Mutual insurers may convert holding companies

Summary#

HB 1616, “Mutual Insurance Holding Companies – Conversion to Mutual Insurers,” amends Maryland’s Insurance Article and adds a new section. It allows an eligible mutual insurance holding company system to convert into a mutual insurer if it adopts a plan and receives approval. The stated goal is to authorize that kind of conversion.

  • Only a holding company that directly or indirectly owns all the stock of a reorganized stock insurer may use this conversion route.
  • The plan must be approved by a majority of the boards of the holding company and any intermediate stock holding company, and by at least 75% of holding-company members who vote.
  • The plan must preserve existing policies, make current holding-company membership interests nontransferable interests in the new mutual insurer, and make future policyholders members.
  • The plan must retire the insurer’s and any intermediate holding company’s shares, dissolve those holding companies, and provide for surplus funds reasonably adequate to protect policyholders.
  • The Insurance Commissioner must review the plan for legal compliance and whether it is equitable to holding-company members and insurer policyholders. The Commissioner may impose conditions, hold a hearing, and hire an expert at the holding company’s expense.
  • The law took effect October 1, 2026. It adds a mutual-insurer conversion option; the amended text also continues to allow conversion to a stock insurer under existing law.

What it means for you#

  • Policyholders: If their insurer’s holding company converts, their policies must remain in effect, though they may be endorsed (changed by an attached document). Future policyholders of the converted insurer become members. The bill does not require policyholders to apply for conversion.
  • Members of a holding company: Their membership interests become nontransferable interests in the converted mutual insurer if a conversion occurs. Members vote on the plan; approval requires at least 75% of those who vote.
  • Eligible insurers and holding companies: They may use the new conversion route, but must prepare the required plan and documents and obtain approval. Conversion is not required.
  • The Insurance Commissioner: Must assess the plan under the bill’s standards and may set additional conditions or arrange a hearing. The Commissioner may hire an outside qualified expert, with the company paying the expert’s cost.
  • Other insurers or the public: The bill does not directly change insurance coverage, premiums, or claims rules.

Money#

No cost estimate is provided in the available material.

  • The bill does not provide an appropriation or a fee or tax.
  • A holding company must pay for an outside expert if the Commissioner chooses to hire one. The bill gives no cost estimate.
  • Companies seeking conversion will have to prepare a five-year operating plan and other required materials; the bill does not estimate those costs.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not define “equitable” or what surplus is “reasonably adequate” to protect policyholders.
  • It does not set a detailed review process or timeline beyond requiring submission at least 60 days before the planned effective date and allowing approval after 60 days if the Commissioner has not disapproved the complete submission.
  • It does not specify how the Commissioner must set additional conditions, or when a hearing would be necessary.
  • The supplied text does not include the full current Insurance Article, so other existing rules or how this route interacts with them could not be verified.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that it gives eligible insurance systems another legal structure to choose, rather than limiting them to the existing stock-insurer conversion route.
  • The plan must keep existing policies in effect and provide for surplus reasonably adequate for policyholder security.
  • Member and regulator approval requirements, along with a five-year operating plan, provide checks before a conversion takes effect.

Case against#

  • The bill leaves key standards— including “equitable” treatment and adequate surplus—undefined, so the Commissioner’s judgment will matter greatly.
  • Automatic approval after 60 days may allow a plan to proceed without a written approval notice if the Commissioner has not disapproved it and all required information has been submitted.
  • A conversion changes the company structure and members’ interests, but the bill does not spell out how those changes affect members’ practical rights after conversion.

Votes

The recorded vote on this bill, member by member.

  1. Division No. 1672356

    Passed136 members voted

    Third Reading Passed

    FOR · 136

    136For

    • Democratic98
    • Republican38

    0Against

    5 members were paired and sat out the vote.