions,” amends existing Maine laws; it does not create a new agency or program. It changes rules about access to, disclosure of, and confidentiality of records in several areas. Its stated goal is to carry out the Advisory Committee’s recommendations.

  • It revises who may receive DNA records and clarifies that a person charged after a DNA search is limited to their own records and other records they are entitled to under the Maine Rules of Evidence.
  • It updates confidentiality and disclosure wording for employer drug-test information, vehicle records, voter-registration information and accident reports.
  • It expressly treats certain accident-report data and records shared with agencies investigating financial exploitation as confidential or not public records.
  • It protects physicians’ personal residence addresses, telephone numbers, email addresses and application health information, subject to stated exceptions.
  • It allows a financial-services administrator to disclose otherwise confidential information to government representatives who promise to keep it confidential, or when the administrator finds disclosure reasonably necessary to protect the public.

What it means for you#

  • People whose DNA records are involved: The listed criminal justice and law-enforcement agencies, the FBI, and medical examiners or coroners may receive DNA records for the purposes stated in the law. A person charged after a search may receive only their own records and other records they are entitled to under the Maine Rules of Evidence.
  • Employees and job applicants: Employer-held information from drug testing remains confidential unless the person consents or an exception applies. Exceptions include disclosure required or permitted by law, and use in a related grievance, hearing or civil action.
  • Vehicle owners and accident-report requesters: The Secretary of State may make nongovernment vehicle records confidential for a specific period, after a written request from an appropriate criminal justice official and a showing that it is in the public-safety interest. The period cannot go past the current registration’s expiry. Personally identifying accident-report data are confidential and not public records. A plate number may be disclosed only to someone who provides an affidavit promising not to use it to identify or contact someone, or disclose it to another person. Nonpersonally identifying accident data are not confidential; the cost of copies is not subject to the general fee limits stated in law.
  • Physicians and applicants: Personal residence addresses, telephone numbers and email addresses, as well as personal health information submitted with an application, are confidential, subject to exceptions. A residence address and phone number are not confidential if provided as the public contact address. The board must redact confidential information before making a record available.
  • Brokers, investment advisers and people seeking help with suspected financial exploitation: They must provide relevant records to the Department of Health and Human Services or law enforcement as part of a referral or investigation. The records made available are confidential. The administrator’s existing authority to examine firms’ books and records is not limited.
  • Voters: The Secretary of State may not disclose information collected under the specified motor-vehicle law, except for listed federal-law purposes. A willful violation can bring a civil fine of up to $500.

Money#

No cost estimate or fiscal note is included in the supplied material. No publicly available information.

  • The law does not state a public spending amount, staffing requirement or new fee.
  • Accident-report copy costs are not subject to the general fee limits identified in the law; the amount charged is not stated.

What is unclear#

  • The supplied material does not include the earlier versions of the amended laws. It is therefore not possible to verify how much of each rule is new, rather than wording carried forward or clarified.
  • It does not set a process, timeline or appeal route for the Secretary of State’s decision to make vehicle records confidential.
  • It does not explain how the financial-services administrator will decide when disclosure is reasonably necessary for the public’s protection, or how that decision is reviewed.
  • It does not state what accident-data copy charges will be or how they will be calculated.
  • The bill is enacted, but the supplied material does not state when each change takes effect.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that clearer rules about which records are confidential and who may receive them can help protect personal information.
  • The bill preserves specified channels for law enforcement, medical examiners, regulators and agencies responding to suspected financial exploitation to obtain information.
  • It makes clear that some information remains outside public-record access while allowing nonpersonally identifying accident data to be disclosed.

Case against#

  • Making records expressly confidential or not public can reduce what the public can obtain, including personally identifying accident data and records shared in financial-exploitation investigations.
  • The bill gives the administrator discretion to disclose confidential information when it considers disclosure reasonably necessary for public protection, without setting criteria or a review process in the supplied text.
  • Accident-report copy costs are exempt from the stated general fee limits, but the bill does not say what those costs may be.