Summary#
Bill 42, The Motor Vehicle Statutes Amendment Act, would amend The Drivers and Vehicles Act, The Highway Traffic Act and The Manitoba Public Insurance Corporation Act, and make related changes to two other Acts. Its stated goal is to change rules for driver training schools, farm-truck use and counselling-cost reimbursement, among other vehicle-related rules. It would take effect only on a day set by proclamation; no start date is given.
- Driver training schools with permits would have to use written contracts for prescribed courses, provide public information, avoid false or misleading advertising, and file annual reports. Students in those courses would have a limited right to cancel and receive a refund.
- The registrar would have to keep a public online registry of permit holders, with its contents set by regulation.
- A farm truck could be used to carry passengers. A farm truck under 5,500 kg registered gross weight could also carry property for the personal use of the owner, a family member or an employee, subject to limits on commercial use.
- People who are not accident victims could be entitled to reimbursement for counselling expenses in specified circumstances, subject to regulations. The Manitoba Public Insurance Corporation (MPI) could pay some expenses directly to the provider.
- The definition of “antique motor vehicle” would be set by regulation. Other changes update vehicle-registration terms and make related corrections.
What it means for you#
- Driver training students: For courses in vehicle classes set by regulation, you would have to receive a written contract. You could cancel by written notice on or before the earlier of seven days after signing or the start of instruction. You would have to return goods received, and the school would have to repay money already paid as soon as practicable, in the manner set by regulation.
- Driver training schools: If you hold a permit and teach a prescribed class, you would have to publish specified information, including courses, fees and your refund policy; file annual financial statements and course information; and provide other information the registrar requests. The details and format are partly left to regulations or the registrar.
- Farm truck owners and users: The bill would allow the listed uses, including carrying passengers. The personal-property use is limited to trucks under 5,500 kg and is not for business or other commercial purposes, except for certain farming operations. The bill text does not give a general permission to use any truck for any purpose.
- People affected by serious accidents: A family member of a victim who suffered serious injury or died, or a person who witnessed an accident or its aftermath resulting in serious injury or death, would be entitled to counselling-cost reimbursement, subject to regulations. Someone who pays such an expense for another person would also be entitled to reimbursement.
- General public: The bill does not create a new agency or directly change vehicle taxes, fees, or fines. It changes rules and duties handled by existing government bodies and MPI.
Money#
No publicly available information.
- The bill requires annual reports from affected driver training schools and a public registry maintained by the registrar, but gives no cost estimate or staffing figure.
- The bill provides for reimbursement of counselling expenses, but the materials give no estimate of how much MPI would pay.
- The bill does not set a new fee or tax.
What is unclear#
- The regulations that would define an antique motor vehicle and set the covered course classes, contract terms, cancellation procedure, school disclosures and registry contents are not supplied.
- The counselling reimbursement rules are “subject to the regulations,” but the regulations and any limits or approval process are not supplied. The bill does not set a dollar limit or timeline for reimbursement.
- The text changes “shall” to “may” in an existing MPI provision, but the existing subsection is not supplied. The explanatory note says this concerns paying a victim in instalments at the victim’s request; the full effect cannot be checked against the supplied text.
- The current versions of the amended Acts are not supplied, so the exact changes from current law cannot be verified. The explanatory note describes the intended changes, but the bill also replaces or updates existing wording.
- The bill does not set a start date; it leaves that to proclamation.
Case for#
- A written contract, a cancellation right and required public information could give students clearer terms before driver training begins.
- Annual reporting and a public registry could make information about permitted schools easier to find.
- Allowing specified passenger and personal-property uses could give farm truck owners more flexibility while retaining limits on commercial use.
- Counselling reimbursement could extend help to some family members, witnesses and people who pay counselling expenses for them.
Case against#
- Important details for students, schools and counselling claims are left to regulations or later decisions by the registrar, so the protections and costs are not fully clear from the bill.
- Annual financial reporting and public disclosures would add duties for driver training schools; the bill gives no estimate of the compliance cost.
- The bill gives MPI discretion to pay directly to a provider and changes an existing “shall” to “may.” Without the existing subsection, the full effect on payment obligations is unclear.
- The bill does not state how much counselling reimbursement would cost or whether the new entitlement would have limits beyond those set in regulations.