Oral-fluid testing would expand alcohol and drug testing

Summary#

LD 2237, “An Act Permitting the Use of Oral Fluid Testing in Determining the Intoxication of Drivers, Aircraft Operators and Hunters,” would amend Maine laws covering aircraft, hunting and recreational vehicles, motor vehicles, and evidence in court. It would add oral fluid (saliva) to the types of samples that may be used for alcohol or drug testing; its stated goal is to permit that use. The bill failed, so it did not change the law.

  • It would add oral fluid testing to chemical-test rules for motor-vehicle operators, aircraft operators, hunters, and people operating or attempting to operate watercraft, snowmobiles, and ATVs.
  • It would extend existing test-collection and laboratory rules to oral fluid, including certification standards set by the Department of Health and Human Services (DHHS) and DHHS approval of collection equipment.
  • It would make oral-fluid test results eligible for admission in court under the bill’s evidence rules. In some cases, a signed certificate would count as initial evidence of its contents unless the defendant gives 10 days’ written notice requesting a qualified witness.
  • It would let a drug recognition expert select a blood, urine, or oral-fluid test to confirm suspected drug use. In an aircraft accident resulting in a death, a law enforcement officer would choose the type of test.
  • It would also address oral-fluid test results kept by hospitals or other medical facilities: those results could be admitted in certain vehicle-operation cases if relevant and reliable, and the court finds probable cause.

What it means for you#

  • People driving, flying, hunting, or operating recreational vehicles: Where the law requires a chemical test after probable cause, oral fluid would become another listed way to test. The bill does not require everyone to take an oral-fluid test or set out a general process for choosing among test types.
  • Law enforcement: Officers could collect oral-fluid samples under the applicable rules. The bill does not create a general intake or review process.
  • DHHS and testing laboratories: DHHS would set certification standards for oral-fluid analysis and approve collection equipment. Laboratories would have to meet the bill’s stated qualification rules to conduct covered analyses.
  • Defendants in court: Oral-fluid results could be used as evidence under the rules the bill extends. A certificate could count as initial evidence of certain facts, subject to the 10-day written-notice procedure for requesting testimony.
  • Everyone: Because the bill failed, these changes did not take effect.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill contains no appropriation or cost estimate.
  • It assigns DHHS certification and equipment-approval functions for oral-fluid testing, but does not say how much staff time or money those functions would require.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not define “oral fluid” or set out detailed collection, testing, or interpretation procedures. It relies on DHHS standards and equipment approval.
  • Except in the aircraft-fatality and drug-recognition-expert provisions, the bill does not clearly state who chooses the test type or how that choice is made.
  • The bill does not provide a start date. It failed, so there is no start date in effect.
  • The current parent Acts and full current-law text were not supplied. The bill shows the proposed wording changes, but I could not verify every change against the full law in force.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that adding oral fluid would give authorities and testing laboratories another option when testing for alcohol or drugs.
  • The bill uses existing certification, equipment-approval, and court-evidence rules rather than creating a separate testing system.
  • Allowing a drug recognition expert to select an oral-fluid test could provide another way to confirm suspected drug use.

Case against#

  • The bill would expand the testing options within laws that require a test after probable cause. The bill does not explain in most cases how officials would choose among the available sample types.
  • Oral-fluid testing details are left largely to DHHS standards and equipment approval. The bill itself does not spell out procedures for collection or explain how results should be interpreted.
  • Oral-fluid results could be used as evidence, including through certificates that count as initial evidence unless the defendant follows the notice procedure. A concern is that the bill does not explain how this evidence rule would work in practice for oral-fluid tests.