Summary#
The Public Schools Amendment and Manitoba School Boards Association Amendment Act amends The Public Schools Act, The Education Administration Act and The Manitoba School Boards Association Act. Its stated goals include addressing bullying, setting superintendent requirements and allowing certain organizations to join the Manitoba School Boards Association. The current Acts were not supplied, so the full extent of the changes compared with current law could not be verified.
- Bullying includes conduct that creates, or should be known to create, a negative or unsafe school environment for a person or a group, based on a characteristic listed in The Human Rights Code. The bill also recognizes expression made with AI assistance as a possible form of bullying.
- School codes of conduct must address the appropriate use of AI. The code continues to apply to students, but no longer applies to staff; it must describe interventions for violations and an appeal process for decisions about those interventions.
- School boards must appoint a superintendent who meets specified teaching and administrative experience requirements, set and pay the superintendent’s remuneration, and notify the minister of the appointment and qualifications within 10 days.
- The superintendent’s listed duties include administering education programs, carrying out board policies, and managing and supervising staff unless the board directs otherwise. If the board keeps hiring authority, it must give the superintendent a chance to recommend candidates before filling vacancies.
- Indigenous educational organizations and some other organizations may apply to join the Manitoba School Boards Association. The association’s executive may approve applications if the bill’s conditions are met. Part 2 requires proclamation to come into force.
What it means for you#
- Students: Their school’s code of conduct must address appropriate AI use. The code must also set out interventions for non-compliance and a process to appeal decisions about those interventions.
- School staff: The school code of conduct would no longer apply to staff. The superintendent would manage and supervise staff unless the school board directs otherwise.
- School boards: Boards must appoint a superintendent who meets the bill’s qualifications and pay that person. If a board does not delegate hiring authority, it must give the superintendent an opportunity to make recommendations before filling a vacancy.
- Indigenous educational organizations and other organizations: Eligible organizations may apply for association membership; approval is not automatic. Approved organizations may name up to nine representatives and change those representatives.
- General public: The bill does not create a new school service or make school staff subject to the student code of conduct.
Money#
The bill requires school boards to pay a superintendent, but the available material gives no cost estimate.
- The bill also requires boards to provide notice of appointments and, in some cases, an opportunity for superintendent hiring recommendations. No cost estimate is provided for these duties.
- Applicants approved for association membership must pay a prescribed fee. The fee amount is not included in the bill text supplied.
- No publicly available information on the bill’s total cost is included in the supplied material.
What is unclear#
- The supplied text leaves the date of royal assent blank. Part 1 takes effect on royal assent; Part 2 takes effect on a date set by proclamation.
- The current versions of the amended Acts were not supplied, so it is not possible to verify which provisions are new and which may already exist.
- The bill does not set a salary or funding source for superintendents.
- The bill does not state the prescribed association membership fee or all membership criteria; some criteria may be set in the association’s by-laws.
- It is not clear from the supplied text what participation or voting rights designated representatives would have under the association’s current rules.
- The bill refers to characteristics listed in The Human Rights Code but does not list them here.
Case for#
- The bill appears intended to address bullying that targets groups, not only individuals, and to recognize that AI-assisted expression can be involved.
- Requiring school codes to address AI use could give students clearer rules about its use at school.
- Requiring relevant teaching and administrative experience for superintendents could help ensure they have experience with education and school operations.
- Allowing eligible Indigenous educational organizations and other organizations to join could give them a route to participate in the Manitoba School Boards Association.
Case against#
- The bill does not explain how schools should identify or respond to conduct that creates a negative or unsafe environment for a group.
- Boards must pay a superintendent, but the bill provides no cost estimate or funding source.
- Association membership approval is discretionary, and some conditions depend on the executive’s opinion or the association’s by-laws.
- The bill does not explain how the association’s existing rules would apply to designated representatives or how much influence they would have.