Rulemaking to cut residential construction costs

Summary#

LD 2224, An Act to Reduce Certain Costs Associated with Residential Construction, is an enacted Maine law. It changes the Technical Building Codes and Standards Board’s membership and requires rulemaking, a standards update, studies and reports. Its stated goal is to reduce some residential construction costs; the law does not guarantee savings.

  • The Technical Building Codes and Standards Board grows from 12 to 13 members by adding a voting affordable-housing expert appointed by the Governor. The new member must have at least five years’ experience in, and be employed in, the field they represent.
  • By September 1, 2026, the board must start rulemaking aimed at removing code requirements for smoke and draft protection assemblies on elevator hoistway doors and two-way emergency video communication systems in elevators. The law requires the rulemaking, not that those requirements be removed immediately.
  • The Office of the State Fire Marshal must adopt the 2025 edition of the National Fire Protection Association’s fire alarm and signaling code.
  • The State Fire Marshal’s office must convene a working group to study residential sprinkler costs and safety, and elevator costs, accessibility and safety. It must provide staff and send the group’s findings and recommendations to the Legislature by January 15, 2027.
  • The Office of Professional and Occupational Regulation must report by January 15, 2027, on the status of its rulemaking for the elevator and tramway safety program.

What it means for you#

  • Home builders and developers: The law does not itself remove the elevator requirements or change residential sprinkler requirements. Rulemaking and a study may lead to later changes, but the bill does not guarantee them.
  • Residents and people who need accessible buildings: The working group must examine safety and accessibility effects of allowing limited use, limited application elevators in buildings under four stories. It may recommend code changes if its members consider that appropriate. The law does not itself allow these elevators.
  • People in buildings with elevators: The board must start rulemaking aimed at removing the two specified elevator requirements. The final rules and their effects are not set out in the law.
  • The public: The law does not create a new public benefit, tax, fee or fine. It does not directly change who must install sprinklers.
  • State officials: The board, the State Fire Marshal’s office and the professional-regulation office must carry out the rulemaking, study, standards update and reports described above.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The State Fire Marshal’s office must provide staff for the working group, but no staffing level or cost is stated.
  • The law requires rulemaking, adoption of an updated fire alarm code, studies and reports, but gives no cost estimate or specific funding amount.
  • Lower construction costs are a stated goal, not a guaranteed saving.

What is unclear#

  • The law does not set out the outcome of the elevator rulemaking or say when any resulting changes would take effect.
  • It does not specify how the working group will measure sprinkler costs, fire losses, safety effects or accessibility effects.
  • It does not specify what “innovative incentives” for reducing sprinkler costs might be or whether any incentive will be adopted.
  • The law does not state how the 2025 fire alarm code differs from the version it replaces or what changes that update will require.
  • No effective date or implementation schedule is given for the standards update or the new board membership.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the law is that it asks officials to examine construction costs before making broader changes to sprinkler and elevator rules.
  • The working group must consider both costs and safety, as well as accessibility for limited use elevators.
  • Adding an affordable-housing expert to the building-code board may give that perspective a formal place in the board’s decisions.
  • Updating the fire alarm code while reviewing other requirements may help officials consider cost and safety issues across more than one part of building standards.

Case against#

  • One concern is that rulemaking aimed at removing elevator protections could reduce safety protections; the law does not specify a safety analysis or other conditions for those changes.
  • Studying sprinkler costs may not reduce them: the law requires recommendations, but does not require the government to adopt them or provide financial help.
  • The law does not state how the working group will balance lower costs against fire safety or accessibility.
  • The required staff work, rulemaking and code update may cost money, but the law provides no estimate.

Votes

The recorded vote on this bill, member by member.

  1. Division No. 1676124

    Passed33 members voted

    Accept Majority Ought To Pass As Amended Report RC #846

    FOR · 19AGAINST · 14

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    19For

    • Democratic18
    • Republican1

    14Against

    • Republican14

    2 members were paired and sat out the vote.