Planning bill tightens timelines, livestock rules

Summary#

The Planning Amendment and City of Winnipeg Charter Amendment Act amends Manitoba’s Planning Act and The City of Winnipeg Charter. Its stated goal is to clarify planning-application and appeal timelines and procedures, while making other changes to regional planning, subdivisions and livestock operations.

  • The Municipal Board must meet several new deadlines, including holding specified hearings within 120 days and making orders within 60 days after hearings.
  • For certain by-law objections, the Board must review the existing records and recommend what to do; the council must consider its recommendations before proceeding. For other specified objections, the Board must hold a hearing and make a final order that the council must follow.
  • Planning regions lose the power to acquire land by expropriation. Adoption or amendment of a regional planning by-law will no longer affect pending applications.
  • Certain changes to livestock operations can be treated as authorized without a new conditional-use approval, if they meet the bill’s requirements, including a limit of no more than a 15% increase in animal units.
  • The bill expands which subdivisions count as minor and changes how some applications to change conditions for large-scale livestock operations are handled.
  • The bill removes provisions for costs over unreasonable delay before the Municipal Board and compensation for delays in issuing development permits.

What it means for you#

  • People objecting to planning by-laws: For some objections, the Board reviews the records without holding a hearing or receiving new evidence. For other specified objections, it holds a hearing, but only people entitled to notice may make submissions. The Board’s order in that hearing process is final, with no appeal under these provisions.
  • Municipalities and Winnipeg council: They must meet new referral and notice requirements and consider Board recommendations before taking specified steps. Where the Board makes a binding order, they cannot proceed unless it confirms the by-law or they comply with its direction.
  • Applicants and property owners: Pending applications are protected from the effect of a newly adopted or amended regional planning by-law. Some qualifying subdivisions, including ones involving a party wall agreement, may use the minor-subdivision process. The bill does not set out a general application or approval process for every planning matter.
  • Livestock operators: A qualifying change to an existing livestock building—or, for supply-managed operations, to the intensity of use of the supply-managed part—may be treated as authorized if a zoning memorandum is obtained and the change increases animal units by no more than 15%. For large operations, some changes to conditions are handled under a different process than changes involving a new operation, livestock category or increased animal units.
  • People seeking compensation for delay: The bill repeals the identified provisions for costs over unreasonable delay before the Board and compensation for delays in development permits.

Money#

No cost estimate is provided in the supplied material.

  • The Municipal Board must do reviews and hearings within new deadlines; the materials give no estimate of the related staffing or operating costs.
  • The bill removes specified routes to costs for unreasonable delay and compensation for delayed development permits. The materials do not estimate the financial effect on governments or affected applicants.

What is unclear#

  • “Sufficient objections” is not defined in the supplied bill text. The supplied materials do not show how the threshold is decided.
  • The bill does not explain how many staff or resources the Municipal Board will need to meet the new deadlines.
  • The bill does not provide a detailed process for the required zoning memorandum for an authorized livestock change.
  • The Planning Act and City of Winnipeg Charter as currently in force were not supplied, so the full extent of changes to existing rules could not be checked against their current text.
  • The bill says it comes into force on royal assent, but the supplied text gives no assent date.

Case for#

  • Faster, stated deadlines could make the timing of Board reviews and hearings more predictable.
  • Reviewing existing records for some objections may give the Board a role without repeating a hearing or accepting new evidence.
  • Requiring councils to consider recommendations, or comply with binding orders in specified cases, gives the Board a clear role when objections arise.
  • The livestock provisions set conditions for certain changes that might otherwise require a new approval, including a limit on the increase in animal units.

Case against#

  • A Board order in the hearing process is final and cannot be appealed under these provisions, concentrating decision-making power in the Board.
  • For record-based reviews, the Board cannot hold a hearing or receive new evidence. That may limit the information it can consider.
  • Removing delay-related costs and permit-delay compensation takes away the specified routes to those payments, without setting out a replacement.
  • The bill sets deadlines but does not provide cost estimates or explain how the Board will meet them.